Stalinists into liberals
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Campaigning for the 'Democratic Bloc' (the Stalinist front) in Romania in 1946. Stalinists who thought they were fighting for democracy and Friday-Saturday-Sunday talisation which is so prominent a End that led to the Battle of Cable part of capitalism learned to live by Street in 1936 was presented as the an all-pervading set of double stan- CP's work. In fact the decisive role dards which allowed them to con- was played by the local Independent demn wholeheartedly and sincerely Labour Party and others, and the in Chile or South Africa what they Daily Worker initially called on its justified and endorsed readers not to try to stop the fascist In Britain for 60 years their "cen- "anti-fascist". Not only was the tral organ" in this work has been fact omitted that the German CP, the daily paper started on 1 January in its ultra-left period of the early 1930, known as the Daily Worker *30s, sometimes collaborated with until 1966, and as the Morning Star the Hitlerites against the Social since. It is a paper that has always Democrats (the "social fascists"), depended on Russian subsidies, but also the fact that the CPs, and open or disguised. And it has usual- the British among them, made proly been the voice of those who paid Hitler propaganda during the Even when it condemned the ting Hitler as the peaceloving victim Russian invasion of Czechoslovakia of Anglo-French imperialism. Russian invasion of Afghanistan editor/CPB) and Arena's (which is more than most Trot- "reporter" Campbell (Marxism skyists did, come to think of it), the Today/CPGB) called each other Morning Star has always, in a thou- Stalinist when it came to discussing sand ways, day in and day out, pro- the split in the early '80s. Both are misrepresenting things to the labour perhaps most clearly, despite her movement, doing public relations SDP politics. There was a great deal work for those who savagely ex- of sloppy ignorance, but also a perploited and oppressed the working vasive desire to prettify the awful class in the USSR and Eastern history. One reason why so many of Europe. these people - all over the world -But now the Russians have pulled have become liberals, or worse, is the plug on the Morning Star. In the that they can't confront the real '70s and '80s it used to sell more past of their own movement and copies to East European govern- critically re-evaluate it. day, there are different govern- something working-class, a sort of ments in Eastern Europe, and the party sectarianism, a "classist" narRussians have cancelled most of rowness. Campbell defined the Gorbachev has all the friendly a matter of devotees of class strugpress coverage he needs, thank you, gle versus people who wanted to Mr Chater, from the Sun to the base themselves on "all human more. but with no comparable good A surprisingly large number of reason, they see liberalism as the respect-worthy labour movement alternative to Stalinism - to people have given their support to themselves. Stalinism was the Mornino Star's anneal for socialism. They were "socialists" London Unio Sean Matgamna Some of the best people I have ever encountered in or anywhere else, for that matter - were Pers, that is, Stalinists, in one degree or another.
These were people who had dedicated themselves mind and limb to a cause which in its broad points of reference and ultimate goals is our own cause, the cause of socialism, and who had given everything they had to it.
They were not "selfless" in any narrow ascetic sense, but people who rejected the values and concerns of the bourgeois world around them with disdain, and who had organised their oWn lives around the working-class struggle for socialism. Or so they thought.
In fact they were people - they, and millions like them throughout the world - who had been utterly fooled and misled, whose work and dedication, whose very lives, did not at all serve the goals they wanted to serve. Served, in fact, other goals, opposite goals.
They were people so miseducated and corrupted by Stalinism that they would in certain circumstances - because of their ideas, the model of "socialism" they took as their guide from Stalin's Soviet Union, and because of the military discipline of their organisation have played the role their counterparts played in Eastern Europe, that is, help set up and staff an anti-working-class Stalinist tyranny.
Erich Honecker, the East German dictator, was also once a "good militant", an activist from early youth who spent 12 years in Hitler's jails and camps; so were most of the others who staffed the East European tyrannies at various levels for 40 years.
It is a tragic story - the British chapter of "The Great Betrayal' of the hopes and sacrifices of God knows how many tens of millions of would-be revolutionary socialists by the agents of the rulers of the Soviet Union.
It is also the story of the selfbetrayal, the semi-religious selfhypnosis, of people who should have known better, and who with some part of their minds, at least some of the time, must have known better. It changed, corrupted, and destroyed them, in almost all cases, completely.
People who set out to fight for socialism found themselves instead serving Russian foreign policy. People who set out to be revolutionaries found themselves instead far to the right of the right wing of the Waged Labour Party. In the 1930s, the Communist Party's Popular Front meant Liberal-Labour coalition, and, as Trotsky pointed out, even the Labour Party right wing were not as right wing as that. In the '40s the Popular Front was broadened to include "Progressive Tories".
People ignited by injustice to fight capitalism found themselves defending injustice all across the world wherever Stalinists ruled.
People who were propelled to fight capitalism because they could see the grotesque capitalist authoritarianism at the core of formal parliamentary democracy were trained to call black white, totalitarian dictatorship democracy, and the fight for democracy in the Soviet Union a petty bourgeois deviation" Or "Trotsky fascism"
People who revi Ited against the hypocrisy and men al compartmensocialism were to get the Causescu regime. wholeheartedly and sincerely march! wherever the CP ruled. the subsidies.
in 1968, and later, in 1979-80, the moted the interests of the rulers of right. the Soviet Union, lying and ments than to people in Britain. Totheir quota of Morning Stars.
Financial Times; he doesn't need life"! your wretched little paper any money to put itself on a new and independent basis. Are they right? Should socialists try to rescue the Morning Star?
Last Friday's Arena (BBC2), surveyed the Morning Star's 60 year history. The reporter was Beatrix Campbell of the Marxism Today faction, which split with the Morning Star some years ago and is venomously hostile to it.
Campbell - whose politics are more SDP than anything else -presented a sloppily dishonest and ignorant survey of the last 60 years. It included a characteristically dishonest, but surprisingly romanucisea, account or ine er or ine diniand anan at of the AD af tha '30s, and a tendentious and one-sided account of the faction fight -in which she was prominent — which split the CP in the '80s.
The worst of Arena's account of the CP and the Daily Worker was the selectiveness and fuzziness of the general history. Campbell talked about the Bolsheviks establishing "People's Power" in 1917. And then they formed the Communist International under that grand old slogan, "People of the World Unite!", didn't they, Ms Campbell?
The left wing mobilisation to stop the fascists marching into the East You'd think that the "30s was all Hitler-Stalin pact (1939-41), presenBoth Tony Chater (Morning Star You could see it in Campbell Stalinism was, to them, 1980s debates and split in the CP as Like millions in Eastern Europe, now socialism is utopian nonsense!
They move away from their history, rejecting it, while continuing to prettify it.
So should socialists help, and maybe rescue, the Morning Star? Tempting as it may be to side with the Morning Star faction, which has at least a pretence of some sort of working-class concerns, it would be a mistake.
There was a Russian revolutionary called Helphand, known as Parvus, who worked with the Bolsheviks, Rosa Luxemburg and Trotsky before 1914. Then he became a shameless war profiteer, accumulating vact wealth After 1917 he wanted to help the Russian Revolution, and approached Lenin and his one-time close friend Trotsky. Hard pressed, they still refused to accept his "help" "Clean hands are necessary" , they told him.
The British labour movement needs a daily paper - but a clean paper, not a paper that has swum in filth and, yes, blood, for over half a century. There is no way to wash the Daily Worker/Morning Star clean. The best contribution the Morning Star can make to the renewal of socialism is to stop publishing and disappear
----- pull-quotes -----
Workers' Liberty 1990 A weekend of socialis discussion and debate
GAINST THE PE
G Seminvil SY DELE