Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Mad mogs and Englishmen T bovine spongiform

Socialist Organiser no. 449, 24 May 1990 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 2,325 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Stormont parliament were both abolished. Torture in police stations was restricted.

The main local security forces then shifted to a shoot-to-kill policy and, more recently, collusion with Loyalist murder gangs to assassinate suspected Republican sympathisers.

When the British government was forced to launch an investigation into the RUC shoot-to-kill policy, it was sabotaged by non-cooperation and its leader, John Stalker, smeared and removed.

Collusion between the RUC, UDR and Loyalist paramilitaries was easier to hide. At least, it was until the Loyalists decided to expose the whole murderous game.

After killing an innocent Catholic two years ago, the main paramilitary group, the UDA, revealed that they had received his name and address from RUC security documents. It was a story which grew and grew.

Photocopied documents with lists of Republican suspects, photos and personal details, appeared everywhere from newspaper editors' in-trays to gable-end walls in Protestant East Belfast.

The government were forced again to launch the now traditional "full and frank inquiry". Last week the Stevens inquiry reported its findings.

Full and frank? The Guardian captured the flavour of the document in a characteristic understatement. "The contrast between the strength of the evidence and the nature of Mr Stevens' conclusions will fuel debate. " Indeed.

The inquiry recovered 2,600 documents from Loyalist groups, containing sensitive information on suspects and Republican sympathisers. This material came from people with legitimate access to the RUC, and given the record of the police in Northern Ireland, there will be plenty of material not recovered.

The Stevens team described the information as low-level, which is probably their measure of the par ucular lives put at r vice was ignored.

The conclusion drawn by the inquiry is astonishingly complacent. Collusion, says Stevens, is not widespread or institutional. "The regiment," says Peter Brooke, 'is fundamentally sound."

This despite Stevens' own findings that there is a network of leaks linking the UDR and Loyalist paramilitaries which will probably never be eliminated.

The recommendations of the Stevens report are feeble and almost beside the point.

They suggest: (1) stronger RUC vetting; (2) an explanation will be necessary "at senior officer level" if the army is to ignore RUC vetting; (3) UDR members should make legally binding declarations that they are not members of Loyalist paramilitaries.

It is what the report doesn't say that is really important. There are to be no prosecutions of RUC members even though that is the source of these leaks. 28 UDR members were arrested in October.)

There is no reply to or comment on Loyalist allegations that most of the leaks were officially sanctioned, and that the security forces used them as surrogates to wipe 'out Republicans.

The central, and entirely justified, nationalist demand for disbandment of the UDR is, of course, not even considered. Many of the officers of that regiment responsible for these leaks and the many associated murders are still in position.

It should be remembered that this whole matter only came to light because the UDA chose to expose it.

Am I jumping to conclusions with inadequate evidence? As a lefty with a nationalist background I am not disposed to believe the government side of these stories.

An instructive contrast should be made, however, between the standards of proof required in cases of suspected Republicans and those required in cases of security force crime.

first, Guildford The latest twist in the encephalopathy saga (apart from John Gummer's public force-feeding of a beefburger to his small daughter) is the diagnosis of a BSE-like disorder in two pet cats.

After developing a neurological disease, the cats were put down and on post-mortem examination found to have a spongy degeneration of the brain similar to that found with scrapie and BSE.

Vets report other suspected cases which are being investigated. If this is a case of mad moggie disease, then this adds another species to the list of those that have been infected with the sheep disease, scrapie, or its equivalent in cows, BSE.

So far, the list includes goats, antelopes, mink, hamsters and mice, in addition to sheep and cows. The mice were infected by feeding them with masive amounts of brain tissue from infected animals. However, most have been affected through protein supplements to their feed which have contained sheep offal, brain, spinal cord, spleen, etc., infected with the scraple agent.

Though this somewhat unnatural practice has now officially stopped, it is not known what incubation period the disease has and so it cannot be reliably predicted how many cases of BSE will ultimately occur. Already, some 13,000 cattle have been found to have BSE.

Neither is it known whether the victims will be able to pass on the disease to their offspring or their fellow animals (as is the case with scrapie); in other words, whether the disease will become a permanent feature of cow populations even after the original source has been cut off.

Still less is it known whether the disease can be passed to those who consume cows and their products. Since the organism responsible for scrapie and BSE has not yet been identified, it is impossible to say whether it is present or absent in milk or meat. Neither is it possible to say whether it is present in the brain or other organs of an infected but symptomless creature.

The argument that it has not spread to humans during 200 years of scrapie in sheep is hardly reassuring, given its sudden spread to other species in the last few years. It may well be that the organism has mutated or been transformed during its passage through the cow. It seems there are about 20 variants of the BSE organism, supporting the theory that it is evolving tast.

What should be done? The chances of human disease resulting from BSE would appear to be exceedingly small, but the consequences would be devastating for the victims.

The feeding of sheep to cows (and of chickens to chickens), dictated by the cut-throat economics of modern agriculture, should be stopped. After all, it was only when soya-based protein supplements became more expensive that this revolting practice became common and it seems there were no regulations to stop it. Pet food manufacturers say they stopped using possibly infected cattle offal last year.

Intensive research should be funded to develop a test for BSE inrection. In the absence of this. careful observation of cows behaviour should be made to see if early signs of BSE infection are evident, as they are in sheep with scrapie.

In the meantime, the suggestion of leading BSE researcher Professor Richard Barlow that calves of BSE cows be marked and monitored should be taken up, otherwise there will be no way of seeing if BSE is passed on to offspring.

The BSE story has highlighted how the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food has failed to protect the interests of the poor bloody consumer. Even now, the Ministry's response has been the unreassuring public utterances of the buffoon Gummer, coupled with vicious attacks, under the cloak of parliamentary privilege, on those scientists, such as public health specialist Professor Richard Lacey and neuropathologist Dr Helen Grant, who have called for a cull of all cattle born to BSE cows.

MAFF's policy, changed only in February, of paying only 50% compensation for cattle slaughtered after diagnosis of BSE, may well have led to the entry of BSE beef into the food chain as farmers quite understandably covered up their suspicions of illness. Certainly, the reported cases jumped by over half after this.

MAFF's policy on calves of BSE cows was shown to be against EC requirements which ban the export of calves to EC countries even if the disease is only suspected in their mothers. However, in Britain, calves may still be marketed without restriction.

Another issue is that, despite bans on offal that might carry the BSE organism, such offal may still be getting into food. This is because current slaughterhouse practice allows the use of chainsaws to cut open carcases down the length of the spine, splashing the rest of the meat with bits of spinal cord. In addition, methods of 'mechanically recovering' meat are used particularly around the vertebral column which contains the spinal cord.

I'm glad I'm a vegetarian!

Scan page 11

By Sleeper H week campaign (the as the CSEU's shorter'Drive for 35') all been a waste of time. More to the point, has the campaign played into the hands of the employers by giving them a heaven-sent opportunity to introduce far-reaching changes in working practices which will more than offset the cost of the hours reductions?

This is the view of a lot of militants and accounts, in part, for the left's general lack of enthusiasm for the campaign right from the start. Some support for this point of view is given by a survey published this week by Industrial Relations Services' , one of those mysterious organisations that provides 'intelligence' for the thinking Industrialist.

IRS says, "Some union members may wonder if the hours' cuts are worth the greatly increased producivity being contributed by them to employers"

Of the 46 agreements analysed by IRS, 15 recouped some of the hours costs by reducing tea breaks and washing-up time and by enforcing bell-to-bell working. Other firms hope to offset their costs through more flexible working arrangements like multi-machine operation and multi-skilling. A few have taken the opportunity to introduce flexible shift working and weekend shifts.

Only 5 of the firms questioned by IRS say they will fund at least some of the hours reductions. Bonas Machine (a textile machinery manufacturer) conceded the first hour of two hour reduction "without corresponding productivity gains being required)" . Cascade (UK) said that some working practices have already changed significantly, it could not recoup costs by that route. It agreed to a 2 hour cut anyway, to remain in the Leagur quarter of the renumerations UDOCE So have those union activists who poured scorn on the campaign all along been proved right? Perhaps not. For one thing, gaffers answering questions in a gaffer's survey (ie, not something very likely to be read on the shop floor) are likely to want to put as good a gloss on their tough negotiation skills as they can.

But even if we accept that the IRS survey is broadly accurate, it still doesn't tell the whole story. A cut in basic hours is a virtually irreversible gain for the workforce, whereas matters like flexibility, rest times and even shift patterns are subject to the level of confidence and organisation that exists on the shop floor at any given time. IRS itself concedes that, "tea breaks and washing up time have a habit of reappearing however definitely they are bargained away"

The 1979 National Engineering Agreement that reduced basic hours from 40 to 39, was accompanied by a flexibility campaign very like the kind of things employers are pushing for now - in fact the reason employers are still pushing for them is precisely because these commitments were widely resisted and often remained a dead letter after 1979. In just the same way, every Ford agreement in recent years has involved extensive commitments to flexibility and productivity increases, many of which the company has been unable to implement in practice.

The other factor that IRS (and the union militants who simply dismiss the hours campaign leave out of their calculations is the tenacity with which some groups of workers have fough for the hours reduction and against the strings. This has led to considerable variations in agreements even within companies. At BAe Kingston, For instance, a 23-week strike succeeded in securing a significantly better deal, with less far-reaching strings, than the agreements reached at BAe plants like Chester and Preston, where less of a fight was put up.

None of this, of course, should be used to obscure the fact that many of the deals reached by the Confed, have been pretty rotten and many bear more than a passing resemblance to the sort of deals proposed by the employers and backed by Bill Jordan) as early as 1987. We should also not forget that quite often (as at Rover this month) workers will chuck out even major hours cuts because of strings like anti-social shift patterns. But that doesn't mean the hours struggle has been waste of time (still less, as some union militants have suggested, has it simply played into management's hands'). "Strings' can be fought, line-by-line, on the shop floor; an hours cut, like diamonds, is forever. mixed ba!

(DH HQ)

T Association (CPSA) confer- he Civil and Public Services Hence in Bournemouth last week was a mixed bag for the left.

The Broad Left did badly in Regional, Section and National elections. In a postal election for the NEC, in which only 20% of the membership participated, the right wing swept the board. The Broad Left won only 3 places, an improvement on last year's one.

A 20% turn-out can hardly said to reflect the membership. This was shown by the fact that the left won important victories on conference floor on issues such as homeworking (supported in principle by the right wing, totally opposed by the left) and Agencies (Civil Service privatisation).

The Agencies vote was a blow for the right wing, who have ignored conference policy to fight Agencies since 1988. Although the motion passed was not the best on Agencies (it failed to call for a national framework and fudged the issue of industrial action) the debate clearly showed that members want to fight Agencies, even if the NEC don't.

Even more distressing for the NEC was the fact that the Branches Against Agencies (BAA) fringe meeting was attended by over 200 delegates and observers. BAA — set up as a branchbased rank and file initiative to organise a fight against Agencies in the face of the NEC's refusal to do so - has at-

----- pull-quotes -----

LESTAlEARNES SICJENICE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 449

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →