Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Jozef Pinior, a first step on a massive…]

Socialist Organiser no. 452, 21 June 1990 · scan p. 9 · about 564 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Jozef Pinior, a first step on a massive scale — industrialisation - then stopped. Now they are looking for a new way to advance themselves.

It seems to me that to say that the bureaucracy is transforming itself. from a caste into a class is wrong. It's more like the opposite way round - transforming itself from a class into a caste. Their position is not becoming stronger, but weaker.

But we must remember that this process is not finished. It was started by Gorbachev. It was a project of the central bureaucracy, to use the capitalist market but control the process.

But the process of self-emancipation in Eastern Eufope went very quickly, and they could not control it. Now they are at the crossroads. They face historical hara-kiri. Perhaps in the future some of them will be managers and so on, but I think their position will be very bad because all social movements will be against them and they are very weak in relation to multinational capitalism.

In Poland, after the Round Table, we said the state was controlled by the bureaucracy. Now it is another situation. Walesa will be president. There will be new elecfions to parliament, and so on.

A lot of managers in the bureaucracy have a strong position. But the bureaucracy as a central political force has lost its positions.

So the bureaucracy must decide. Not in Poland, because the Polish bureaucracy is not independent - it is nothing - but in Moscow they must decide.

Our position is that the Stalinist systems were class systems that are not an advance on capitalism. Some of us think they were new systems, quite distinct from capitalism; some of us think they were a form of state capitalism. Why do you think that state capitalism is a wrong description of the East European systems?

The accumulation was on another level than capitalist accumulation. It was a new form of accumulation, a new form of exploitation and domination. The bureaucrats' relation to the means of production was that they decided about profits and production and so on.

Why did the systems go into economic crisis?

Their so-called centralised planning was not planning. It was bureaucratic planning, planning without planning. Economically it was completely without sense.

Capitalist multinationals have much better planning. In fact things were decided by fighting within the bureaucracy about money and resources and so on.

They made a first step-industrialisation. They couldn't make another step.

First it was a workers' state in Russia. The bureaucratic caste could not advance society to a new stage without the working class. But they oppressed the working class.

So it was impossible for the bureaucracy to advance society.

The bureaucracy was caught in a vicious circle. Their existence as a caste depends on entirely controlling the working class. On the other hand, their existence for the future as a class depends on advancing the economy and industry: It was a contradiction.

So the bureaucracies are a caste and a class. Their existence as a caste depended on totally controlling the working class and society.

But in the long term that weakened their position. It made it impossible for them to advance the economy and industry, Their position as a class depended on advancing the economy and industry. It was a contradiction.

From that point there was a development to today's crisis.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 452

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →