A policy for the luncl A policy tor ine ! tables of the City
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Maybe you're a teacher, wrestling with stagnant wages, repeated rounds of cuts, and the threat now of the sack.
You'll be thrilled by Neil Kinnock's new policy document. It promises stern control over public sector wages and reassures us that "secondary" industrial action — for example, by teachers nationally in support of teachers sacked in a particular area - will stay unlawtul.
Or perhaps you're unemployed, miserable because of eroded welfare benefits and the Poll Tax.
Neil Kinnock has promises for you, too. A Kinnock government would keep public spending under strict control. There could be no question of splashing out on big increases in benefits, or spending substantially on public works which would generate useful jobs.
No. After all, the centrepiece, the jewel, the diamond cutting edge of Neil Kinnock's socialist economics is now British entry inito the Exchange Rate Mechanism of the EC. And surely everyone can understand that rules out fuddy-duddy old-style cloth-cap generosity to the poor.
Then possibly you're a worker in an industry which has been privatised or is about to be privatised, weary of speed-up, exploitation and job threats from your profit-hungry boss.
The post-modern Labour Party has words for you. A Kinnock government will buy two per cent of the shares in British Telecom to create a majority (51%) government shareholding. That's a caring socialist policy, quite different from the brutal and vicious Thatcherism of a 49 per cent government stake.
It will also establish government control over the electricity grid. Not the power generating companies, not the power supply companies, but just the grid.
And if you're a trade unionist? How old-fashioned! Neil Kinnock's line for you is that Tory restrictions on solidarity action and pickets will be "streamlined"
As Hugo Young put it in the Guardian, "Labour's fondest wish is to be regarded as the party which will make Britain safe for capitalism."
It's not just that Labour's leaders commit themselves to managing capitalism. They've always done that. But at times in the past they've promised to manage capitalism for the workers, in the workers' interests. Now the main promises are to manage capitalism in the capitalists' interest. Hugo Young again: "What has been the point of Mr Smith's journeys round the lunch-tables of the City, if not to convince them that they have nothing to fear?"
It makes no sense for vote-catching, because John Smith's Ci ty lunch companions are still going to vote Tory. And probably even John Smith and Neil Kinnock will scrape around for some bits of policy to highlight which seem more pro-worker come election time. But for the present their priority is to convince the bosses and bankers that they are respectable, responsible, modern capitalist politicians.
Over the past ten years the Tories have ruthlessly plundered billions of pounds from the poor and handed it to the rich. The victims of that plunder beg on the streets, wait in the dole queues, and struggle with low wages and Poll Tax.
To restore those billions would. not be a radical or socialist policy. Whack the taxes back on the rich, and pay out the money in welfare to the majority, that's all: it would not overturn capitalism.
But Neil Kinnock will not even promise that much. Even reversing the shift in the balance of wealth and power effected by the Tories, restoring the status quo, is too much for him to contemplate.
The new policy document, due to go to the National Executive this month, emerged from the usual process of democratic decision-making Kinnock-style. There was a kitchen cabal, with the kitchen fire no doubt fuelled by burning volumes of Labour Party conference decisions. Then the policy was announced to the working class and the labour movement through the now customary channel of a leak to the Guardian.
At Labour conference this October, Neil Kinnock hopes to buttress and safeguard this sort of policy-making by making Conference secondary to a new "policy council" and removing the right of Constituency Labour Parties to put proposals direct to conference. He has shown us what sort of policy he wants to make and protect through such a mechanism. All the more reason for Labour activists to rally to defend our democratic rights.