Mugabe's state of emergency
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-07-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
L Jameson reports from Zimbabwe the same week that De Klerk lifted the state of emergency in South Africa (excluding Natal), the government of "socialist" Zimbabwe invoked emergency powers a legacy of the Smith regime) to outlaw a wave of civil service strikes that have swept the country since late May.
Since the March general election, discontent has been growing amongst government employees. In April the nurses struck against poor pay and conditions and were briefly joined by hospital doctors.
The recent, unprecedented strike wave was initiated by teachers who walked out on 24 May to protest against a pay review which massively increased differentials between graduates and non-graduates (only 4% of teachers are graduates), and threats to take away teachers' leave entitlement without compensation.
The tame, pro-government teachers' union, ZIMTA, officially condemned the action and ended up supporting a government call 1or a return to work. The Zimbabwe Teachers Union, supposedly a "left wing" split from ZIMTA, condemned the strike as a "ZIMTA mess" , and had nothing to do with it. Although local ZIMTA militants participated in the strike it was weakened from the start by the lack of any clear leadership.
The strike's objectives remained unclear, and strikers in different areas employed different tactics. No attempt was made to picket schools which stayed open.
On 5 June the government took action and announced that any teacher who didn't return the next day could consider themselves dismissed. It was further announced that in terms of the emergency powers (introduced by Smith at the time of UDI in November 1965) all civil service strikes were illegal and any assembly of more than three teachers was unlawful.
Children were encouraged to inform on any teacher who didn't teach properly and any Zimbabweans with 5 'O'-levels were urged to report to the Ministry of Education and enrol as replacement teachers for those who had been sacked.
The announcement embraced all civil service strikes because, by early June, the teachers' example had been followed by taxmen, the Salaried Staffs Bureau and employees of the Central Mechanical Engineering Department. Furthermore, artisans at the Zimbabwe Iron and Steel company, labourers at Mazowe truit plantations, bank workers and even the police were either on strike or rumoured to be contemplating strike action..
The announcement that teachers" demonstrations were unlawful gave the green light to the police. Marchers in Harare and Bulawayo were charged and teargassed. In Bulawayo, children who refused to be taught by replacement teachers marched to the regional education office and were teargassed.
Police were called into a Bulawayo school when children refused to attend lessons, the children were chased across a playing field and batoned At the time of writing (10 June), it is difficult to judge the situation nationally because of'a virtual news blackout, Extrapolating from the situation in Bulawayo, with which I am familiar, it seems that many teachers have been forced back to work. Rumours that the Central Intelligence Organisation are collecting strikers' addresses will no doubt intimidate many more back into the classroom, especially as they are receiving no support or guidance from their union.
The SSB, Inland Revenue and CMED appear still to be on strike and there is a possibility of a police strike sometime in June.
Overall, though, the strike wave appears to be subsiding. However bleak the immediate prospects for Zimbabwean trade unionists may be, it is possible that the recent militancy will inject life into Zimbabwe's usually quiescent union movement. It seems possible that many people, cynical about the political system (turnout in the election was only just over 40% - very low for Zimbabwe), may be turning to trade unionism as an alternative voice for their discontent. If that's true, then Zimbabwean polities could be on the threshold of a new period of confrontation between ZANU(PF) and a growing army of opponents.
Scan page 3
Scargill arrested at Orgreave 1984. Photo: John Harris From front page And who, after all, is it who is in pursuit of Scargill? Who cracks the whip for the media dog-pack? Who cries for "morality in public life" and accuses Scargill of financial chicanery?!
None other than that embodiment of bloated and degenerate capitalism, Robert Maxwell.
No less an authority than a House of Commons committee condemned Maxwell for his own financial dealings and pronounced him unfit to manage any public company. That oafish megalomaniac is not morally fit to carry Arthur Scargill's briefcase.
On the question of Stalinism, Maxwell is worse than Scargill. Scargill combines a serious commitment to the working class interest in the class struggle in Britain with a blinkered old-fashioned Stalinism, with politics which are increasingly difficult to understand now that Stalinism has disintegrated before our, and Arthur Scargill's, eyes in Eastern Europe and the USSR.
Scargill remains a Stalinist, still willing to go to the USSR — as he did recently - as a guest of the oificial police-state miners' "union" from which the members are flowing in hundreds of thousands now that, for the first time in over half a century, they have the chance. Arthur Scargill's politics here testify to a tragic confusion. But evidently they are the politics of a would-be honest working-class socialist. If they are remarkable it is because Scargill now embodies a once numerically very strong tradition, Stalinist would-be revolutionary socialism, which is now almost vanished into the mists of history. Scargill does and says what he does about the Stalinist states because he believes in it.
And why did Robert Maxwell publish libraries of obscenely lying propaganda for little Stalins like Brezhnev, Ceausescu, Husak, Jaruzelski and others? Why has his publishing house - which sacks trade unionists, as he did with the workers at Pergamon Press in Oxford who are still in dispute - been a main outlet for Stalinist propaganda in the West?
Because Maxwell believes in it? No, because he made millions from mob_first, everything cond.
And rightly so, though serious issues are raised now about the running of the union. Over £1 million was made available by the USSR. It was not, could not, be made available by the miners' union there. There was no union. In 1985 the miners in the USSR had literally no rights inside the state-run "union" but to do what the bureaucrats decided they would do.
That money was a forced levy on. the Russian miners, even if one they willingly accepted - and it is no wonder some of them bitterly ask for an account of it from their own "union" leaders and from Arthur Scargill. If it was available, it is strange indeed that it was not used to alleviate the hardships of the strike and its aftermath.
Left to themselves, without the howling of the press, left-wing miners would probably have pointed questions to put to Arthur Scargill. Some will go on to ask the important basic question about the so-called International Miners" Organisation, the question SO raised five years ago: what the hell was a genuine workers' organisation like the NUM doing, splitting from most other miners' unions internationally and shacking up with the police-state "unions" of Eastern Europe and the USSR?
As a paper which has given unstinting and unflinching support to the NUM in its great battles against our common capitalist enemy, we believe we have a right to raise these questions, and to suggest to militant miners that they too should raise them.
But right now the first task is to say and repeat to the capitalist media and their Kinnockite outriders: hands off the NUM! Hands off Arthur Scargill!
about the Calcutt Report.
For years people have been warning the British press that unless it clears up its act, statutory controls would come in, as sure as eggs is eggs.
Calcutt stops just short of statutory controls but contains the clear warning that this is the very last chance: just one example of backsliding by a single paper and in comes a statutory Press Complaints Tribunal. "And a good thing too. Serve the bastards right, " I hear at least some of you saying. Most people despise the British press (especially tabloids) and few tears would be shed at the thought of the Sun, the Daily Star, the News of the World, etc being forced to abide by laws enforcing some modicum of respect for privacy, accurate reporting and common decency.
So what's wrong with Calcutt's proposal for a tougher body, independent of the newspaper industry, to replace the present Press Council, backed up by the threat of legislation? Jake Ecclestone of the NUJ summed it up quite well: "The present government has demonstrated how it is prepared to abuse its powers of appointment in the case of the Board of Governors of the BBC. The greatest threat to press freedom in Britain today comes from government interference and the concentration of ownership. The Calcutt Commission has encouraged the one and entirely ignored the other.' Unfortunately, Mr Ecclestone's view is not typical of either public opinion or the mainstream of the British labour movement. Disgust the repeated excesses of the tabloids and revulsion at the blatant sexism and thinly-disguised racism of much that appears in the Sun (especially) has made most decent people less concerned about press reedom than about press standards. Nowhere is this more the case than in the Labour Party and Roy Hattersley is almost certainly more representative of mainstream Labour opinion when he says about
----- pull-quotes -----
DITOR Calcutt freedom i is very tempting to gloat