Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Rolling forward the state

Socialist Organiser no. 449, 24 May 1990 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 918 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Clive Winston Silcott was murder of PC Blakelock in October 1985 at Broadwater Farm on two bits of evidence.

There was his own confession, and the testimony of one eye-witness.

But the eye-witness, a child, was found to have made his story up to stop the police questioning him further: the judge instructed the jury to find this witness, who was himself a defendant at the time, innocent. The jury were never told the reasons, but the judge believed the case against the boy to be completely ridiculous.

Photo: Martin Shakeshaft And Silcott's confession was the following words: "You ain't got any evidence. Those kids will never go to court, you wait and see. No one else will talk to you. You can't keep me away from them." And again: "You won't find evidence against me."

Asked about the whereabouts of the weapons used that night, he told the police: "No, you find them"

On this evidence, Silcott was jailed for life. But no one could seriously say it amounted to confession. Equally — or more — plausibly, he was defying the police to set him up.

And suppose he had confessed. In many legal systems, including the Scottish one, uncorroborated confession alone is not enough for a conviction. People can confess under police pressure. In itself, a contession is not proof of guilt.

Silcott was found guilty because it was politically essential that somebody was. In that, as in much else, his case bears a striking resemblance to those of the Guildford Four, Birmingham Six, etc, etc. As the 'Spitting Image' sketch has it, maybe soon they'll be reopening cases where after ten years they've discovered that those convicted were actually guilty.

The Silcott case is not an isolated one. It points to something sick about the whole legal system. Our civil liberties are being eroded.

The catalogue is formidable. There is renewed talk about more centralised policing. During the miners' strike, the National Reporting Centre was, useful experience for the police. from their point of It enabled them to move large numbers of police around the country, using police to undertake violent anti-picket activities in areas they didn't know and against people they had never met. The public accountability of the police small enough now. The problems with a national force would be astronomical.

The police are more militarised than before. They have more shields, riot formations, cavalry charges, and guns; and there are more and more specialised 'riot police" . Along with this there is an increased emphasis on public order', as opposed to individual crimes.

The police are less accoun table, whether to local authorities, parliament or the courts. The police are more overtly right wing: witness James Anderton's outbursts.

And police powers have been increased. The 1984 Police and Criminal Evidence Act extended Police over order see stor and search, and search premises.

The 1986 Public Order Act extended police powers to ban and impose restrictions on demonstrations and pickets.

And the 1984 Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provision) Act extended the terms of the original 1974 Act to include members and supporters of any organisation in the world which uses "violence for political ends" (a definition which no doubt excludes, for example, the American government's actions in Panama).

This last measure is linked to the absurd banning of the voices of Sinn Fein representatives.

In addition, police methods have become more antidemocratic. During the miners' strike, the police extensively used roadblocks and the charge of 'threatening behaviour' (defined very broadly) to arrest pickets. Pickets could find themselves convicted for obstructing the highway and other breaches of criminal law.

Magistrates have extended their powers to grant bail conditionally, for example imposing detention on groups like striking miners and hippy Peace Convoys.

In the crown courts, the defendant's right to silence has been eroded.

In 1988 the Home Office convened a 'working group' not to discuss whether in principle the right to silence should be curtailed, but how to do it. In Northern Ireland, the right was unceremoniously abolished even without the working group coming up with any findings.

The government looks set to make the following changes:

1. The judge will be able to allow a defendant's refusal to answer questions to be commented upon adversely by the prosecution.

2. In a crown court, if an accused fails to mention a fact on which they subsequently rely for their defence, the prosecution will be able to cross-examine them on why they omitted it.

3. Instead of the old caution, «You do not have to say anything unless you wish to do so," there will be a new one: "You do not have to say anything. A record will be made of anything you do say and it may be given in evidence. So may your refusal to answer any questions. If there is any fact on which you intend to rely in your defence in court, it would be best to mention it now. It you hold back until you go to court, you may be less likely to be believed."

And there are other less ing proposals.

As the bulletin of the Legal Action Group comments:

...Suspects are often questioned away from the police station, without benefit of legal advice, juvenile - the presence of an independent adult. False confessions are still given with alarming frequency." (Legal Action, February 1990)

The journal continues:

Scan page 7

JENT-S HREAT :IVIL LIBE

----- pull-quotes -----

liberties under liberties under

contemporaneous note-taking, tape-recording or - if a

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 449

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →