Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The class nature is not changed

Socialist Organiser no. 452, 21 June 1990 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 1,014 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

The sight of Stalinist protestors last week Bucharest is a sad one. But those sections of the left that critically hailed those who led revolution against Causescu "socialist rebels" it's time rethink.

•led ical in for unthe as to All socialists supported the wave of rebellion in the Stalinist states last winter. It was high time the corrupt bureaucracy was swept away. However, the revolution did not replace Stalinism with workers' control. Instead the Romanian bureaucracy was purged and reforged on a pro-capitalist programme.

The freedoms won in December are being turned back. Phones are tapped, letters opened, the Securitate is back in action. The Stalinists manipulate the privileged miners — now paid 3 times more than the average wage — to break up independent newspapers, parties and protests.

Many Romanian radicals understand what's going on. As student leader Marian Munteanu said: *the miners are not guilty for this, they were tools" Undoubtedly the Stalinists will use the repression of radicals to cover up cuts in the living standards of workers and the introduction of the market.

What does this tell us about both the revolutions last winter and the tasks for working class socialists?

Firstly, the revolutions exchanged hardline Stalinists for pro-market "reformists' themselves hoping to become part of a future capitalist class. The Stalinist class nature of these states has not been fundamentally changed.

Secondly these revolutions were betrayed because the working class didn't fight for a programme that reflected their class interest. Instead incynicilowed the /liberal: wing of the Stalinists.

Finally the workers must take the power themselves. They must reject the plans for the dominance of the market and make a new revolution against the bureaucracy and the threat of imperialist domination.

Many in the West did not oppose the Stalinist moves towards the market because a healthy workers" state could use market mechanisms. But it is clear that a healthy workers' state was not being created!

The only programme that can lead radicals in the bureaucratised workers' states forward is working class anti-Stalinist revolution for socialist democracy and workers" control of production.

British socialists must learn from that. We need a campaign in solidarity with workers in the East. But we also need a political dialogue to build revolutionary workers' parties in those countries and internatonally.

up Duncan Chapel, Manchester

Scan page 5

The Kuzbass Workers' Union was formed in response - to the bureaucratisation of the original workers' committee set up after last summer's miners' strikes, Yuri Budchenko told a press conference in London.

Yuri is a representative of the union currently touring Britain with the Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bloc.

The workers' committee became like officers without an army, he said. The union is more democratic, and has real support. It has gone on to be the base for the new Confederation of Labour established on a Soviet-wide basis.

More than 50% of the delegates at the recent Confederation congress were from the Kuzbass. They see their role as to help the smaller workers' organisations that have now been set up.

The union believes the crisis in Soviet society to be very severe. Socialism is a discredited idea among the workers, and so "the market' is a popular alternative to the chaos and collapse now taking place. They don't see the market as ideal, Yuri said, but can see no better alternative.

Asked 11 there was not a contradiction between the aim of defending workers' interests and supporting the introduction of a western-style market, Yuri argued that the market would at least provide basic goods. If there is a better way, they would like to know about it, he said, But he seemed unconvinced by Yuri Budchenko Independent Soviet trade unionist Yuri Budchenko has told meetings across the country about the new Soviet miners' union The working class is only just beginning to fight. Everything is ahead of the working class. It has awoken.

The working class is in opposition to the ruling class - the bureaucracy and administration.

The bureaucracy form a new aristocracy - like under Tsarism. There are many bureaucratic organisations who act in the interests of the rulers. They operate the plan. The plan is built on control of distribution - of production, resources and raw materials.

Last week the miners took a major step forward. They took a decision to form an independent miners' union.

One delegate was elected from each pit in the USSR. Nearly 600 pits sent delegates from a total of 650 mines in the USSR.

Two thirds of the delegates voted to set up an independent union. The union will be set up in August, after the delgates have had the chance to go back to their pits and discuss with the miners who sent them the conference.

It is important to understand why the miners have taken the decision to organise their own independent union.

The state miners' union conference was held in Moscow during the winter. However only 20% of the delegates to this conference were miners. The rest were functionaries.

A lot of genuine workers left in disgust. The state union has failed Scari. And accept vitationth to BuCTs. Arthur speak at the state union's conference damage their reputations amongst Soviet miners: they are seen to be siding with the government which treats Soviet miners very badly.

The Soviet state, despite the strikes last year, still has a lot of power. It cheats Soviet miners by using its monopoly of power.

For instance, it buys coal we produce, then it sells it on the world market using its monopoly of foreign trade, for much more.

Many of the demands - 47 in total - which the government agreed to in order to settle with the miners during last summer's strikes (Resolution 608) have not been fulfilled. The government has only kept its promises on 14 minor points.

It is true that the supplement paid to Siberian miners has gone up from 15% to 30%. But there are no more goods in our shops. The hous-

----- pull-quotes -----

EASTER formed their ov

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 452

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →