Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Private monopolies, s monopoly: no choice

Socialist Organiser no. 449, 24 May 1990 · scan p. 4 · about 876 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Ana move guaranteed to warm the heart of the average Russian stuck all day in a potato queue, Mikhail Gorbachev this week awarded himself a pay rise of 200%.

He trebled his salary to the equivalent of around £45,000 This puts Gorby's income at approximately 20 times that of most Russians.

Very egalitarian.

He still gets less than either Thatcher or George Bush, however. Thatcher gets a cool £66,851, and Bush €117,000 a year.

But Mikhail makes up for it a bit. He also gets, as a handout from the state, a luxury flat in Moscow, a holiday home by the sea, a whole fleet of cars - an helicopters - and, naturally, round-the-clock protection from the KGB.

Well, mad cows have little pussies now, l I never liked cows much anyway, horrible things that nothing all day except eat sheep's brains and make cowpats. Which is not to say thought they deserved to be eaten by cats. -But it turns out that when the government was first told about Bovine Spongiform Thingamy. they told experts to keep the lid *scrapie" (the sheep which caused BSE).

Actually beef is bad for you anyway, because it's so fatty. unless it's very expensive and no-one ever heard of a lentil bake going wobbly on its legs, charging around manically and infecting your pets, the solution to all this seems to me perfectly obvious.

One advantage of mad cats, however, is that they could be fed to Rott weilers, not, I hasten to add, in order to cause Mad Rottweiler Disease, which I would rather not contemplate, but in order to be able to get an official government ruling that Rottweilers should be destroyed just in case Yet last week a woman in Wales was rescued from drowning by none other than a Rottweiler, who somehow managed miraculously to drag her to the shore without severing her jugular or otherwise permanently disfiguring her.

Since this obviously proves how nice and cuddly the huge beasts are after all, I propose a new use for them. In future, all Sun journalists should be tossec once a week into rivers and Rot tweilers sent in to rescue them.

Every time the dog fails to rescue the journalist, we feed him a mad cat as a reward.

Speaking of Rottweilers, the manager of Crayford greyhound racing track h just lost his job because he allowed a comedy sketch to filmed in which a Rottweiler LETITERIS The editorial 'Conflicts coming in the USSR' in Socialist Organiser no.447 made many important points about the crisis in Russia over economic reforms.

As the editorial pointed out: "most independent trade unionists in the USSR seem not to oppose the drive for market economics on principle". After decades of economic suffocation by the bureaucrats' plan, after decades of workers having little power as consumers, atter decades of little choice being available in the shops — it is no wonder that workers are keen to see increased market competition.

But will the market reforms increase the power of workers as consumers? Will the reforms bring a greater variety of goods at reasonable "competitive" prices onto the shelves of Russian shops?

The Russian socialist Boris Kagarlitsky in his essay *Perestroika: The Dialectics of Change makes several important points on the relationship between sections of the ruling bureaucrats and the market reforms.

Over the past decades of Stalinist rule, production has been oriented not to the satisfaction of human need but to the interests of the bureaucrats. Will the economy become more humane through the proposed reorientation from central commands to profit criteria? The means are changed, but the goal remains the same.

The Russian economy is dominated by the state monopoly. Perestroika aims at the reform of this monopoly. But the reforms are likely to replace the state monopoly with independent monopolies under the control and ownership of the bureaucrat bosses.

In this scenario of Perestroika each area of production would end up dominated by a monopoly created out of the existing state industries.

In any part of the economy where production requires substantial investment it is unlikely that new rivals will emerge able to compete in the new market. In a 1990s economy practically all key sectors of production require substantial initial investment. Where will new rivals emerge from?

The economic system based on state monopolies is likely to remain a system dominated by monopolies even if the state relinquishes central Kagarlitsky reports that "since 1987, when a series of departments transferred to the principles of self-financing, the newspapers have begun to report fast rising prices on the most varied goods and services, from trips abroad and window cleaning to...funeral services."

The slogan of 'self-financing" was transformed in practice into the freedom for bureaucrat bosses of monopolies to increase prices.

Should socialists defend the Stalinist plan against the market?

The rigid, suffocating grip of the command economy needs transforming. A workers' socialist revolution would necessarily use market mechanisms as part of gearing production to the satisfaction of human need.

The key to defending workers'interests and the key to economic reforms which will be geared to satisfying the needs of consumers is the fight for workers' control over production expressed by the demands for workers' selfmanagement.

Tony Dale, Manchester

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 449

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →