Rank and fileism - Tory style
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-06-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
INS OI.
By Sleeper One of the more infuriating aspects of the Tories' anti-union offensive has been the way they like to dress it all up with rhetoric about "handing the unions back to the members" defending "the rank and file" against "unrepresentative leaders" ete etc.
Parts of some speeches by the likes of Tebbit and Fowler could have been written by... well, me, for instance.
The idea of Tebbit or Fowler as al champion of the rights of the rank and file should have been laughed out of court. But it wasn't. Even quite solid trade unionists were at least partly taken in for a while - the reason being, of course, that on the whole British trade unions are bureaucratic and unresponsive to the wishes of the rank and file.
This is an important part of the explanation for the lack of resistance to the Tories' anti-union legislation and something that tends to be overlooked by those who prefer to explain away everything in terms of simple betrayal and cowardice by the officials.
The evidence is that the provisions of the 1988 Employment Äct, making postal ballots for general secretary and executive elections compulsory, were actually quite popular among rank and file trade unionists. The Tories knew this was a vulnerable area for the bureaucracy and clearly expected the legislation to result in a decisive shift to the right throughout the trade union movement - as did most union activists.
The funny thing is that the predicted stampeed towards 'moderation' doesn't seem to have happened. In fact, the legislation has not produced any very decisive changes at all, according to a Acting Convenor, "Stop the Merger"
Campaign (personal capacity)
PSA and NUCPS members will vote before the end of the year on a merger between the two unions.
NUCPS conference agreed to recommend a merger by 7:2, CPSA conference agreed to ballot without a recommendation, after a vote to recommend rejection in the ballot was lost by just 2,000 votes out of 140,000. Labour Research survey of the 50 largest TUC-affiliated unions. For a start only 27 unions out of the 50 had to make any rule changes in order to comply with the new legislation, either because they already held postal ballots (or were in the process of introducing them irrespective of the legislation) or because they don't have full time officers on their executive.
32 of the unions surveyed have held general secretary elections since 1988; in 18 cases the existing general secretary was a candidate (sometimes, indeed, the only candidate) and in all but one case (NATFHE) the sitting candidate was reelected. In the 14 unions where the general secretary did not stand, someone with remarkably similar politics took over in every case.
What has changed quite noticeably, however, is the level of membership participation in the election process... it's gone down. Last year, for instance, just 30.9% of the members of the tax workers' union IRSF took part in their executive committee elections - the first to be held by postal ballot. Under the previous system of workplace ballots average 56%. In this year's TGWU executive elections, the turnout was a mere 17%, compared to 39% in the 1988 elections held under the union's old rules. Much the same has happened with NALGO, CoHSE, NATFHE and Tass/MSF.
The Labour Research survey explodes the favourite myths of both left and right: secret ballots do not increase rank and file participation in union elections (the right-wing myth); and they do not inevitably favour 'moderate' candidates (the left's traditional explanation for the right-wing domination of a union like the AEU, which had postal ballots long before the Tory legislation).
However, in one respect the survey's findings should be taken with a pinch of salt: it ignores the fact that many unions' pre-'88 election procedures were notoriously slack and in some cases downright corrupt. The TGWU's old system of "block voting', for instance often meant that in practice ballot papers never reached the membership but were filled in 'on their behalf' by an unseen hand....
The conclusions for the unions would seein to be:
1. Tory legislation has not enhanced union democracy even to the extent of improving rank and file participation in 2. Ballots for union elections should take place after maximum information members. Rules ourlawing campaign members. ing' should be abolished. Ideally, ballots should take place at the workplace, after properly convened meetings where all points of view can be properly aired.
3. While campaigning for the abolition of all Tory anti-union laws, we do not necessarily advocate a return to the old status quo - especially in unions where the pre-'88 system of elections was known to be corrupt.
Finally, it seems to me that the survey tends to back up the stand taken by those of us who've said all along that while we don't advocate postal ballots, we also don't recoil from them as though they were worse than no democracy at all... wingers and soft lefts withour any shared policy objectives); and the gungho right wing "Progressive AntiCommunist' faction whose single policy is to destroy the left.
The Stalinists continue to deny that their tightly organised secret faction is anything of the sort, but if they are not to be completely destroyed they will now have to argue their policies openly with the members.
All the factions except the Broad Left are represented on the union executive, and there will probably be at least some partial realignment over the coming year.
The breakdown of the Stalinist hold on conference (and the relative weakness of the right amongst the active members) was most surprisingly demonstrated by the decision to vote for affiliation to CND. But it also found expression in the carrying of two conpletely contradictory motions on One deplored the NUCPS's previous support for 'state run puppet unions' and called for maximum support for "democratic and progressive free trade unions' ,and the other effectively called for continued relations with the 'official' East European unions only.
A big step forward was taken by the decision to vote for flat rate pay increases. But conference policies remain characterised more by what they deplore than by positive strategies to defend jobs, conditions and pay.
A significant number of delegates felt that the union is not confronting the attacks being made upon members. Conference voted to recommend merger with CPSA, but the most thoroughgoing and valuable unity will be that forged on the picket line in opposition to these attacks.
The Broad Left must relate to this task. It must build upon its successful interventions into conference by developing its policy alternatives to the other factions, constructing a real, active rank and file group which intervenes as a group into all the struggles that members are waging now.
Strikers believe that more flights will be grounded as the action bites.
The engineers' shorter working week campaign continues.
Last week 7 key companies were targetted for possible action: Plessey, Dowty, Tl, Vicker Defence, GPT, Ruston and Gas Turbines.
The Confed claims to have won 442 reduced hours agreements.
The new phase of the camto 'mop up" those smaller con panies who have not yet agres to an hours cut. By Paul McGarry The National Union of Students National Committee met recently to discuss next academic year's priority campaigns and work.
Unsurprisingly the Executive failed to commit itself to building on its policy of non-payment and non-collection of the poll tax. The Kinnockite faction drew back from endorsing a 'Don't Pay, Don't Collect' campaign, favouring a softer line more acceptable to Labour Party HQ.
Left Unity supporters proposed that NUS needed to organise occupation, pickets and sit-ins at the start of the autumn term when students face removal of housing benefit and housing shortages.
Emma Colyer (NUS National Secretary) proposed Left Unity's alternative strategy document. Our strategy includes an affiliation drive aimed at the FE sector and policies which tie together the need to build a fighting union with developing more membership participation inside NUS's structures.
New NUS President Stephen Twigg won support from the Communist Party and the SLD for a rerun of the lobby-style, wait-for-aLabour-government strategy that has characterised Labour Student's 8 years of rule in NUS.
Interestingly, the SWP had nothing to argue, consoling themselves with the revolutionary activity of voting against everyone's proposals, including a Left Unity motion on Further Education Union Development.
The Executive meeting alloted individual work-responsiblities to Ex"New NUS president Stephen Twigg won support from the ecutive members. As in previous years, the left members received virtually no important work areas, while the Kinnockites and fellow travellers got up to 5 times as many responsibilities.
An index of the political culture on the Executive were the remarks of Steve Clamp and Mark Bloomfield in justifying why they should have responsibility for the poll tax.
("I can give a Welsh perspective"
- Clamp) and Northern Ireland ("the problem in Ireland is an English problem, I'm Scottish" -Bloomfield)!
Student activists should ring or write to Stephen Twigg demanding that the NUS leadership implements its poll tax policy and asking why
----- pull-quotes -----
paign, 'Operation Cascade' , is designed by engineers' leaders
block fight
Communist Party and the SLD"