Don't apologise f Stalinism Stalinism
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
this week's News of the World, under "Wicked Mum's Sex Show in Jail" , you will find some interesting for them, embarrassing statistics.
The result of the News of World's survey asking if its readers prefer to call homosexuals 'poofters' 'pansies' red.
This was true both among homosexuals themselves (nearly 70%), and among heterosexuals (27.8%, which put it top).
The Sunday tabloid's daily sister, the Sun, has of course just been done by the Press Council for insisting the use of the word 'poofter' was justifiec in the name of the public popularity of that word.
The survey was supposed to prove the Sun's point.
How to get out of that one? "This proves," the News of the World comments, "that you lie, its readers) aren't all intolerant bigots, as suggested by last week's Oxford don (ie, the Press Council)"
Who said tabloids had sense?
ETTERS Sylvia Bolgar (letters, SO 449) says that capitalism needs foreign markets to survive, and would therefore not survive were it not for the new markets being opened up in the USSR and Eastern Europe.
She says that the October Socialist Revolution's chief significance, and that of later "socialist" revolutions, was in taking parts of the world outside the market. The forum for capitalist expansion was gradually decreased, and capitalism, presumably, pushed towards its final crisis.
This is a rather crude version of a theory rarely aired these days, namely Rosa Luxemburg's theory of imperialism.
It's wrong on several counts. First, capitalism experienced its greatest ever expansion after World War Two - precisely at the time when, according to Sylvia Bolgar, one third of the world had been rescued from the capitalist market. If her theory were right, instead of expanding, capitalism should have been collapsing.
Capitalist expansion does not depend, in the crude way defined by Bolgar (or even in the way defined by Luxemburg) on foreign markets (Luxemburg specified that they had to be non-capitalist markets, hence the drive to colonial conquest).
Second, Eastern Europe has never been simply cut off from the world market. Nor is it especially desirable that it should be. International capitalist integration needs to be replaced not by lots of countries splitting away from the world market to build up their own economies, but by international socialist integration.
Finally, the collapse of capitalism does not depend on the mechanical contraction of the world market, even if this were the result of socialist or Stalinist revolutions. Socialist revolution depends on the organisation and consciousress of the working class. Our benchmark should be not whether or not the market is expanding, but whether or not the conditions are improved for the independent action of the working class.
The opening up of the Stalinist states to Western capital (and domestic private capital is not something we support. But the crisis of Stalinism and the class struggle which is accompanying and will accompany the changes in the East provide fresh chances for building independent working-class, socialist movements.
That is the real significance of what is happening.
Socialists will get nowhere if we pretend that the system which is being destroyed was in some way preferable to capitalism, or appear to the workers of Eastern Europe as apologists for that system.
We have to be the champions of a new alternative to both.
Gerry Bates, Southwark.
----- pull-quotes -----
'queers', 'shirtlifters' , or gay' was that 'gay' was by far prefer