Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

As far from Stalinism as from capitalism

Socialist Organiser no. 451, 7 June 1990 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 765 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Will the SWP vote to such a degree that she received 94 stitches.

He had lived through years of "married hell" ,the judge decided, being "nagged" , so it was hardly surprising that after 30 years he should "snap" , which is to say he attacked her with a decanter and a fork, so that 'the floors and walls were splattered with blood"

Well that's all right, then. I mean we can't let women get the idea that they can get cross with their husbands just because after thirty years of marriage he's not yet managed to learn how to cook an egg. Women just have to learn that if they raise their voices they'll be stabbed with a fork...or a kitchen knife, even better, hung upside down and left for dead.

The judge in this case, a Mr William Taylor, deserves and award. Suggestions, please, to Graffiti, c/o Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. "The SDP is a permanent struc ural feature of British politics.' Socialist Action, 1984 Duncan Chapel (letters, SO D 450) sees a 'hint' in Tony Dale's letter (SO 449) that we should favour market mechanisms in Eastern Europe as the means to gear production to human need.

I didn't see that hint, but Tony can answer for himself. What I did see clearly in Duncan's letter was the statement that "we must oppose the introduction of the market into the East... Instead workers should defend and control the planned economy"

It is impossible for workers to control 'the' planned economy, i.e. the Stalinist command economy typical of Eastern Europe before 1989. That economy is one organised for the exploitation of workers by a totalitarian or semitotalitarian bureaucracy which cannot permit the workers even to organise freely in trade unions, let alone to "control' the economy.

Certainly workers need a planned economy. But that workers' planned economy will be as different from Stalinism as it is from Western capitalism. We can only discredit ourselves in East European workers' eyes if we tell them that our alternative is a cleaned-up and. democratised version of the system they have suffered under for so long - and that in the meantime, until they are strong enough to win workers' control, they should "defend' that collapsing old system.

We should certainly not slide over Green?

Will the Soci alist Workers er or start voting Green or Scottish Nationalist?

At a recent Canterbury SWP public meeting, a local SWP member told us that in a local council by-election in the Thanet area, he had canvassed for an anti-poll tax candidate against the Labour candidate.

He went on to say that in future elections the SWP should support Soviet miners to the opposite mistake of suggesting that the answer is a version of Western market capitalism likewise mystically 'controlled'.

Nonetheless, a workers' planned ecsnomy, in the foreseeable future, would also be a market economy.

Just to take over the planning offices and put democratically-elected people there in place of the Stalinists would solve little. Socialist planning presupcandidates who were calling for non-payment against Labour candidates.

Was it just his personal opinion? Apparently not. The speaker at the meeting was Chris Harman, editor of Socialist Worker and neither Harman nor any one else registered disagreement. They even refused to answer my question as to whether the SWP would vote for a Green Party candidate.

Mark Sandell, Canterbury CLP poses accurate accounting and comprehensive information. Stalinist accounting is a mass of lies. Even the most revolutionary workers' government would need to use market mechanisms to get information about real costs and about what consumers want.

A socialist revolution cannot abolish' the market by decree any more than it can 'abolish' money, the State, or the family.

An attempt to 'abolish' the market prematurely would only be counterproductive, leading to black markets, corruption, and bureaucratic bungling. That happened not only under Stalinism buriado under cohens isme, in the also under workers decisions made by democratic planning instead of the gyrations of the Stock Exchange and the law of the devil take the hindmost.

Maybe that is what Duncan means when he writes: "Wherever market mechanisms exist, we must struggle lo place them under workers' control? His way of putting it, however, misses the point, We will need marker mechanisms to the extent that we are not able to control consciously — to the extent that we lack information, we lack technology, and shortages block the spirit of cooperation.

Gillman

Scan page 5

pence

----- pull-quotes -----

What a workers' government could do would be to have the basic strategic

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 451

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →