Defend mand reselection!
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
getting Black Sections recognised in the Labour Party. Some people spoke as if such measures were really the key to improving the position of women and black people.
Ken Livingstone opened the discussion on economic policy with his programme of cutting war spending and forcing capitalists to bring money invested abroad back to Britain. The discussion was warped by the notion that the left must propose only policies which can command a broad consensus in the Labour Party. On economic issues, today, that means that the left automatically debars itself from proposing authentically •socialist ideas. We end up with half-measures like Livingstone's, which are adequate neither as advice to John Smith nor as a programme for a working class alternative to John Smith.
A side-feature of the conference was the virtual extinction of Socialist Action as a political force. Over recent years they have slipped from producing a weekly paper to publishing a flimsy magazine once every few months. They seem to have made a full mobilisation of their forces for the LLL conference - and it amounted to about two dozen people, and no political contribution other than a couple of whacky speeches from Socialist Action editor John Ross. normal seitcuon procedure. Any time this happens it will inevitably be portrayed by the mass media as a vote of no confidence in the sitting MP.
Conference believes that this practice would be seriously and needlessly divisive. It would effectively free Labour MPs from the obligation to carry out Party policy as decided by Conference. It would also further retard the legitimate aspirations of Labour women who would lose their present right to be included in the parliamentary shortlist if nominated.
In the interests of party unity Con ference therefore resolves to uphold the principle of the automatic right ti branches to make a nominations for parliamentary candidates once in a lifetime of every parliament. By Vladimir Pete Willsman M was born of a long and andatory reselection I bitter struggle.
Its demise may be short and sweet. Proposals for its abolition will shortly be circulated.
CLPs and affiliated organisations are to be 'consulted' but irrespective of the results the NEC plans to present this rule change to 1990 Annual Conference.
As things stand, every Labour MP must go through a reselection process once during the lifetime of a parliament. This alone ensures the MP's accountability to the party which selected him or her. Without it MPs will be under no obligation to carry out the policies decided by the Party.
Mandatory reselection was introduced after the experiences of the 1964-70 and 1974-70 Labour governments. These governments ignored the interests of organised labour and the policies of Party Conference. This led to the 1979 winter of discontent, the Labour government's downfall and more than a decade of Tory rule.
We understand that under the NEC proposals, a sitting MP would automatically be adopted unless a fity per cent majority of individual members of the CLP, in a postal ballot, demand that a reselection procedure be invoked. If this is true it would mean no reselections at all. The turn-outs in contested reselections in Labour-held seats have been about twenty percent: to get fity per cent in favour of a reselection would be highly unlikely.
Before mandatory reselection was introduced in 1979 any attempt by a CLP to change its MP resulted in protracted infighting and damaging media coverage. The 1970s reselections Lincoln, Newham North East, Hammersmith and Sheffield Brightside CLPs all testify to this.
But the NEC proposals go much further than the pre-1979 rules. Under the old rules, the General Committee of a CLP by a majority vote, could ask the NEC to invoke the reselection procedure. This hardly ever occurred and when it did, it took at least six months of 'Now the NEC wants to return to return to the situation where MPs were the only officeholders in the party without accountability massive aggro to deselect. Nevertheless under the NEC's present proposals even MPs like Reg Prentice - later a Tory minister -would still be Labour MP for Newham North East.
The NEC suggest mandatory reselection should be dropped because: "Significant difficulties are anticipated in ensuring necessary voting attendance by MPs in the House of Commons whilst the reselection procedure is taking place in their consituencies, and they need to be frequently absent on week nights' (Is this why TV viewers so often see an empty chamber?)
When Labour is in government mandatory reselection becomes essential. For it is then that the gap between the Parliamentary Labour Party and rank and file Party andtrade union members widens. The last Labour government made Party members realise that unless the PLP is accountable to the Party, itwill move away from the people it claims to represent. Mandatory reselection is the only safeguard against this. It preserves a measure of unity between Labour MPs and those who sent them to Parliament.
Whatever the NEC's motives, the effect of its 'reform' would be to cut off 'sitting' MPs from rank and file opinion and allow the next Labour government to adopt measures which - as in 1978-79 -would lead to a revolt by organised labour and would bring the government down.
Mandatory reselection has run smoothly for 10 years. Now the NEC wants to return to the situation where MPs were the only office-holders in the Party without accountability. The leadership lectures CLPs on 'One Member One Vote', ', but under the new proposals the only 'vote' that will count will be that of the "sitting' MP,on whether he wishes to continue as MP or not.
Abandoning mandatory reselection would also perpetuate the present white male middle class domination of the PLP. The tiny progress made in getting more women and black MPs was largely thanks to it.
Most trade unions remain bound by their conference decisions to support mandatory reselection.
Every individual and affiliated Party member should be made aware that what is at stake is the PLP's accountability to the Party, the Party's links with the trade unions and the fate of the next Labour Government. CLPs should choose this issue for their Conference Resolution.
Reprinted from CLPD Newsletter, May 1990.