Perestroika in Northern Ireland?
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Fight the witch-hunt!
members to associate to publish and distribute journals such as Socialist Organiser is an essential part of the democratic life of the Labour Party" Ray Carrick Dave Cliff Emma Colyer Jeremy Corby Sam Darby Ray Davison John Farrar Andrew Y Gordon Steve Hall Tony Hilda Alan Kenworth Derek Cooper Steve King Ken Livingston Christine Mallaband Gurdev Manku Anni Marjoram Steve Mitchell Paul Montero Eddie Newmar Martha Osamc Ann Poulter Roberts The Reverend lan Paisley first made his name in politics when he denounced the then Prime Minister of southern Irish counterpart Sean Lemass in 1965.
The O'Neill-Lemass talks were portrayed very effectively as the prelude to an auction of the Protestant heritage to the agents of Rome. In fact, O'Neill was aware that the whole basis of the Northern Protestant state was fast disappearing.
Numerically, the Protestant majority was in decline. Economically, the North's industries were suffering most from Britain's fading world position. Politically, the sectarian discrimination which sustained the state was no longer really tenable.
Terence O'Neill proposed to deal with this crisis by encouraging slow internal reform and a limited rapprochement with the southern Irish government. He was swept aside partly by a radical civil rights movement which demanded more thorough-going reform, but largely by a popular Protestant revolt against reform led by the fiery and far include:
Shop steward ambulances Stoke Central CLP Secretary National Secretary MP Labour councillor Manchester Secretary Honiton CLP Treasurer Stoke Central CLP Labour Party Black Section Secr Atherton Trades Council Chair Brentwater Former leader, Hackney council Wakefield CLP Vauxhall CLP Former leader council MP Stoke Central CLP women's officer Labour councillor Birmingham Secr. Women's Actior C'tee Vice-President FEUD, NUS Convenor Humberside Area NUS MEP Greater Manchester Central Former deputy leader Haringey Secretary Stoke on Trent DLP Chair Stoke Central CLP Former Asst AEU signature!
Name.
Drg/position (for identification only)
Send to PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA the right for Labour Sam Semoff Owen Sloss Mark Strong Margaret Tach Pam Tatlow Valerie Veness Pete Willsman Walter Wolfgang (Organisations only) fiercely anti-Catholic Paisley.
O'Neill was not the last to suffer Paisley's denunciations. In 1974 he saw off another Prime Minister, Brian Faulkner, for the same crime of supping with the Papish devil and agreeing to a small role for the Republic in Northern Ireland's government.
Paisley's hatred of Irish nationalism is so powerful that by 1985 no major Unionist figure could ignore the mass Protestant hostility to the Hillsborough Agreement, which again gave the Irish Republic a consultative role in Northern Ireland's affairs.
Two weeks ago, when Charles Haughey visited Belfast, lan Paisley organised a hostile "welcoming party"
All that background makes it a little surprising to read that the same lan Paisley has this week agreed to enter direct talks with representatives of the Irish government on the future of Northern by the biggest Unionist party, the OUP, led by James Molyneaux.
Peter Brooke, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, has held separate talks with the Unionist leaders, the SDLP and the Irish government in the last few months to find a way to proceed to a constitutional agreement. He couldn't get direct negotiations going, Secretary Granby Wa LP Chair Stoke on 'e on Trent DLP SERA CLP secretary, Okehampton Chair Women's C'tee Former dep lea Islington Woolwich CLP Labour CND ed for identifica 'Keep Ulster Protestant = Remember the bridge. But the Unionists are being because the Unionists' precondition is the suspension of the Hillsborough Anglo-Irish Agreement, and that is unacceptable to Irish nationalists.
What has now been agreed is a carefully planned series of talks. First, the main Unionist parties will negotiate with the leading nationalist party, the SDLP, with a view to agreeing on an internal settlement, a devolved government with considerable guarantees for nationalists, possibly powersharing. They will also discuss relations with the South.
Secondly, the Northern Ireland representatives will enter talks with the Irish government to consider the relationship between any new Northern Ireland government and the Irish Republic. It is at this stage that Paisley and Molyneaux will negotiate directly with Haughey, hence acknowledging the legitimacy of the southern interest.
Finally, the British and Irish governments will decided whether any of the new proposals Or agreements is sufficient to justify replacing the 1985 agreement. That agreement is an international treaty, and cannot be ended without the consent of both governments.
These developments are not all that surprising. We have been predicting them more or less accurately in SO since 1985, though we expected to see a bigger hardline Protestant opposition to those prepared to do deals than is manifest at present.
Unionist politics faced a major test in 1985-6. The old position of mass resistance to reform from above was repeated, but failed. Since then Protestant politics has been changing, including on the role of the Republic. 1690' is the slogan printed on pushed into a deal with Dublin Peter Brooke's talks have been a matter of finding the right form of words to make the shifting Unionist politicians seem as resolute as ever.
1985 represented a shift in British policy, too, though a shift that was germinating long before. The government needed to undermine the support abroad and in Northern Ireland for the Provisional IRA. They did it by shifting the emphasis of their policy on to constitutional nationalism.
The importance of doing deals with moderate nationalism had been recognised much earlier, above all in the power-sharing agreement of 1973-4. But that, and every other attempt to appease nationalists, was pushed aside by the likes of Paisley.
What was new in 1985 was the determination to prevent any repeat. The Anglo-Irish Agreement was set up without consulting the Northern Ireland Protestants and without relying on their consent. The Protestants could rebel as much as they liked, and the Agreement would hold as long the nerves of the two governments held.
This week's developments confirm that strategy. If no real talks with real agreement result, then London and Dublin will continue tc consult each other about Northern Ireland's government and possibly move towards joint sovereignty. li the Unionists want to avoid that, then they must agree to a form of settlement acceptable to the SDLP.
With Sinn Fein at their backs, and the Accord to fall back on, the SDLP will want a serious, substantial settlement.
Success for such a strategy could further marginalise Sinn Fein. Serious reform has always commanded widespread support among Or Northern Catholics, and the IRA has been sustained by the total failure of Britain to deliver such reform. The Provisionals' military campaign, however, is increasingly desperate and vulnerable.
They have, and will retain, a hard core of electoral support, but if they lost the West Belfast parliamentary seat in the aftermath of an agreed settlement with Dublin and the Unionists, that would be a heavy body blow.
Of course, the talks may well fail, and certainly the Provisionals will be relying on failure to keep their base. Their weakness, as ever, is that they rely on negative support coming from failed reform, alienation, and oppression, and they offer nothing positive as an alternative except the idea of resistance.
Terence O'Neill was, in a way, a Gorbachev for his time. In attempting to impose reform from above which would stabilise Unionist power, he unleashed forces much too strong for him. He became an ineffectual outsider, swept away by reactionaries and radicals.
Now, however, some of the forces unleashed then may just be leashed together again, to agree upon and advocate the sort of perestroika a more competent O'Neill might have planned.
When Terence O'Neill fell from power, John Hume was in Derry articulating long-felt nationalist grievances, while Ian Paisley was in Belfast offering to defend the Protestant faith to the end. Even the vague possibility that they could combine with the British and Irish government to put a constitutional settlement to the voters of Northern Ireland shows that the underlying problem of the 1960s was indeed the legitimacy and viability of the state.
----- pull-quotes -----
*We believe Signatories
Northern Ireland, Terence O'Neill, for meeting his
relandat in ane has toll September, and they will be joined