Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

'ocialist Inside Worker KREMLIN WOTE LABOUR BUT.. Step up Step up the tight

Socialist Organiser no. 448, 17 May 1990 · scan p. 9 · about 570 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Listing leaders. They recognise that FOR LABOUR militants lacking political tempering and experience; they are people who take refuge in a semi-syndicalism from the problems of the working-class movement - people who know enough to say Vote Labour in elections to avoid the organisational consequences of their day by day and year by year denial that the working class should engage in politics, but unfortunately don't know enough to behave responsibly towards the class and avoid irresponsible gibberish like the SW front page I have quoted.

They are people who think that the history of the British labour movement ended when they formulated their present politics in response to the vile Wilson governments of the '60s. As late as 1966 an editorial in their paper could describe as a scab someone who stood against Labour in a by-election in Hull in protest against the Labour Government's support for the US war in Vietnam. Then they decided that Labour was finished.

Thereafter it has been a matter only of the enlightened ones explaining the all-saving idea to workers in struggle!

They are stuck in one-sided and incomplete and inadequate conclusions from the period around 1968, and have managed to learn nothing since then, despite the "70s, when industrial militancy of great scope and intensity returned a Labour government, and the '80s, when we did not advance from that because workers had learned from it, but got Thatcher and regression. The SWP leaders have learned nothing in 20 or 25 years!

The American socialist James P Cannon used to tell the story of the once vastly popular pre-World War One socialist paper Appeal to Reason, whose circulation at its height reached an astonishing quarter of a million. Because it confined | itself - tremendously powerful — agitation around elementary socialism, it failed to keep readers or to develop those it kept into "cadres" . Its effect was needlessly limited.

SW is "better" , of course: it is *better" because of a classically "British" inconsistency. It "builds the party" , and pulls people to the SWP, which educates them and gives them a general socialist culture, and sets them to work... selling SW But it is "worse" , too: it counterposes itself to the existing labour movement. And its "build the party" element does not for long (for most of the labour movement, ever) contradict the Appeal to Reason effect: lots of people pass through the SWP and often those who stay in politics wind up on the soggy left of the Labour Party or further right. Having been taught that revolutionary politics is sectarian party-building and denunciation of Labour from outside, when they begin to see the inescapable need to relate to the political labour movement they drop revolutionary politics. That's what they were taught: either-or, either revolutonary politics or involvement in the political labour movement.

In fact, in neither phase do such people function as adequate MarxIStS.

When SO was launched in 1978 it was the organ of a very broad coalition, the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory. At one of the early open Editorial Board meetings I asked someone to go and talk politics to a very wet-seeming reformist.

I remember feeling pleased at that man's "contributions" , or rather at his presence, because it showed how broad the reach of our campaign was... Yes, it turned out that he had been in the SWP. For seven years.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 448

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →