Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Another turn on the Jewish-Arab conflict

Socialist Organiser no. 449, 24 May 1990 · scan p. 8 · Sean Matgamna · about 2,346 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Like a well-written book, istory sometimes pauses to provide a concise summary encapsulating what has gone before, spread out over many decades or centuries.

Right now we seem to be living through the summary chapter in which is recapitulated the tragedy of the Jews in the 19th and 20th centuries, and the linked tragedy of the prolonged Middle-East conflict between the Palestinian Arabs and the Jewish refugees from European It is as if a selection of the events which opened with the Russian pogroms against Jews in 1881 and after and led by way of the Holocaust to the foundation of Israel, and now to the continuing Arab-Jewish conflict, being paraded before our eyes in this summary chapter.

We see a vast wave of Judeophobia sweep across the USSR and its former satellites, as if some lethal virus long frozen, like so much else, inside the Stalinist icefield, has been freed in the general thaw.

Compared with this raw, bareknuckled, strutting, unashamed, rampant, grave-desecrating and would-be Jew-killing new strain of anti-semitism, the old official antisemitism of the Stalinist states seems to be a refined slow poison So it was; except that the "subtle" official anti-semitism kept the Nazigened strain and prepared past we have first seen Enoch Powell make "thoughtful" and "civilised" racist speeches, and then seen the racist thugs in the East End of London "translate" Powell into knifings and bootings of Asians.

In Russia, then as now, after the assassination of Tsar Alexander in 1881 there was a great eruption of anti-Jewish feeling. Then it was directly encouraged by the State and organised by the officiallybacked Union for the Salvation of Russia, the so-called Black Hundreds.

There followed a tremendous awakening of the Jews, and the migration of millions of them westward to the shores of the Atlantic and across it to the Americas. And then, a new growth of anti-Jewish feeling across Europe, traditional Christian anti-Jewish attitudes mixing and overlapping with a newer hostility defined, in line with the intensified nationalism of the West, in terms of ethnicity and The French Revolution had swept away the old medieval obstructions of religion and caste, created citizenry, of all religions and none, equal before the law, and finally cleared away the walls of the ghettoes in West Germany; nevertheless, it was in France that virulent anti-semitism made itself most felt in the West.

The "Dreyfus Affair", in which a French Jewish officer was wrongy convicted of spying (for Germany) put France in political uproar for a decade. Left and right divided for and against Dreyfus, for and against the right of Jews to equal treatment as citizens, for and against the idea that a Jew could be a French citizen.

Someone plausibly said of the conventional military man, Alfred Dreyfus, that had he not been Dreyfus he would never have been a Dreyfusard (supporter of Dreyfus). Jews who, like Dreyf, were all for assimilation, were made to feel uncomfortable and not quite equal. The German Jewish community, the oldest and most thoroughly assimilated of all, would feel this too in coming decades.

It was the Dreyfus affair that turned the passionate Austrian assimilationist Theodor Herzl into a Zionist - convinced him that the Jews would never be "accepted" in the world, never be secure until they had a country of their own. More to the point, Dreyfus and the continuing pogroms in the Tsar's empire ensured that large numbers of Jews began to feel the same way. Herzl's seed fell fertile among the Jewish people.

Still, only a small number of Jews were Zionist at the beginning of this century. By mid-century, events compared to which the Tsarist Russian pogroms seemed the furnishings of an innocent bygone age — the systematic Nazi murder of six million Jews — would have converted the big majority of the world's surviving Jews into Zionists, living in or identifying with Israel, convinced that the existence of Israel was their only guarantee against anti-semitism in the future.

Jerusalem had a central place in the religious history of the Jews, the notional commitment to go there a central place in the emotionalreligious life of Jews and Jewish communities. A weak Jewish community had continued over the centuries to exist in Palestine, tolerated as an inferior community by the controlling Muslims. Now an organised, politically-motivated Jewish immigration began, at first a weak trickle.

"In 1939, on the eve the great European slaughter of six million Jews, Britain forbade The immigrants who thrived were socialists. Many of them organised themselves in big utopian-socialist farming communities, the kibbutzim.

They came not to exploit Arabs, but to build up their own Jewish communities, depending on their own labour. They formed a colony unlike those typical in Africa, where the colonists were a thin upper social layer of exploiters, but more like the colonies in the USA, Argentina, or Australia, where a whole society was transplanted and displaced the previous population.

Whatever the early socialistZionist colonists wanted - and they couldn't have wanted it - that was the logic of their enterprise. Ironic Palestinian-Arab comment afterwards put it this way, contrasting Zionism with other colonising enterprises which exploited the "natives": there was one thing worse than colonial exploitation, and that was not being exploited.

The Zionist colony grew steadily: In 1917 the British government committed itself to allowing the setting-up of a "Jewish national home" in Palestine, while safeguarding the rights of the Arabs. Britain's rulers believed that a Jewish state could be a little loyal Jewish Ulster" , a reliable ally in the Middle East. They could not have been more mistaken.

The Zionist colonists bought land from the feudalistic Arab landlords, clearing off the Arab tenants, and reclaimed barren land. The first big Arab-Jewish clashes occurred in 1919, focused on the issue of religious precedence in Jerusalem. Fear of Jewish colonists eventually becoming dominant, economic rivalry, Muslim religious bigotry, all combined to poison Arab-Jewish relations. The rich who sold land to the Zionists also agitated against the Jews.

The advent of Hitler transformed the Jewish colony, with a vast infusion of refugees and capital. Britain and the Jewish community allied against the prolonged PalestinianSyrian Arab uprising of 1936 and after. Then, alarmed at Arab hostility, Britain betrayed the Zionists in the hour of the Jews greatest need.

In 1939, on the eve of the grea European slaughter of six millior Jews, Britain forbade Jewish immigration into Palestine, except for a derisory handful. Faced with the visibly gathering forces of annihilation, the mortally threatened Jews of Europe had nowhere to go: no country would open its gates wide, or wide enough; many kept their gates shut and barred against the Jews.

To take a terrible example, one shipload of Jews left Europe on the eve of war for the Americas, and, hostile coasts op North and South after sailing and down the America, could get permission to land nowhere. The war had started, but they had to return to Europe. Most of them died there at the hands of the Nazis. In France, the heroes of the anti-Dreyfusards were in power in the area not occupied by the Nazis. They rounded up the Jews for the Nazi exterminators.

Hostility or indifference to the Jews did not end with Hitler's death. Two years after the war, tens of thousands of Jews were still in camps in Europe. No country would take them. Britain would not let them go to Palestine. In Eastern Europe, Jews returning home from Nazi near-extermination met with stark hostility and - dozens of them - murder.

The Jewish colony in Palestine was now a nation, with its own developed economy, territory, language, history, and identity, living still under British control in a sea of Arab hostility.

Most of the Jews had backed Britain in the war; a small minority started a struggle for independence from Britain: a handful of political imbeciles, among them, it seems, Yitzhak Shamir, thought they could work with the Germans because they were the enemy of their enemy, the British. The main Palestinian Arab leaders worked with the Nazis, trying to organise a fighting force to ally with Hitler.

Relations between the Jewish nation and Britain, which was still balancing between Jews and Arabs, become hostile OVeL Britain's refusal to let Jewish "displaced persons" from Europe into Palestine.

In 1947 Britain gave up, and the United Nations agreed to partition Palestine into Jewish and Arab states. The Jews agreed, the Arabs refused. The establishment of the state of Israel in May 1948 was met with a large-scale Arab invasion from Jordan, Syria, Iraq, Egypt, in some cases under British officers. They said they were aiding the Palestinian Arabs; far from it, as it turned out.

Their goal was to conquer and destroy the Jewish state and its population. But the Arab states, then mainly decrepit and ramshackle monarchies, lost the war. The victorious Israelis drove the Arabs out of part of their UN. allotted territory. They still had the West Bank - until it was annexed by Jordan in 1949.

Something over half a million Arabs were made refugees in that war. Perhaps three quarters as many Jews were driven out of Arab countries in the next few years and went to Israel.

It was, in abstract balance Dreyfus sheet, not too far off an equitable exchange of population. Excepi that the Arab refugees were left to languish in refugee camps, consigned to indefinite refugee existence both by the sluggish economies of their host Arab states and by Arab governments concerned to preserve the refugee camps as an argument against acceptance of Israel's existence. Feeble attempts in the '50s by prominent Israelis like President Weizmann to do something to solve the refugee problem were met with complacent indifference by Prime Minister Ben Gurion. The refugees' numbers multiplied to their present four million.

Israel, surrounded by enemies, became an armed camp, and sought international alliances. In June 1967 an Egyptian blockade of an Israeli port triggered a war in which Israel shattered the Arab armies of Jorcapied the West Bank and GazaPre-1948 Palestine was now once more reunited, but under Israeli The consequence was that the Palestinian Arabs now asserted their independence from the Arab governments. The Palestine Liberation Organisation became a force.

Formally it disavowed the old Arab nationalist programme of "driving the Jews into the sea" , but it demanded nothing less than the self-destruction, self-disarming, and surrender of Israel, and Israeli agreement that the Jews would assume a subordinate position in an Arab democratic secular state of all Palestine. In fact such a demand was something completely unrealistic for the Palestinian Arabs to achieve, and in practice could be nothing more than an ideological justification for the military subjugation of Israel by the surrounding Arab states.

The PLO and other groups conducted a sort of international guerilla war against Israel, often indefensibly focusing on soft civilian targets.

Israel has now been in occupation of the West Bank four years longer than Israel had existed in 1967 There has been a sizeable growth of Israeli settlement amidst the Arabs of the West Bank. Israeli politics have been dominated for a dozen years by the would-be expansionist right, by people intent on repeating the experience of the first four decades of this century in the West Bank, and ultimately displacing the Arabs there.

The intifada recreates the 1936-9 uprising. And now the horrendous eruption of anti-semitism Europe, together with the liberalisation of emigration rules in the JSSR and its former satellites, Seems to throw us backwards in history by 60, or even 100, years.

Hundreds of thousands of Jews, perhaps millions, want to go from the USSR, to flee the hatred and the threats, as their relatives and ancestors went after 1881. But they have no place to go but Israel. The USA won't let them in.

Their only option is... the Jewish state. And where exactly! The expansionist right want them as demography fodder on the West Bank. No wonder the Palestinian Arabs are alarmed. No wonder the plague-like spread of Judeophobia across Europe alarms the Jews. They have never felt quite secure with the smug liberal post-war certainty that mass-murdering antisemitism could not happen again, and they have welded the idea of strae, into their Jewish state, collective consciousness.

So we have all the elements -apart so far from mass murder, but the Jews today operate with the indelible memory of mass murder, and Israel operates with a ruthlessness sustained by that memory. We have rampant and growing anti-semitism, migration of Jews, influx into Israel/Palestine, Arab resistance, intensified JewishArab conflict.

The action of the Jewish lunatic who murdered Arab building workers last Sunday - in the sort of incident inflicted on both Northern Ireland communities more than once in the last 20 years - was the spark which triggered the present clashes, but only the spark.

What the astonishing upsurge of Judeophobia all across Europe says to us is that the Jews haven't been wrong; that the Jews who looked for security in their own state weren't wrong, even though their solution would not have been our first choice of solution, and even though nothing is secure until there is peace with the Palestinian Arabs on the basis of justice for both peoples.

The solution is the programme now common to the Israeli left and, since the mid-'80s, also the PLO: two states for the two nations who live in Israel/Palestine.

But between us and that solution stands the intransigent expansionist faction in Israel, and the upsurge of anti-semitism which is once more sending masses of Jews in search of a home and which may well make them willing to join the Ariel Sharons and Yitzhak Shamirs in a protracted attempt to make that nome on the West Bank.

Is this, after all, a freak summary chapter, recapitulating the awful past, or the beginning of a prolonged new display of proof that God is an incorrigibly and implacably malign old bastard!

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST TU TIDE

Jewish immigration int Palestine, except for derisory handful."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 449

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →