Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What did you do in the war, Daddy?

Socialist Organiser no. 452, 21 June 1990 · scan p. 10 · Vicki Morris · about 725 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Armin Mueller-Stahl and Jessica Lange as suspected Nazi war criminal and his attorney daughter in Music Box Belinda Weaver reviews 'Music Box' Parents' pasts have to be up, most of us probably heard different versions of our parents' history, some false, some true, some exaggerated and embellished. We can never really know which is real. We weren't there.

In 'Music Box', lawyer Ann Talbot has to start questioning that early childish trust when her father, who emigrated to America from Hungary. after the second world war, is accused of war crimes and threatened with loss of citizenship.

At first, it seems like an honest mistake; Ann believes the authorities have the wrong Michael Laszlo. But when the case comes to trial, and she decides she must defend him, she has to confront her own fears that the man she knows and loves may have been the brutal and sadistic Mishka, of the Special Section death squad.

Her doubts don't all surface at once. Laszlo is anti-communist, and has publicly humiliated the Hungarian government. It's possible that they might want to destroy him in revenge. After all, they seem almost too eager to cooperate with the prosecuting Americans. But as witness after witness identifies Laszlo as Mishka, Ann becomes more and more uneasy. bal warm The witnesses, all imported from Hungary, have amazing recall of what they went through at Mishka's hands. Forty six years have not drawn a veil over the horrors, and many relive them over and over as nightmares.

Ann is pierced by their testimony, the overwhelming cruelty meted out to them, the whole catalogue of inhumanity. She begins to lose heart. Could her father be one of those exNazis, a man who compartmentalised his life, hiding past years of brutality in the new guise of model citizen and family man? It suddenly begins to seem possible. But if it's all a terrible mistake, she can't afford to shrink from the grim task of destroying the witnesses' credibilty.

This book would make a very Whatever the outcome, she knows she will never feel quite the same about him again.

The film is obviously inspired by the ongoing John Demjanjuk/Ivan the Terrible trial, where the issue of identification has played so important a part. But it ducks the issue of whether it is right to try to prosecute people, even Nazi war criminals, so many years after the Those opposing trials of war criminals usually doubt that the trials would be fair, or that any testimony could be accurate after so long a time. Yet in this film, the evidence of the witnesses is as clear and as concise as if the events had happened days, not decades, ago, It's as if the images were burned into their brains.

The one discussion in the film about the trails issue is held outside on a terrace. We only hear snatches of it, while we're involved in quite a different scene inside.

The film is not just a courtroom drama, but a film about the emotional devastation of a family. Ann and her young son, Mikey (named for his beloved grandfather), go through hell. But the film lets us draw our own conclusions about their ordeal; director Costa-Gavras doesn't exploit their suffering, or cheapen it.

"This isn't a tear jerker, but it's a sad film, a film that thinks the unthinkable.

Watching BBC2's programme about Spurley Hey comprehensive school made by wish that I'd been nicer to my teachers when I was at school.

Not that I was particularly disruptive, just that I probably didn't get as excited about their subjects as I might have. That, pupils interest • and improvement in learning, it seems, is all the compensation these comprehensive school teachers could find in a stressful, poorlypaid and undervalued job.

The programme followed the fortunes of Spurley Hey school in Manchester and of its staff in particular throughout the revolutionary year of 1989.

The programme had some faults, mainly being rather monotonous. The passage of the school year wasn't clearly marked. The teachers began the year depressed and disgruntled, and ended it depressed, disgruntled and doomed. The Head, who had tried to raise their flagging spirits throughout, had to announce that, because of the disastrous poll tax, Manchester was now looking to make some teachers redundant.

----- pull-quotes -----

been nicer to TV

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 452

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →