What if Garry Bushell were
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-06-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
the womb during the woman's next montly cycle.
If some of these problems could be overcome, this might be the preferred method of PID since transferred blastocysts have greater rate of implantation in the womb. Professor Winston said that in one programme of blastocyst PID there had been only a 1 in 5 success rate and that in his opinion it would be unethical to continue with this technique at present.
Professor Winston identified several areas where further research was required. Other ways of diagnosing genetic disorders were being investigated, such as observing how the embryo metabolised its food or seeing if it produced unusual compounds when it was carrying a faulty gene. These would not involve the removal any material at all. Seeing how the normal embryo developed and finding ways of culturing it beyond the 5 or 6 days at present possible might help make IVF a more successful technique.
He stressed that his work was not aimed at reducing the levels of faulty genes in the population. Whether this was a legitimate aim, he did not offer an opinion. Some people think this smacks too much of the 'eugenics' programme of the Nazis, though I cannot immediately see the connection. I cannot see the objection to reducing the incidence of many of the worst genetic diseases though I question whether it would be possible to significantly affect the incident of any but the rarest ones.
Professor Winston also stressed that it was the people affected by these genetic tragedies who were asking for help, not the whitecoated technocrats who were trying to play God, as caricatured by some 'pro-life' campaigners. As PID became more reliable, he foresaw it being offered perhaps to all those over 40, in view of the high risk of Down's syndrome babies.
Rather than risking the development of a 'super race', PID was likely to remove much worry and heartaché from a group of unfortunate people.
To people have the right to D stay in the closet? Much discussed at the moment is the question of 'outing', the practice of forcing famous people who are lesbian or gay to admit it publicly.
An American gay magazine, Outweek, has a regular column where it spills the beans on the rich and powerful - like film stars and senators. Could this catch on in Britain? It formed the subject for the last episode of the recent series of Channel Four's 'Out on Tuesday' and I've found myself discussing it quite a lot.
There are really two categories of "outing'. At its most extreme, the argument runs that all people who pretend to be heterosexual thereby maintain some privileges the rest of us don't have. They deserve to be exposed: no one needs to stay in the closet, and those who try to should be dragged out screaming.
Second, there are the closet cases whose actions positively harmlesbians and gay men, who write or say vile anti-gay things, who for example vote in Parliament for Section 28. 'Outing' such people severely damages the reactionary cause they have lent themselves to.
I'm sure a lot of people would find the idea of any kind of outing simply the most monstrous invasion of people's privacy which should be stopped before it gets out of hand. It wouldn't be a nice way for your mum to find out.
This indeed was the background to this country's first real case of outing. Jimmy Somerville grassed up the Pet Shop Boys, who apparently were terrified of their parents Knowing. He was sick of being the Gay Pop Star when everyone in the business knows that half the twelve year old girls in the country have screaming queens pinned on their walls. So why should he take all the rap?
Whatever the rights and wrongs here, you can't construct a general policy from it. People choose to remain in the closet for all sorts of reasons, from fear of parental discovery to personal self-doubt. Force in such cases is not usually the best policy.
Equally, all sorts of factors, by no means the chief of which is necessarily courage, and still less political principle, make it easier for other people to come out.
We should be against outing as a form of terrorism.
But isn't any form of it just gutter journalism? Why is it any better for a gay magazine to make a public issue out of someone's sexuality than for the Daily Mail?
Recently, right-on people everywhere were annoyed by tabloid attempts to suggest that Prince Andrew was having it away with Michael Ball. If Outweek made the same claim, wouldn't it be just the same?
Let's pretend, for the sake of getting to the point of this issue, that someone had proof that Garry Bushell was gay. Nothing pornographic (heaven forbid), just a photo of him lying on the beach in Sitges with a sylph-like Spanish boy draped over his arm and a copy of Zipper laid out on the sand in front of him.
What would you do with that photograph?
Publishing it would hardly put a stop to tabloid gay bashing. But face it, it would be brilliant.
I think in such cases, outing has a point. Take MPs. When we talk about gay MPs who voted for Section 28, it is not a matter of some quiet old Tory who's ridden with angst and spends every evening in church asking God for forgiveness. We are talking rampant hypocrisy.
There are MPs whose homosexuality is known to a signficant number of people, who make no attempt to keep it secret (except from the general public and, of course, their constituents), who are known, for example, to swan around from one public lavatory to the next, yet who act in such a way that ordinary lesbians and gay men suffer. Those on the receiving end both of reactionary legislation and more general worsening social attitudes do, not share these MPs' privileges, or their power, which includes the power to have docile gossip columnists happily playing along with the charade.
The outing of such people would surely make the job of the anti-gay propagandists harder. Exposing people as hypocrites has a powerful effect. And it is surely improbable that such action would be counterproductive. According to the editor of Outweek, 'outed' US senators have started to speak out for lesbian and gay rights; the threat of it has stopped others doing harm.
Coming out is an essential aspect of the modern 'gay experience'. It is not just something you do, and then it's over with. Every day, for most lesbians and gay men, even well-adjusted out-and-proud ones, decisions have to be made about it. Every time you meet a new person.
In some jobs, for example, it is a big decision indeed. It could cost you the job.
That should make us sympathetic to the millions of lesbians and gay men who still haven't managed to come out even to themselves, and to the thousands more who are only out in certain spheres of their lives and firmly closeted in the rest.
But if Garry Bushell were gay, 1 would have no sympathy for his closet at all. If then someone wanted to use his sexuality against him, that would be a different matter. But watching him squirm would be more fun than the Market Tavern last Friday. And take it from me, that's fun.
Scan page 11
int leaders
----- pull-quotes -----
OUT AND PROUD