Cinderella and the good capitalist
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
findings. In her "Thatcher saves the world' mode, she has described the IPCC report as of *historical significance... an authoritative early-warning system" • She told UK climatologists coordinating the IPCC working group, "Your task is no less a one than to help us safeguard the future of the planet" (my incredulous emphasis).
She then announced the government's commitment to a 30% reduction in CO, emissions by 2005. True, this is only half that recommended by the experts just to stabilise present CO, levels, but it sounds more than the EC proposal... until you read the rest of the declaration.
It is 30% less than projected emissions. Since these are estimated at 25% above present levels by 2005, her grand gesture amounts to just 5% in real terms. And that only if other nations do likewise!
It is essential that the failure of governments to act adequately in the face of global warming be attacked and condemned by socialists. This means tackling thequestions of energy production and use of transport both in the Western countries, where the vast majority of CO, emissions originate, and in the Third World and Eastern Europe where much more CO, Will be released if they continue to industrialise on the Western pattern.
The danger is that, without a socialist approach, workers will carry the can, as miners in Yorkshire and Nottingham seem likely to do soon, for the polluting technologies of the boss class. Belinda Woman' Pretty Woman' seems AP like a classic Cinderella story; Vivian, a prostitute, meets a handsome billionaire who sweeps her off her feet.
But the magic works both ways in this fairy tale. The billionaire's heart is frozen solid, and he's insensitive, and it takes all of Vivian's warmth, love and honesty to turn him from a toad into a prince.
We're back in rags-to-riches American Dream territory. Vivian (Julian Roberts) takes an elevator ride to the top, but she's shown as deserving, so the books are balanced. Yes, she's a prostitute, but deep down she's really an innocent, sweet, unspoiled, slightly daffy and unsure of herself.
The plot is pretty mouldy, even for Hollywood. As ever, Vivian proves her true womanly worth by caring only for the man, and not for his money. Love is all she wants.
But can she get it? Richard Gere's billionaire looks the ideal man, but he's hardboiled, and his heart seems armour plated. He's presented as the epitome of the tough capitalist.
In the old days, the mean capitalist was the one who exploited his workers relentlessly, who never gave a thought for their welfare. The kindly capitalist on the other hand was paternalistic and concerned about his workforce. Both were exploiters, of course, but one had a conscience about it.
But in 'Pretty Woman', the old roles not longer fit. The bad capitalist is one who builds nothing, who creates nothing but wealth. He is an asset stripper, a corporate raider, someone who breaks up and sells off the corporations other capitalists have taken years to build up (on the backs of their workforces).
In *Pretty Woman' the good capitalist, on the other hand, what Gere becomes when transformed by love, is the one who builds something — cars, bridges, houses, anything, as long as it's more than a bank balance. (The fact that the bank balance grows too is never mentioned). *but fundamentally feudal, not to say monarchical, in its concept of the bond between man and his land"
The Prince didn't actually name Marconi and Ford as the villains of modern history, but there can be no doubt that his hankering after "stewardship' and geographical communities rather cuts against developments in communications, production, finance and social mobility that have taken place at least in the West) over the past 200 years. This may account for his rather diffident closing remarks: "I've certainly reached the conclusion that there are no easy answers". How true. How very very true.
I must admit that from what little I've seen and heard of Charles, I rather like him. He seems a decent sort of cove. He thinks and worries about the Big Questions - the environment, the Third World, inner city deprivation, unemployment, that sort of thing.
Apparently, as a student he toyed with the idea of joining the Labour Club and had to be talked out of it by the likes of lan Gilmour, specially bussed in to keep him on the straight and narrow. He still can't stand That Dreadful Woman', by all accounts.
The junk bond scandals and the insider dealing scams of the past few years have given American finance a bad name. The ire against the gospel of greed and against the truly obscene amounts of money dealers were making out of speculation has made Hollywood sit up and take notice. Hence 'Pretty Woman' and its presentation of the new style American capitalist — caring, concerned, a man of physical rather than (purely) monetary substance.
Most American films, beneath the romantic or comedic froth, have a sub-text. On the top, we get the sugar coating, underneath the bitter pill. In Pretty Woman' , the subtext is that American capitalism is reformable. All it takes it a little more humanity on the part of the money men, and all will be well again in Wall Street.
But again, they've put their foot in it. Gere becomes a builder all right, but of Navy war ships! Hardly the mark of humanity!
The film is fluff, but it's remarkably enjoyable. Even the men in the audience seemed entranced by it, which goes to show that, with enough sugar sprinkled on, audiences will swallow anything.
Compared to his boorish father and most of his worthless, parasitic family and in-laws, Charles certainly seems a Good Egg. But then I've always had quite a soft spot for his auntie Margaret, whom the National Union of Royal Operatives and Allied Trades should long ago have disciplined under their Bringing into Disrepute' rules.
And what about the last 'People's Prince', Edward VIII, who made a point of identifying with the unemployed and made occasional 'anticapitalist' noises? He was chummy with Oswald Moseley and Hitler had him lined up as the tame royal for Nazi Britain. At a time of crisis, who knows what manner of reaction could rally round Charles' mystical populism?
I don't propose machine-gunning him. After the revolution he should be sent out to do a proper day's work -maybe, like the last Emperor of China, he could be set to work as a gardener in the grounds of his own former palace. That would help him commune with nature.
I still think he's a Good Egg, mind you. But when a leading Communist raves about a member of the royal fami ly... well, it really is appalling.