Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Bro. Kinnock's favourite union rights

Socialist Organiser no. 448, 17 May 1990 · scan p. 11 · Tony Dale · about 2,221 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Mistakes torpedo anti-poll By Sleeper t doesn't seem so very long ago that the mere suggestion of Labour defeating the Tories and Neil Kinnock moving into 10 Downing Street, would produce hoots of derisive laughter in saloon bars up and down the land.

Now, Labour's victory at the next election is virtually taken for granted in many quarters and the "serious" press is full of interviews with John Smith and speculation about Labour's economic It's no surprise, then, that the thorny old question of Labour's relationship with the unions is coming to the fore once again. It is the common wisdom of both Walworth Road and Congress House that the image of Labour as a party in thrall to the unions has been largely responsible for their trouncing in three general elections since the 1978 *Winter of Discontent"

One of Kinnock's key projects has been to dispell this image. So, while John Smith oozes round the City and Wall Street, assuring the assembled parasites that they have nothing to fear, Kinnock has been bending over backwards to appear to distance himself from the unions and to reduce obvious union influence over the party's policymaking. This does not mean, however, that the historic links between Labour and the unions have been broken - far from it. It's just that the partnership is now a rather less equal one and the form it takes › is more secretive and bureaucratic.

John Edmonds of the GMB has long been the "brains" behind the re-shaping tax stance Manchester NALGO HousM in Stewards voted on Thursday 10 May to drop their policy of non-cooperation with poll tax collection at Housing offices.

A majority of Housing offices and sections were unwilling to take industrial action if any member was disciplined for refusing to cooperate with poll tax work, so the Stewards Committee had no option but to retreat. However, the setback could have been avoided.

By refusing to back the dispute the NALGO branch officers undermined Housing workers' opposition. The Branch Secretary issued a circular condemning the NALGO Housing position. Branch and District officials refused to listen to requests for an official ballot.

Mistakes were also made by sections of the left on the stewards committee. The SWP argued for Housing workers not to cooperate with the poll tax purely on the basıs of the principle of 'Don't of the Labour/union relationships. Edmonds, like Kinnock, wants the union block vote at Labour conference whittled down and eventually removed altogether, to be replaced by onemember-one-vote.

Edmonds has also been a prime mover in downgrading the TUC-Labour Liaison Committee as the central power-broking forum between the party and the unions.

This body used to meet monthly but has not not met for nearly a year. It has effectively been replaced by a secretive "contact group" made up of selected union bureaucrats and members of the Shadow Cabinet. The "contact group" is much more to Kinnock's liking, excluding as it does NEC lefties like Benn and some of the more recalcitrant bureaucrats like Ken Gill. The members of the union side are Normal Willis (TUC), Bill Jordan (AEU), Ron Todd (TGWU), Rodney Bickerstaffe (NUPE), Brenda Dean (SOGAT) and -of course - our old friend "Brains" Edmonds.

The contact grouphas already endorsed the broad outlines of Labour's economic policy, in which membership of the European Monetary System plays a vital role. Now, the technicalities of the exchange rate mechanism may not seem a terribly exciting subject for trade unionists (or anyone else, come to that) but from it flows all manner of wondrous new policies - like public sector pay restraint imposed through strict cash limits on nationalised industries. Membership of the EMS is also being used as an excuse to drop Labour's commitment to full employment. Having been endorsed by the "contact group" , these policies went through the TUC general council more or less on the nod.

So far, Edmonds, Jordan and the TUC "right" who support Kinnock down the line, have been making all the running. But what of the "left" and, in particular, Ron Todd?

Pay, Don't Collect'. They argued that Manchester Housing workers should not collect because no council worker should collect the poll tax.

This position was always going to be difficult to hold the line on once the Council-wide NALGO branch meeting voted down the 'Don't Pay, Don't Collect' position.

A strategy was needed to link oppositon to the poll tax with a campaign around service and condition issues eg regradings and staffing levels. By relating to the day-to-day concerns of Housing workers a real fight would have been possible.

Socialist Organiser supporters proposed such a strategy.

The SWP argued against linking opposition to the poll tax to service and conditions demands.

The crunch came when workers faced the threat of disciplinary action. Only a minority of sections and offices were willing to take industrial action.

Despite this setback the battle around the poll tax is not over. Inadequate staffing levels, poor office accommodation and low pay will spark disputes over poll tax implementation.

they can do is take cheap swipes at the Tories instead of really getting stuck in putting their weight behind

ig

The leader of the TGWU is in a very strange situation: he ought to be Kinnock's closest confidant on the union side (not only is the T&G the largest union in the country, but it can also count Bro. Kinnock amongst its members) but in practice Todd's voice is more or less disregarded as Labour's economic and industrial policy takes shape.

Not that Todd (or any other "left" bureaucrat) has actually put up much of a fight on economic pileft simply mainly because the mainstream doesn't have a coherent alternative these days (the old "Alternative Economic Strategy" based upon import controls and a siege economy having long since been dumped by all but the most diehard Stalinists).

On one issue, however, the TUC "left" looks like taking some sort of stand: trade union rights. The Labour leadership has long made it plain that they have no intention of repealing very much of the Tories anti-union legislation. A paper prepared by employment spokesman Tony Blair (and endorsed by most of the "contact group") spells out Labour's policy towards the unions: a specialist court headed by a High Court judge sitting with assessors from "both sides" of industry, will have the power to fine unions engaged in "unlawful" action and enforce damages; existing law requiring ballots before strikes and for union elections will remain; "secondary" action will be permitted only where there is a "direct interest of an "occupational or professional nature" The new court will interpret these principles and build up case law.

This cuts right across the policy of the TGWU, whose biennial delegate conference has repeatedly demanded the repeal of all Tory legislation and the restoration of immunities. Similar policies are also held by MSF, NUPE, NALGO, NUR, ASLEF and several smaller unions.

The first sign of a counter-attack by the "left" was the launch on 1 May of Are had a strike a year wages but about national negotiating rights.

*We won that, but management here are ignoring it. That's what this dispute is about."

Guards at Manchester's Piccadilly railway station are on strike following the imposition without agreement of new work rosters. Guards voted on Sunday 13 May to continue existing working from Monday 14th, when the new rosters were to be imposed.

One guard explained: "When we came into work we were stood spare (told not to work), then on Monday night two guards were sent home for refusing to work new rosters and so we came out on strike."

The guards plan a mass meeting for Wednesday 16th, and have approached NUR head office for a ballot to make their action official. Another strike commented: "I am confident. There are only two or three gone in out of 230 of us — we're solid.

The strike comes against background of British Rail bosses' attempts to erode national negotiating they'll have to be supplying the same amount of coal as they're supplying now at today's prices. the "Campaign for Free Trade Unions" sponsored by 33 big-wigs including Todd., Bickerstaffe, Ken Gill (MSF), Tony Dubbins (NGA) and Derek Fullick (ASLEF). The campaign's charter includes the right to belong to a union and to be recognised for collective bargaining, the right to strike, to picket effectively and to take solidarity action. In line with International Labour Organisation conventions, it also calls for the right of union members to determine their own rules.

How seriously the likes of Todd and Bickerstaffe take this initiative is open to question. It was noticeable that none of the big guns were present at the official launch of the campaign, leaving it to relatively minor leaders from NUCPS and FTAT. And within a few days of the launch, Todd was publicly offering the Labour leadership a compromise on the issue of pre-strike ballots, whereby a Labour government would allow ballots to ratify action after it had started in the case of "genuinely spontaneous" walkouts over, for instance, victimisations.

A further complication is added by the attitude of the Stalinists who still hold sway in a few unions, notably MSF: they seem to be opposed to any talk of "positive rights" for unions, preferring to concentrate upon demanding the repeal of existing legislation and the full restoration of immunities. The Morning Star (which, despite its declining influence, is still a fairly accurate barometer of how the Stalinist element of the bureaucracy is thinking) carried an extraordinarily sectarian editorial attacking the campaign on the day of its launch.

Despite these problems, the campaign is the first sign of life from the official "left" of the movement in a long while. And, whatever the motives of some of the campaign's signatories, they've chosen the right issue on which to take a stand. At last. defend negotiating rights for the rail unions. The roster imposed by the management at Piccadilly demanded guards work in excess of the nationally agreed 312 hours in 12 weeks, when staff shortage through savings prevented rostering within agreement.

The Piccadilly strike is significant for all railworkers.

IN BRIEF A tube strike is looking less likely this year after the NUR union executive decided not to hold an immediate ballot on strike action after rejecting management's 9.3% offer.

Aslef and TSSA have already accepted the deal. NUR Genera Secretary Jimmy Knapp has been hinting very strongly that the London Transport subcommittee of the NUR should accept the deal. Meanwhile senior supervisors for Traveller: Fare have been given a 22% wage increase.

According to a survey sponsored by the Inland Revenue By Mike Grayson the Civil and Public Servants T Association (CPSA)

has been called the *Beirut of the trade union movement"

Unfortunately, no hostages have been released.

The 1990 annual conference (14-18 May) seems set to continue the bloodletting tradition.

CPSA is the largest of the civil service unions, organising mainly clerical grades, and is presently run by a viciously "red-hunting" right wing. At the same time, the union has Britain's biggest Broad Left grouping - dominated by supporters of Militant.

The resulting clash of ideologies produces a heady brew at conference. By the end of the week many delegates feel that they've just done 15 rounds with Mike Tyson.

The Broad Left suffered a setback when the election results were announced in the DHSS section: traditionally the strongest area of militancy in the union. For the third year running, the Section Executive Committee will be in the hands of an alliance between the traditional right wing and "BL'84" (Kinnockites, Stalinists, careerists in suits).

However, the Section Conference itself was still dominated by the Broad Left, who were able to win almost all of the policy debates. It is widely anticipated that, when the national election results are announced later in the week, the right wing will retain their control over the Executive.

At the time of writing, most of the major debates are still to be heard. On Monday's debate over the 1990 pay offer of 8%, the left failed to win a motion critical of the right's handling of the issue by only 3 votes. Whether this will set the tone for the coming week remains to be seen.

T the first days of CPSA he largest fringe meeting in conference was the Branches Against Agencies' (BAA) meeting on Monday lunchtime.

Over 200 packed into the meeting to discuss how to fight the Tories' plans to break up the civil service into Executive Agencies (semi-privatisation).

The BAA campaign is unique in CPSA because it is based on branches, not just a group of individuals. Over 70 branches took part in the BAA Conference in February — and many more signed up to support BAA at the fringe meeting.

The mood and theme of the meeting was that the campaign must continue and intensify its activities.

With the right wing set to be reelected we can expect no campaign to be led from the top.

Therefore the BAA campaign seeks to bring together all those concerned branches to exchange information and plan for the industrial action which is needed to beat Agencies.

campaign

----- pull-quotes -----

Railworkers rights *W ago not just about

Boost for Agencies fight By Steve Battlemuch

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 448

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →