All you wanted to know about ng, nitrates
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-06-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Faced with a plethora of F environmental problems, with an overwhelming quantity of facts and claims and counterclaims, the layperson can be forgiven for being confused.
There is therefore a ready market for popular books, and these have not been slow in coming forward. have been looking at what's on offer and I have to report that there are some good and some not so good.
Poisoners of the seas is a highly inforinative book, full of data on sea pollution by oil, sewage, toxic and radioactive chemicals. Inevitably, technical terms and acronyms litter the text, but are fully explained.
It is not a dry-as-dust academic tome. Blow-by-blow accounts of famous pollution disasters put the statistics into a more real context. These include:
• the wreck of the Torrey Canyon in 1967 which brought 100,000 tonnes of crude oil to the beaches of Cornwall and Brittany;
• the poisoning by dumped mercury waste of the fishing community of Minamata, Japan, in the '50s and '60s;
• the saga of radioactive leaks from Sellafield, exposed by Greenpeace.
The pressures on the seas from our modern industrial society are described, as are the consequences when corners are cut, errors made or deliberate decisions to pollute taken. useful companion to anyone speaking on pollution of he seas or otherwise seeking to alert others to the threats to the health of the liquid covering of our planet.
On the other hand, Nitrates the threat to food and water',? by Nigel Dudley, about an important environmental pollutant, is marred by inaccuracies and an alarmist tone, bordering on the scaremongering.
It was particularly depressing to read in the preface that nitrates in farm manure are an important source of air pollution and "thus' of acid rain! Later, this was "clarified" so that ammonia released from the manure was the culprit.
This is the complete opposite of the truth which is that ammonia is an alkaline gas and thus neutralises acids. Nor does ammonia oxidise sulphur dioxide to the more damaging trioxide, as Dudley claims. He also names nitrous oxide, - the laughing gas of past dental practice, as an important source of acid rain!
I was unable to locate details of the nitrate contribution to the greenhouse effect promised in the blurb.
An eighth of the book tells us of the many claims for health damage from nitrates but has to admit to a complete lack of firm evidence. Nitrates and nitrites added to meat products are claimed to form carcinogenic nitrosamines in the body which lead to stomach cancer.
However, present levels are tar lower than in the salt-cured meats of the past, thanks to refrigeration, and in any case stomach cancer levels are falling. You are far more likely to get introsamines from smoking (including other people's) than from food.
High nitrite levels in water are said to threaten babies with the condition methaemoglobinaemia ("blue baby" syndrome), which harms the ability of the blood to carry oxygen. But, far from this being a growing problem with the increased use of fertilisers, there have only ever been 14 cases in Britain (2000 worldwide since 1945), the last nearly 20 years ago.
Dudley accusingly quotes the Fertiliser Manufacturers Association as saying that there is no evidence to link nitrates with cancer and that unfertilised soil can sometimes Telease as much nitrate as treated soil. But these statements are true! Indeed, organic farming can sometimes result in more nitrate pollution.
Ten hey Dudley is on stronger ground when he describes the effects of nitrate run-off on freshwater and sea eco-systems: the overgrowth of algae cutting out sunlight and killing other plant life and hence animal life in the rivers; the poisonous algal blooms ithat sometimes occur in reservoirs and in the North and Baltic seas.
His strategy for reducing nitrate exposure wevld unfortunately rule out many interesting and otherwise nourishing foods. Eetter is his plan for reducing nitraie usage in agriculture and 1 am sure many of the more enlightened farmers would be happy to save hemselves money by reducing wasteful applications of fertiliser.
The above criticisms aside, at £4.99 for 118 pages of large prınt, with no index, this book is rather poor value, unlike Dudley's excellent "The Death of Trees" (reviewed by me a few years ago).
"Green Energy — a non-nuclear response to the greenhouse effect'3 is written by SERA member Dave Toke. It is, on the whole, a competent and well-written book. Briefly stating the problem of emissions of "greenhouse" gases, from industry, transport, homes and most importantly trom power generation, he goes on to dismiss nuclear power as an environ friendly alternative.
Interstingly, he points out that quite large amounts of CO2 are emitted during the mining and processing of uranium ore.
Unfortunately, he then loses his way and starts lashing out. He repeats the dubious claim that fast breeder reactors are at risk of nuclear explosion. FBRs are, of course, a way of circumventing the inevitable future shortage of uranium by generating plutonium. Toke does not really help his case by warning of a world "almost literally swimming in plutonium"!
His case against nuclear power is at its strongest in simple economic terms, as is his criticism of the vast sums spent on nuclear fusion research. However, his criticism of the attention paid to the "cold fusion" seems misplaced.
This was not, as he claims, "high science" but relied on very cheap components. If cold fusion had worked, it would be the height of stupidity to reject it in favour of what Toke terms *technology that acts in harmony with nature" (rather unfairly the image of Boy Scouts rubbing two sticks together comes unbidden to my mind).
The rest of the book is a much more balanced survey of energy conservation, acknowledged to be the most rewarding way of reducing emissions of greenhouse and other polluting gases, and cleaner energy sources, renewable or otherwise.
While slightly. pricey, the book would be a useful addition to a socialist environmentalist's bookshelf (or to the library of a Labour Party or trade union branch).
I. K A Gourley. Zed Books, 256pp, £7.95.
2. Nigel Dudley. GREENprint, 1990, 118pp, £4.993. Dave Toke. 136pp, £5.57, This was the final blow in a whole series of attacks on education in recent years: cuts and changes like Local Management of Schools and the National Curriculum had already combined to cause terrible strains in the year.
The Head himself seemed the most cowed by this latest disaster. He had scrupulously avoided political comment when talking to staff, if not the camera, before which he was prepared to call the National Curriculum a fascistic type of educational control.
In staff meetings, though, he had spent a year persuading staff to enter positively into the task of "marketing" the school — appointing new governors with business acumen and connections, cadging money from local banks which only materialised in the form of some nasty wallets to send the school's prospectus out in, and collecting scrap paper for recycling.
This latter made the weirdest spectacle of all. While the Head in his office tried to do deals with Barclays Bank, pretending they really had something to offer them, a teacher and a group of pupils worked outside shovelling scrap paper ınto the skıp which would take it to the recycling plant.
Why do teachers stay? It's not the pay, it's not the prestige, it's not the job security anymore.
Lots of teachers are leaving. This programme concentrated on those who do. Some had domestic reasons for avoiding upheaval. All seemed genuinely concerned that someone has to do the job and no-one is likely to replace them if they leave.
And what of job satisfaction? The programme made little effort to show those aspects of teaching which make it enjoyable for teacher..or pupil.
But it wasn't, after all, a recruitment film. Just a rather impressionistic attempt to show the dismaying effects of the Tories' wrecking job on our state education system.
Scan page 11
By Sleeper It is not good for trades unions that they should be brought into contact with the courts... Where class issues are involved..a very large number of our population has been led to the opinion that they are, unconsciously no doubt, biased."
That about sums up the standard left wing attitude towards the law and trade unionism. The less contact there is between the two, the better. Hence the widespread suspicion that exists on the left towards any talk of legal "positive rights" for unions. Much better -much more "revolutionary" — to rely upon the struggle in the workplace. Only craven reformists look to the law to enforce workers' rights.
Now I'm as much in favour of work place struggle as the next person; it is the starting point for all serious socialists. But workplace struggle needs to be given a political direction if it is to result in lasting gains for the entire working class. And that political direction often takes the form of forcing through progressive legislation.
In the latter part of the nineteenth century, for instance, there were big arguments amongst socialists about how best to pursue the campaign for the 8-hour working day. That well-known reformist Karl Marx insisted that strikes in particular factories, or even throughout entire industries, were not sufficient:
*On the other hand the movement to force through an 8-hour law is a political movement. And in this way, out of the - separate economic movements of the workers, there grows up everywhere a political movement, that is to say a class movement, with the object of enforcing its interests in a general form,"
Of course, since then the British labour movement has developed its own alternative way of dealing with the law - immunities. The idea is very simple: instead of having positive rights under the law, unions were instead exempted from certain laws that would otherwise make effective organisation and action impossible.
This began in the 1870s, when the governments of Gladstone and Disraeli gave the unions immunity from the conspiracy laws. Then, in the 1890s, the judges began using the civil law against unions, digging up the obscure tort of "inducing a breach of contract" against strikes. After the notorious Taff Vale judgement, the fledgling Labour Party was able to force the Liberal government of 1906 to give unions and union officials immunities from the torts (civil laws) concerning breach of contract.
And there matters stood for about the next five decades, with a de facto agreement between the state and the union bureaucracy that the law would be kept out of union affairs and the officials would keep the membership in line. But with the rising rank and file militancy of the 1960s, the judges suddenly discovered that the threat of industrial action constituted the tort of "intimidation" . The 1906 Act had given immunity to the act of inducing a breach of contract, but it had not said anything about the threat of breaking a contract!
All of which goes to demonstrate one of the central weaknesses of immunities. they are by definition defensive and can only relate to past decisions of the courts. Judges have often shown an impressive degree of imagination in conjuring up new civil law offences in order to get around existing immunities.
Incidentally, back in the 1870s, the TUC leadership had wanted to go for positive rights, but were persuaded to opt instead for immunities by their friends in the Liberal Party.
This brief wander through the history of unions and the law has not just been an academic exercise. Probably the single most important issue now facing the British labour movement is what we want done about the Tory anti-union laws. Labour's Policy Review is clear: the laws will stay, with a few rough edges smoothed ott, and some of the more blatantly unfair aspects modified.
But the left is still confused and divided, with a lot of people refusing to give any support (or only giving half-hearted support) to demands for positive rights like the right to strike, take secondary action and picket effectively. The myth that immunities are more effective and somehow more "pure" and "militant" still prevails on sections of the left; the idea that "real" trade unionism means having no truck with the legislative process is equally widespread. Such prejudices have meant that the left of the movement has not always thrown itself behind the 'Campaign for Free Trade Unions' or the 12-point Workers' Charter recently endorsed by the NALGO conference, with the unambiguous vigour that it should have done.
Hopefully, the history behind this issue will help some people on the left shake off their syndicalism and/or illusions in Good Old British Immunities.
By the way, that quote right at the start was from Winston Churchill.
Thanks to Roger Welch of Chelmsford and District Trades Council for a lot of the historical background for this article.
that we come out on the right end of Ithough NALGO has many sections (Universities, Polys, Electriety, Gas, New Towns, Water, Health, etc) Local Government dominates, with nearly three quarters of the 750,000 members.
And if an issue or speaker catches the imagination of the majority, it can snowball to massive support. When something doesn't hit the nail on the head it can be disastrous.
The Poll Tax debate was a classic case. Everyone agreed that the Poll Tax was terrible, but when speakers from the SWP and other left groups screamed at the conterence to support mass non-payment, boycott collecting the tax, atfiliate to the All-Britain Anti Poll Tax Federation and back a one-day general strike, the leadership were able to appeal to the self-interest of delegates by saying we need the money from the Poll Tax to pay our wages, so we should wait and get rid of the tax in several years time under a Labour government.
The "Don't Pay, Don't Collec!"" position was hammered and yet some left sects were visibly so happy at their positions being heard that they didn't care about the issue being lost.
But all is not despondency. We are still left with last year's position of "supporting a campaign of mass non-payment if and when it becomes viable" . Branches can still argue that it is viable and they will strike as Greenwich NALGO are doing.
----- pull-quotes -----
LES HEARN S COLUMN
NALGO: How we