New evidence undermines pe
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
can suspects...possibly know what facts they 'may wish to rely on in court"? At this stage, few will be fully aware of the allegations against them."
"The Tory government has made Britain a far more authoritarian, undemocratic place to live than it used to be, and far worse than mo of the rest of Western Europe."
But complaining about police behaviour is unlikely to get you very tar, it you are questioned aggressively or otherwise mistreated while in custody, or it you are beaten up by the police on a demonstration.
A delegate to the Police Federation Conference in 1988 summed up police attitudes to the Police Complaints AuthoriPOLIC ty, describing it as a "load of middle-class wallies". Lawyers often advise clients not to cooperate with 1, the police complaints system, because, as Louise Christian puts it, of *bitter experience of the way in which the system is manipulated to the advantage of police defendants in a civil action" (Socialist Lawyer, Winter/ Spring 1989)
Thus police officers have been acquitted in cases involving deaths or serious injuries: John Shorthouse, Stephen Waldorf, Cherry Groce; the police didn't take action at all after the death of Cynthia Jarrett. No one was ever convicted for the death of Blair Peach. There are many, many other such cases.
That the British prison system is in a dreadful state hardly needs to be demonstrated after the spate of riots by prisoners (including, in some cases, people yet to be convicted) in protest at overcrowding and other bad conditions.
Civil liberties have CICE ed under this government on countless other fronts: local government, trade union rights, the rights of homosexuals and so on.
Will Labour reverse this trend? On trade union law, there is reason to be pessimistic; but they have at least opposed the extension of the PTA.
The Tory government has made Britain a far more authoritarian, undemocratic place to live than it used to be, and far worse than most of the rest of Western Europe. If the Labour Party is committed to radical, or any sort of, change in Britain, it should repeal the undemocratic changes the Tories have made, and pass new laws guaranteeing our rights.
Our freedoms and our ability to defend them don't start and finish either in Parliament or in the courts; but the labour movement needs to address itself seriously to the issue of democratic rights, and fight to reverse the trend to the strong state' we have seen over the last decade.
om the Martin Foran fence Campaign n the wake of the West Midlands Serious Crime Squad being disbanded, Martin Foran's allegations of police malpractice are now being investigated by the West Yorkshire Police.
Martin Foran is in Frankland Prison, Durham, because he was convicted of armed robbery and then of taking a warder hostage during a protest in prison.
His initial conviction was based on an alleged confession produced by the West Midlands Serious Crime Squad. New evidence strengthens Martin Foran's argument that he was framed up.
The West Yorkshire police investigators have sent the solicitor acting for Mr Foran two supposed copies of the custody sheet relating to his arrest on 10 September 1984.
West Midlands Police claim to have destroyed the original document in accordance with their procedure of shredding material after two years.
During Martin Foran's trial the time of arrest became of crucial importance. The Prosecution maintained that he had given a verbal adPaul Hill, one of the Guildford Four, shortly mission to DI Paul Matthews at che scene of arrest. Mr Foran maintained that he had been arrested earlier that afternoon, that this showed the police account of the alleged 'confession' to have been false, and that the custody sheet had been altered.
Significantly, there are major differences between the writing and the text of the two sets of papers which are both supposed to be copies of the same original police record.
A spokesperson for the Martin Foran Defence Campaign asked: *How can the West Midlands Police Force explain the fact that whilst the original record was destroyed, two copies were made, and these in turn are different from one another?"
The Detence Campaign has also announced the release of an LP titled 'Justice is our Conviction' , a compilation record aiming to highlight Martin Foran's case. The artists' royalties from this project are being donated to the Martin Foran Support Fund, and the record also contains information on the case.
The TV series 'Rough Justice' is preparing a documentary which is likely to be released within the next six months.
More information from 'Conviction' PO Box 522, Sheffield S1 3FE.