[reviews 'Enemies - a love story', 'She Devil'…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
reviews 'Enemies - a love story', 'She Devil' and 'McCabe and Mrs Miller"
Enemies — a love story' is about four New York Jews, one man and three women, who managed to escape from the Nazis, but who yet remain prisoners of the past.
Herman Broder is the man; the three women are his wives.
Such a scenario seems tailormade for comedy, but "Enemies' is too sad for comedy, though some of Herman's predicaments have a kind of gallows humour.
During the war, Herman spent three years hidden from the Nazis in a hay lott. Yadwiga, a simple peasant girl and his family's former servant, hid him and fed him at great personal risk, and he married her and brought her to America out of gratitude, all the while thinking that his first wife, Tamara, had perished along with their children in the Holocaust.
Bored with Yadwiga's simplemindedness and devotion, Herman also lives part time with Masha, a Russian survivor of the death camps. The volatile Masha is eager for anything; living on the edge emotionally is her way of proving she survived.
Herman is awkwardly juggling these two, _ papering over his absences with lie upon lie, when Tamara reappears, seemingly risen from the dead. Though physically alive, Tamara died spiritually when her children died and she was thrown along with them into a ditch full of corpses. More gracious than the possessive Masha, Tamara cedes Herman to Yadwiga, and urges Herman to put his life in order:
But Herman is still emotionally in his hay lott; he has lived with external constraints so long that he has lost the knack of controlling himself. Like Masha, he can deny himself nothing; he's greedy for Love, for sensation, to grab as much from life as he can - anything to blot out the past. He lurches from crisis to crisis, always sweating, always worrying, yet never resolving anything.
He fears he will be caught, he knows he should be punished, but he goes on, regardless, a man ruled by his heart, not his head. Like Tamara and Masha, who know they are only half alive, Herman lives in a twilight zone, guilty that he survived when so many perished, bereft of religious comfort, spiritually alienated from the people around him.
"Enemies' is about the Jews' impossible predicament — how to go on living in a world where the Holocaust was allowed to happen.
There's not much devilry in SheDevil'. Roseanne Barr, who plays the spurned wife, is too deadpan to be wicked; she seems to be playing decayed to a safe level. On past performance, it is unlikely that any human society will survive that long. People living then may have no idea what nuclear waste is and Roseanne Barr and Meryl Streep i tongue in cheek. Meryl Streep, as the swathed-in-pink Barbara Cartland style romance writer, Mary Fisher, who snatches Roseanne's husband, is better; she camps it up and seems to be having a whale of a time.
But the film is limp. There's no real malevolence, no bite to it; nothing's really at stake, and the ending is feeble.
Fay Weldon's story, The life and loves of a she devil', had a dark twist in its tail. Through plastic surgery, the plain wite became a replica of the romance writer heroine. That said something about women's obsession with appearances and perfectionism.
But 'She-Devil' has been turned into an affirmative action, ugly-ishave looked for evidence as to what has happened to similar natural substances in the past.
Astoundingly, it turns out there is an almost exact model for a nuclear She-Devil beautiful, love-your-limitations fable, which totally changes the slant, and robs the story of its point. Far from being a she devil, Roseanne ends up contented and nobly forgiving. Hug? Where did all her rage and anger go?
I can only surmise that it fell through some of the holes in the script.
Robert Altman's 1960s' film "McCabe and Mrs Miller' has been revived in a new print for audiences in London only.
Though frustrating in parts - it seems to have been shot through misty lenses, and the overlapping dialogue is often inaudible — it is a film that rewrites one of the myths of American history.
Set in the early years of the U-235 is less stable, half going every 700 million years. Counting bck from the usual proportion of 0.7% U-235 now found, we can work out that 2000 million years ago the pro- American West, it's the story of McCabe, an ambitious, but not overly bright saloon owner and brothel keeper, who comes to grief at the hands of greedy men.
The Western frontier in movies has always been the home of solid American values, where good inevitably triumphs over evil. Not in this film. Big companies, eager for profits, are gobbling up the smaller entrepreneurs, and doing it ruthlessly. Those who won't sell out to them end up cold and dead. Might is right.
Like all the other big powers, America, the so-called land of the free, was built upon blood and exploitation. 'McCabe and Mrs Miller' shows us one example, and does it with style. rocks around the Cigar Lake deposit are similar to those proposed for the underground depositories.
Since it is further proposed to
----- pull-quotes -----
LEST HEARN S SCIENICE