Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Should we mourn the collapse of Stalinism?

Socialist Organiser no. 452, 21 June 1990 · scan p. 7 · about 1,870 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Pennsylvania, 1888. vorkplace was a rope-making oryIn 1902 Joel's mother died. The Hägglund children were now able to upport themselves. Therefore they lecided to sell their home and tivide the money between them.

Joel and one of his brothers lett iweden for the promised land of America inthe autumn of 1902.

In America, Joe worked in facories, mines, on farms and as a locker. He went from the east coast o the west.

After a while he ended up in San —'edro, California. This was where we joined the Industrial Workers of -he World (IWW). Many of Joe's songs were written in San Pedro.

Joe Hill's life as an IWW member and activist was very exsiting. Joe went from one struggle o another.

It could be a strike at the mouthern Pacific Railroad or a steelworkers' strike in Illinois. Wherever it was needed, Joe came ith his songs and violin to unite id to help the workers in their ruggle.

The songs gave the strikers a feelng of unity and solidarity. The eason for the popularity of the songs was Joe's knowledge about e workers' situation and his sarastic and satirical judgements on capitalists of all sorts.

In 1915 Joe worked in the mines in Utah. It was during that time he was framed on a murder charge.

He was supposed have murdered a shopkeeper in Salt Lake City. The evidence produced was not sufficient, but the capitalists and the politicians wanted Joe dead.

Meanwhile, Joe had taken a third name, Joseph Hillstrom.

In the month of November 1915 they killed Joe with five shots through his body. After this Joe Hill became a legend, formed by the IWW and other workers' organisations.

His story has been told not only in America, but also in Sweden, Australia and many other western countries, in Russia and in East Germany.

Today, Joe the Wobbly, hidden in myths, rightfully can be called "the man who never died". Hill's songs have become a part of working class culture.

His songs are still living and the words are worth considering even The first of Hill's songs in the IWW songbook was "The Preacher and the Slave'. This song was printed in the third edition in 1911.

The song is a parody of the Salvafion Army hymn 'In the Sweet Bye and Bye' and it's an attack on the "streetcorner" missionaries and against the preachers in the Salvation Army.

The preachers told the workers to be satisfied with their share in society, so that they would be worthy of ine wealth and happiness in the sky bove. The revolutions in Eastern Europe, according to Socialist Action, were "the greatest defeats suffered by the working class since World War II." Only one victory has been won there - the electio success of the Romanian Stalinists (National Salvation Front).

The revolutions in which workers won the right to organise and speak freely for the first time in 45 or even 60 years were worse defeats than the Chile coup of 1973, the Indonesian coup of 1965 in which half a million leftists were slaughtered, the suppression of the Hungarian Revolution in 1956, the imposition of apartheid in South Africa or the 1948 Arab-Israel war which led half a million Palestinian Arabs becoming refugees!

Socialist Action comes to its strange conclusion because of its theory that the old regimes were "deformed workers' states". Vicki Morri invastigates the argument.

That the events of 1989 were a turning point in history, few would disagree. But that the political revolutions in Eastern Europe, and the dismantling of their Stalinist systems has dealt a crushing blow to the prospects for world socialism is harder to accept.

That is, nonetheless, what Peter Drew argues in the latest edition of Socialist Action.

His argument starts to go astray in his second paragraph. 1989 "weakens the working class strengthens world capitalism" . I agree that anything which does both "sets back the fight for equality, etc". But are the two both consequences of 1989, and, if so, in what proportions? Drew refuses to contemplate the idea that you might have one without the other.

Even if they were, would the alternative, that Stalinism continue its stranglehold, on Eastern Europe - and on the allegiance of large sections of the world's "anti-imperialists" — bode any better for us in that fight?

Unlike Drew, who is confident to predict the apocalyptic consequences of 1989, I think the first question is very difficult to answer. For now, then, I'll try to tackle the second, Read Drew's article and you will not find a credible attempt to explain why Gorbachev wants to introduce the market in the USSR, nor, indeed, why enormous numbers of ordinary Eastern European people were prepared to risk possibly their lives to bring down their national Stalinist regimes. I'm sure it isn't, and wasn't, because of their illusions in what capitalism might give them, but because of their disillusionment with what they already have.

For Drew, howęver, actions are explained only by reference to the treachery Stalinists, now reaching their full extent. Gorbachev has sold out the international working class.

Why do Socialist Action imagine that Stalinists have, or would ever do otherwise? In fact, Gorbachev's interest is personal: to keep control of the USSR. To make it function and certainly not as a workers' state. The only way he can do this is to find something to end the present economic stagnation and decline.

Like the adherents of the degenerated workers' state theory, Socialist Action throw up their hands in horror at the social and economic problems which the insecurities of the market will bring to workers. But the USSR was no paradise before.

Market economies in the developed capitalist countries periodically require their workers to tighten their belts, and the workers can usually do it. But it won't be possible for East European workers to pull their belts any tighter than they already are. Austerity measures will be horrendous in Eastern Europe as a whole, because the Stalinist systems have maintained their economies at such an already low base.

Likewise racism was already rife, and the position of women already dreadful. Drew does not do justice to his case to raise these spectres as threats of what the market has yet to bring.

Socialist Organiser is against these terrible conditions, conditions which the market might exacerbate. But who can say that they would not have deepened anyway had Stalinism prevailed?

Are we for the end of Stalinism? Absolutely. And, it seems to me, that the price we urge the international working class to pay is, in terms of the gains — of which, as l said, more anon - not too high.

Are Socialist Action anti-Stalinist? Probably...in the long run. And there is the rub, They are for the end of Stalinism ..if it is replaced by socialism. And if that isn't a viable option - it certainly isn't at present with working class orgnisations and politics at such low levels - then they seem to think that, compared to capitalism, it is a lesser evil.

Or do they? Socialist Action probably wanted change. But of a different kind. The logic of their illusions in the Stalinist regimes seems, and their demonisation of the Big , Imperialism - by which they mean, I take it, international capital - must be that they welcome the extension of Stalinoid formations in other parts of the world.

Soviet aid, unlike the interventions of international capital, has, indeed, been beneficial to the national economies and bureaucracies - of developing countries like Cuba and Nicaragua, if not to the independence of the workers' movements there. But I cannot understand how Socialist Action can be so sanguine as to think that, in brighter days, the USSR would not rather have invaded those countries - as it did Eastern Europe to set up replicas of its own regime there, and bring those countries more firmly into its own military fold.

Whereas the USA wields a big tick in the Third World, the USSE offers a big bribe, probably because its stick wouldn't stretch that far.

Nor, of late, does its budget. Did pre-Corbachev Soviet leaders give a damn for the impoverished masses of the Third World? No. Does Gorbachev? Oddly, he probably cares a bit more, but the USSR can no longer afford to give the aid.

Drew berates him for abandoning. his commitments. By extension, does he rue the gradual, if uncertain, thawing of the Cold War? Although this disarmament is not something we have brought about or can take for granted, history, even in this age of "deepening imperialism" , does deliver the odd temporary boon. Reduced arms spending means money for more useful things, and less chance for our governments to distract the workers with chauvinism.

Yet in this article we find Socialist Action feeling utterly dismayed and demoralised by the events of 1989 and by the undeniable confidence which the capitalists have taken from the aftermath. I do not know how they could not have felt demoralised before.

Were the Trotskyists greater in numbers then? Could they operate more freely? No. Were their tasks. any less? Not appreciably.

those who believed that the regimes were already doing part of their job for them must now, undoubtedly, be feeling rather at sea.

Others of us see the opportunities. which the end of Stalinism brings.

For instance, it is an enormous. asset to see disarmed those Stalinists enjoying life outside the Stalinist states but nonetheless willing to sacrifice the interests of the international working class to the foreign policy needs of the USSR. In this country, arguably, their day s already long past as they are already quite discredited.

But what of the Trotskyists like Socialist Action — who seek a rapprochment with their remains? They are in danger of appearing more than a bit cranky for denouncing those who were moved by the sight of the East European people putting the Stalinists to rout.

None of us are over-sanguine about the struggles ahead. But we nust rejoice at the prospects for workers organisation which the events of 1989 open up.

Socialist Action did not despise the formal rights to equality granted to women in the Stalinist ystems although even they admit that the material conditions for their realisation were poor. Why hen discount, for instance, the rights which the left now has in Eastern Europe to publicise its deas, just because they will find it difficult to afford a photocopier?

Socialist Action correctly identifies the first task of socialists East and West as uniting in struggle. Although necessary, how possible was that prior to 1989? They also say that we should not let our ideological differences hinder us.

To that end it would be better if Socialist Action would use more thought before denouncing the socialists who take a different view of the events of 1989 to themselves.

Such thought might convince them that their disorientation past and present - is a result of feeling impotent in a world where the Trotskyists have seemed overwhelmed by history, and the Stalinists have seemed on the offensive against capitalism, even if against their own working classes into the bargain.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 452

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →