Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Whether or not nuclear power continues as an…]

Socialist Organiser no. 448, 17 May 1990 · scan p. 10 · about 1,203 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Whether or not nuclear power continues as an energy source, we are still faced with the problem of what to do with its waste products.

Highly radioactive spent fuel must be kept safely for thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, ot years until its radioactivity has An obituary Holt Luigi Nono was one of the generation of composers who attempted to rebuild music on the ruins of the Second World War in Europe.

In opposition to Stockhausen and Boulez, Nono's music confronted audiences with the political issues of the day, from a revolutionary socialist point of view.

His first work to be widely played was Il Canto Sospeso (The suspended song) for voices and orchestra, setting the texts of letters written in Nazi concentration camps by captured Resistance fighters. His first staged work, Intolleranza 1960 (Intolerance) presented images of racism and concentration camps and the need to build a new social order. Its first performance in Venice was marked by street fighting between students supporting Nono and fascist mobs trying tolstop the performance.

Throughout the 1960s Nono worked our methods of disposal must take this into account.

Last year I summarised a talk given to Open University students by geologist and nuclear waste expert Dr Neil Chapman. He has recently enlarged on his research findings in an article in New Scientist (jointly with lan McKinley of the Swiss Nuclear Waste Disposal Organisation).

In order to predict what will happen to waste buried now over the next thousands of years, geologists on music for electronic tape, singers and actors, to enable his works to be performed in factories and other unconventional venues.

The works from this period included A floresta è jovem e cheja de vida (The forest is young and full of life) which concerns the struggle against American imperialism in Vietnam. This work ends with taped quote from a demonstrating student in America: "'Is this all we can do?" Nono implies that we can do a lot more.

The early seventies saw a second large staged work, Al gran sole carico d'Amore (A great sun full of -love) celebrating the Paris Commune and the orchestral, choral and electronic Ein Gespenst... setting the beginning of the Communist Manifesto.

Nono wrote relatively little in the late seventies, and in the last ten years of his life became involved with the use of live electronic processes to transform vocal and instrumental sounds and to position them in space. The works of this final period included Quando stanno morendo, about the terrible history of Poland in our century, and his third major staged work, Prometeo, a collaboration reactor — a natural fission reactor deep in the rocks at Oklo in Gabon. Oklo's nuclear reactor consisted of a massive deposit of uranium established over 2000 million years ago. When the deposit was discovered in the "70s, geologists were surprised to find less of the U-235 isotope (the form used as fuel for nuclear power) than is usually found. Why was this?

Ordinary uranium (U-238) decays at a very slow rate, half disappearing every 4 billion years or so. with the philosopher Massimo Cacciari.

These later works were all written with the creative participation of the performers and should be seen as collaborative works.

Nono's life was filled with involvement in the world, from his participation in the factory struggles in the 1950s and 1960s to his collaboration in artistic work with the painter Emilo vedova and the Trotskyist dramatist Peter Weiss. All his music shows rigorousness, the physical impact of sound and an expressive intensity.

Of his generation in music, only lannis Xenakis shares these qualities.] Nono was deeply involved in Spanish and German culture as well as that of his native Italy. He travelled extensively in Eastern Europe and South America, and eventually settled in West Berlin. His music was most frequently performed in Germany, where Nono's work has been influential on such diverse composers as Helmut Lachenmann, Dieter Schnebel and Nikolaus A Huber.

Nono's music was not played often in Britain, probably because of its ability to confront audiences with political portion of U-235 was some 3%, similar to that found in nuclear fuel.

This, coupled with the fact that the Oklo deposits are highly concentrated (50-70% uranium oxide), allowed a fission reaction to commence, going on over half a million years, producing much heat and radioactive waste. This used up much of the U-235, resulting in today's depleted levels.

Thus the Oklo rocks have contained the equivalent of spent nuclear fuel for 2 billion years. Many of the constituents, plutonium, neptunium and thorium, have stayed more or less where they were, despite the percolation of groundwater. However, other substances, such as the more soluble iodine and caesium or the radioactive gas radon, have been washed away or have escaped along cracks and fissures, not exactly encouraging news for those trying to find ways of containing nuclear waste.

But the rocks at Oklo are not necessarily those that one would choose to put nuclear waste in. In contrast are the rocks surrounding another massive uranium deposite at Cigar Lake in Saskatchewan, Canada. There a deposite containing up to 40% uranium oxide (14% on average), so concentrated that it may have to be mined by remote control to protect the miners from radiation, has lain for 1300 million years at a depth of 450 metres.

Incredibly, there is no sign at the surface of the presence of such a massive amount of radioactivity. Despite the water saturating the rocks, the groundwater and streams contain no traces of radioactivity. This is tremendously encouraging for those trying to model the behaviour of buried waste since the surround nuclear waste deposits with clay, evidence of how substances move through clay is also needed. This evidence has come from studies of sentiments at the bottom of Loch Lomond. There, a layer containing uranium, radium, iodine and bromine was deposited 5000 years ago. None of these substances has moved far in that time, even though the latter are in products free that one.

clay binds them in some way:

Further encouraging evidence comes from Morro do Ferro (Hill of Iron") in Brazil, the most radioactive place in the world. On this hill, above 30000 tonnes of thorium (similar to plutonium), grow plants so radioactive that when placed next to photographic film they X-ray themselves! Six weeks on this hill would give a person the equivalent of a lifetime dose of natural radiation in Briatin. Nevertheless, the streams running through the hill leach out just 1 part per billion of this radioactivity, containing far less than permitted levels for drinking water in the US.

Lastly, archaeological evidence on the corrosion of iron (such as a 12 tonne hoard of Roman nails in Scotland that remains partly intact after 2 thousand years) suggests that the steel containers of radioactive waste would not leak for a thousand years.

So the evidence is accumulating that radioactive waste can be stored for thousands or even millions of years without contributing significantly to the background of radiation that we all have to live with. Though the debate about nuclear power continues, it seems it is possible (though expensive) to deal with one of its major problems.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 448

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →