Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"We reject the Stalinist system and we reject capitalism"

Socialist Organiser no. 452, 21 June 1990 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,399 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

member of the Centre in Poland, in London recently, and spoke to Mark Sandell and Martin Thomas about his ideas on the nature of the Stalinist systems.

Be are not sure, of course. The discussion My personal opinion is that it was a workers' state after October 1917 in Russia. Later there was a process of degeneration. That process of degeneration developed, developed, developed. It is difficult to say now about whether there is a workers' state.

In my opinion it is a postcapitalist state, a bureaucratic system. The bureaucracy has a lot of elements of a class, but a lot of elements of a caste, too. Now we are in a period when the bureaucracy is trying to change themselves into a strong class. In what way do you see the system as being post-capitalist? In a way the Stalinist system in Poland, say, is post-capitalist — it came after capitalism - but it seems to us that it is not post-capitalist in the sense of being a historic advance on capitalism, more progressive...

It is post-capitalist in the sense that it is another system...

But post-capitalist means not just that it is different but that it is "after", it is more advanced. The question is: was the Stalinist system an advance on capitalism? Did it create better conditions for the working class, or for the development of the productive forces? It seems to me that if you put the question clearly now, there is only one possible answer: it wasn't, In the October Revolution there were a lot of possibilities to build an advanced system. The process of Stalinist degeneration crushed those possibilities, and the working class rejected the bureaucratic system.

It is difficult for us to say which is worse, capitalism or Stalinism, because we reject both. We rejected the Stalinist system and at the same time we rejected capitalism. We socialism, worker, Possibilities of aimed for new of on.

It is difficult for us to say which is worse, because in this process of rejecting Stalinism we don't like to support capitalism.

If you say the Stalinist system is more advanced, the conclusion must be that not only do you reject capitalism — but also that you say to the Polish workers that the system they have is bad, and they should try to fight for socialism, but capitalism would be even worse, so they should fight to defend the present system against capitalism even if they can't win socialism.

We say that we fight to overthrow the bureaucratic system in Poland and Eastern Europe, and at the same time we want to create a new revolutionary alternative. We don't want to defend the bureaucratic insitutions.

That isn't what you would say if you thought the system was more advanced. In the 1930s Trotsky argued that the system in the Soviet Union wasn't good, but it was better than capitalism; he argued for the workers to organise to overthrow the Stalinist system, but.

when they weren't strong to overthrow the Stalinist system they Strikers in Gdansk last year should defend it against capitalism. I think that view made some sense then; I don't think it makes any sense now for the Soviet Union, and I don't think it makes any sense at all for Poland, where the workers never had power.

We don't want to defend this bureaucratic system. It is difficult to say which system is more advanced, because every system is worst! And, of course, we must use the possibilities in every system to overthrow that system of exploitation and domination and create a new alternative - all possibilities, workers' rights, workers' freedoms, and so on.

Don't you think what's happening in Eatern Europe indicates that whatever the systems were there, it is possible to transform them peacefully into capitalism?

The problem of restoration... Yes. And restoration which is not happening as you would expect if they were workers' states, but counter-revolution against the working class, but by a peaceful process which is supported by the workers...

I think we must be very careful in these discussions about restoration. In Poland there is no national bourgeoisie. There is not a class which can make an accumulation of capital on a capitalistic level. The peasants cannot make an accumulation of capital. There is only foreign capital.

Foreign capital could probably do it through the central bank, central government, and so on. But I think it is a process of decades. It depends on the class struggle.

We have a workers" resistance against pauperisation. Workers will defend themselves against the IME programme.

It will not be a struggle against capitalism as such, I think, but struggle against pauperisation.

There are three possibilities, not only two. Not only revolution or restoration, but also a real possibility of bureaucratic reaction. The independent Soviet bureaucracy has the force to reproduce itself. The Polish bureaucracy is not independent, but the Soviet bureaucracy is different.

We must be careful. In Poland the process of re-privatisation has not really begun. It is a plan.

If the IMF wants to introduce its programme of re-privatisation, factory closures, unemployment, and so on, they must absolutely control the state and the government. They must attack workers' rights.

In South Korea they had a ban on trade unions. But in Poland these freedoms - workers' rights, trade union rights — are a Solidarity symbol. If you want to introduce the programme in Poland, you must attack the Solidarity symbols too. The bureaucracies, led by Gorbachev, are trying to solve a crisis in the way their economic system works. For some of them, at least, not all of them, their aim is to convert themselves into private capitalists. And isn't there a good possibility that the IMF will go into alliance with them?..

It's possible for new capitalist classes to be built up around the state machine. It has happened in the Third World.

In Poland - perhaps it is different in the Soviet Union - it is not possible for the lower and middle bureaucracy to become capitalists.

They tried to do it after the Round Table. They tried to control the means of production through setting up new companies. They met workers' resistance, and now, a month ago in Parliament, they made a law against it.

The central, top bureaucracy is another problem. They really control the banks, the ministries, and so on. Nobody knows the result of the process.

But their position, I think, is very weak. On the one hand you have a labour movement absolutely against them. On the other hand, you have the capitalist market and the big multinationals. In relation to the big capitalists, the bureaucrats are nothing. They are very weak It is difficult to say if it is possible or not possible for bureaucrats to become capitalists. But what looks more possible to me is a bureaucratic reaction, military action as in China.

In the Soviet Union, there is a process of disintegration. The central bureaucracy must choose between continuing that process or repression. At some point they must decide for repression or go for historical hara-kiri. I think they will choose repression.

But aren't the indications that a military or dictatorial regime — and the first step of it has already happened, with Gorbachev taking full powers - will not restore the old Stalinist command economy but carry through marketisation faster?

agree. There are several possibilities. The first possibility maybe the most likely, is some kind of military dictatorship with a proçess of marketisation... se Another possibility is that power is taken by the most chauvinistic, reactionary part of the Russian bureaucracy.

I don't think there will be repression on the classical Stalinist level. And I agree there will be marketisation.

The bureaucracy is trying to change itself into a strong class with a lot of elements of capitalism. I don't know whether it will be capitalism or not capitalism. Of course it will not be socialism! The bureaucracy is completely reactionary.

It is difficult to say how this process will look. It is a different process from in Turkey or Mexico or countries like that. On the one hand the bureaucrats' position is very strong because they have the army and police, on the other hand very weak because they have workers' resistance.

They couldn't advance economic production. They organised the

Scan page 10

wish l'd

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 452

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →