[Will there be a war and Iraq, there…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Will there be a war and Iraq, there is a war fever.
Children in Israeli schools are learning how to use gas masks, because of the threat by Iraq's Saddam Hussein to use chemical weapons against Israeli cities like Tel Aviv. In Iraq there seems to be considerable support for a war with Israel, despite the terrible hardships of the only recently ended war with Iran.
Each country has the capacity to do terrible damage to the other. Iraq's readiness to use chemical weapons is not a matter for speculation. Towns in Iran, and areas in Iraq populated by the Kurdish minority, have first-hand experience of how ruthless the Saddam Hussein regime can be. Thousands of Kurds fled bombardment of their villages with mustard gas at the end of 1988.
And Israel has nuclear weapons.
If both sides acted upon their current bloodthirsty threats, large parts of both populations would be annihilated. Other Arab states have expressed their will to join with Iraq in any war, so the destruction could be limitless.
Clearly the superpowers could not just stand by and wait for the war to end. The United States at least would get involved. The USSR maybe has enough problems of its own right now, although "saving the world" might be a heaven-sent diversion for its government.
These days the superpowers would probably act in concert, so their intervention would not mean World War Three. But that is little comfort for the thousands or millions of people who could die in a Middle East war.
W The statements of Arab hy the war-mongering?
leaders suggest desperation at the failure of negotiations to lead to a settlement of the Palestinian question.
They seem to be saying that with one more war they could sort it out once and for all.
But the calculation is absurd. It is possible that a substantial military defeat for Israel would force its government to make concessions on the occupied territories. "Land for peace" could be secured by force. That is what happened in 1973. The Arabs, after their *The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Newsdesk: 071-639 7965 Latest date for reports: first post Monday wished by WL Publications Ltd Box 823, London SE15 4NA Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU)
Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Signed articles do not ecessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser humiliation notice of them. Evehe forced the USA to take tually Egypt won Sinai back as a result.
But chemical or nuclear warfare will not lead to a harmonious or stable peace! And in any case, the Arab states have spent nearly two decades working towards a negotiated settlement. Some have worked harder at it, like Egypt; others, notably Libya, have opposed the project. But diplomacy has been the consensus.
The USA is more likely than ever before to opt for a settlement favourable to what the Arab governments see as their interest, that is, some sort of Palestinian state. A war costly both in dollars and lives would be an immense risk for the Arab governments as well as the people of the region.
For Iraq, you might think, that is even more true. It has just tinished eight years of war with Iran, war which Saddam promised would be over swiftly, leaving Iraq as the region's dominant power, favoured by imperialism, raking in cash from its oil exports and the support of other rich Arab governments.
Why fight another war with even less prospect of success?
One theory has it that Saddam Hussein is mad. But there are rational explanations. Iraq became over the last decade a society geared completely to the pursuit of war. Contrary to expectations, Saddam's failure to secure a quick victory did not lead to his downfall. He survived the war. His regime, one of the mostly completely totalitarian in the world, is intact.
Be needs wars. He needs the dovishness. Israel can't give anything to the Palestinians, it argues - except repression -because Israel's security depends on its continued occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, especially the West Bank.
Without the West Bank, Arab armies could cut Israel in two in one quick movement. Give an inch, and you give a nation state.
Saddam's bloodcurdling threats are all Shamir needs to form a majority government. You might think they were planning it together.
Shamir's political tradition, it may be relevant to recall, thinks the Jewish state ought to extend to the river Euphrates, in Iraq (which is the ideological reason for hanging on to the occupied territories: they don't accept that the Palestinians have any right to them).
Thus the warmongering serves a valuable role as an internal political weapon. In reality, neither side can much afford a war, especially the Iraqis. Sir 9n, Expis president o is it all hype? Even if it is, In 1967, Egypt's president Nasser provoked war with Israel, although almost certainly he didn't really want to go through with it, and he dramatically lost it.
If you yell from the rooftops your intention to crush the "Zionist entity" enough times, there comes a point when you can no longer retreat. Saddam also might find it hard to be the president who cried wolf.
Similarly, if you make the military threat posed by Iraq central to your political calculations, you might have to do what Shamir's Likud predecessor, Menahem Begin, did, and bomb Iraqi military installations. Saddam might then be forced to do more than protest to the United Nations.
So the hype could become reality. The people who can stop that are; in the first place, the people of Iraq and Israel.
An Israel which recognised the rights of the Palestinian Arab people to their own state would cut the political ground from under Saddam Hussein: after all, there is no pretext for Iraq to go to war with Israel except the Palestinians. The less democratic Israel is in its treatment of the Palestinians, the more it is at risk.
Equally, if the Iraqi people manage to throw off the tyrant's yoke, Shamir won't have any excuse to blow them up.
Easier said than done. In the meantime, we have to apply all the pressure we can to stop a Middle East war. It would be a war from which no-one could gain, and everyone would lose. If it is an old-fashioned conventional conflict, the likely result will be Israeli occupation of Jordan. If it is the horrifying slaughter with chemical and nuclear weapons that the governments are threatening, who knows what the result could be?
Justice for the Palestinians! Israel out of the West Bank and Gaza! No war in the Middle East! M Clive Bradley dealt estimable colleague more than adequately with the Gary Bushell - 'poofters' business a couple of weeks ago and comment from me seemed superfluous. This week I had intended to discuss Mad Cow Disease, a subject I find marginally less stomach-churning than having to write (or even think) about Mr Bushell. But there have been further developments. I cannot shirk my duty The far: Gary Bushell, neanderthal TV reviewer' on the Sun was reported to the Press Council over use of word poofter'; reversing previous decisions, the council found in favour of the complainant; Mr Bushell announced that in future he would use different words... like "shirt-lifters' and "stoopers'; a Sun editorial dismissed the Press Council as "a bunch of loonies"
Since then, it has been Open Season on the Press Council and its Chairman Louis Blom Cooper. The Daily Mail and the Mail on Sunday have been particularly vociferous in their attacks. This Sunday, for instance, Sir John Junor (who shares Bushell's homophobia but has the advantage of being at least semiliterate) denounced the "poofter" decision as "utter idiocy" and "only one of many recent examples of absolutely tacky adjudications" • Junor went on the claim that Blom Cooper only got the job "by default" and called for him to be sacked and replaced by "someone of rather more calibre"
I suppose that its no use trying to warn the likes of Gary Bushell and John Junor. They have been warned many times before but still the message does not seem to have sunk in: they are slowly and surely making a noose for their own necks. The Press Council and the voluntary system of self-regulation that it represents is their only hope of warding off legislation to control the press. The demand for statutory controls has been gaining momentum for some time. Last year, Private Members Bills proposing a legal "right of reply" and a "protection of privacy" Act, commanded widespread public support and were only defeated after frantic lobbying by the industry. As a result Home Secretary Hurd warned the press that "it was on probation" and the commit. tee under David Calcutt QC was sent off to look into the whole question of press standards and possible controls.
For a short while, towards the end of last year, it looked as though the press was really trying to clean up its act -papers appointed 'Ombudsmen' to investigate complaints, Rupert Murdoch announced that in future his papers would reflect his own new found spirituality, Robert Maxwell sacked Wendy Henry... but it couldn't last. Coverage of the Strangeways riot marked a new nadir in hysterical, lurid and inaccurate reporting. A Daily Telegraph last month warned that tabloids' form virtually guaranteed that legislation was back on the agenda.
Meanwhile one of the less emphasised parts of the Labour Party's Policy Review Document is the proposal for a statutory body with powers to enforce a
----- pull-quotes -----
Provocateur or moron PRESS GIANIG