AFTER THE ELECTION Finish Thatches
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Kinnock to replace her. We can HERE HERE the way forward cannot, on the experience of history so far, be by way of building up a largely independent new labour movement, but by way of shaking up and renovating sections of the old movement and reuniting the excluded socialists with them.
The latter way was the Comintern's strategy, leading to tactics like the United Front. The former was the policy of the so-called Council Communist faction of th early-'20s Communist International Herman TOTEE Anton Pannekoek, Sylvia Pankhurst.
Embellished though it is with such contradictory opportunism as SW's calling for a vote for Labour and advocating membership in trade unions (while refusing, not so long ago, even to take shop steward positions), the Council-Communist dea is the only logical core of the SWP's political enterprise. And at its heart is not so much an attitude to the Labour Party as an attitude o parliament which - except for at general elections! — rejects the existing political institutions. Essentially what the SWP says about Labour derives from a neosyndicalist attitude to parliament.
The Italian Communist Antonio Gramsci is today the unconsulted champion of the ex-Stalinist liberals, like Marxism Today. Jesus Christ, born according to the myth in a stable and a carpenter by trade, was yet the god of the super-rich for centuries; Lenin, who led the liberating workers' revolution of 1917, was yet the official icon of Stalin's despotic state and Gramsci, the unbreakable revolutionary who spent the last ten years of his life in a fascist iail. is now the champion of neo-reformist fainthearts and defeatists!
Gramsci is ours, not theirs. • He wrote this about the politics of the SWP, with Italian syndicalists in mind.
Within the state, the propertied class forges its own discipline and unity, over and above the disputes and clashes of competition, in order to keep intact its privileged position in the supreme phase of competition itself: the class struggle for power, for pre-eminence in the leadership and ordering of society...
Some of the currents in the socialist and proletarian movement had emphasised trade-union organisation as the essential feature of the revolution, and directed their propaganda and activity accordingly. At one stage, the syndicalist movement appeared in the light of the true interpreter of Marxism, the true interpreter of reality...
Syndicalism, while presenting itself as the initiator of a "spontaneist", libertarian tradition, was in fact one of the many disguises of the Jacobin and abstract spirit...
The workers and peasants felt that, so long as the propertied class and the democratic-parliamentary state are dictating the laws of history, any attempt to remove oneself from the sphere of operation of these laws is inane and ridiculous.
There is no denying the fact that within the general configuration of an industrial society, each man can actively participate in affairs and modify his surroundings only to the extent that he operates as an individual and citizen, as member of the democraticparliamentary State. The liberal experience is not worthless and can only be transcended after it has been experienced.
The apoliticism of the apoliticals was merely a degeneration of politics: to reject the State and fight against it is just as much a political act as to take part in the general historical activity that is channelled into Parliament and the municipal councils, the popular institutions of the State.
The quality of the political act varies. The syndicalists worked outside of reality, and hence their politics were funTHIS WEEK was Thatcher's will be worse. inflation topping 10 percent.
We dont need to y & What we need lo do How do we finish ler Socialist Workers Or damentally mistaken. On the other hand, the parliamentary socialists worked in close contact with events, and while they could make mistakes (and indeed they committed many mistakes, and grievous ones too, they made no mistake in the direction their activity took and so they triumphed in the "competition"; the broad masses, the people who objectively modify social relations through their intervention, favoured the Socialist Party.
Notwithstanding all its mistakes and shortcomings, the Party did succeed, in the final analysis, in accomplishing its mission: namely, to transform the proletariat into something whereas before it had been nothing, to give it an awareness, to point the liberation movement firmly and enthusiastically in the direction corresponding in its general lines to the process of historical development of human society.
The greatest error of the socialist movement was akin to that of the syndicalists. Participating in the general activity of human society within the State, the socialists forgot that their role had to be essentially one of criticism, of antithesis. Instead of mastering reality, they allowed themselves to be absorbed by it.
('The conquest of the state', Political Writings 1910-20, p.74-75).
I'm not sneering at syndicalists, and neither was Gramsci. Nor, 1 hope, does SO have much in common with those like Socialist Action and some in Briefing who have always dismissed the SWP's proper concern with the industrial struggle as "syndicalism" while they devoted themselves to pernicious fantasies about some imagınary overseas workers' paradise and Scenarios for Britain. T-hose people call us syndicalists, too.
The syndicalists before and during World War 1 were amongst the best people in the labour movement. They contributed a great deal to the early Communist International, which many of them joined, rising above their one-sidedness.
NO When a German Marxist, Paul Levi, dismissively lectured some syndicalists at the Second Congress of the Communist International in 1920, sneering that they were wrong on things the Marxists had known for decades, Trotsky jumped to their defence. "Today people are attracted to the neosyndicalism of the SU because they are repelled by the supine The syndicalists were a one-sided reaction against the political one-sidedness of the broader labour movement, and against its leadership of bureaucrats and careerists. Today people are attracted to the neo-syndicalism of the SWP because they are repelled by the supine politics of the Labour Party leaders.
The one-sidedness of syndicalism has always helped the Kinnocks and the Ramsey Macdonalds - even when, as in the case of the SWP, it makes socialist propaganda, invokes Lenin and Trotsky, and "builds the party" while standing aloof from the real working-class political movement.
And the leaders of the SWP are not revolutionary working-class leither Washington nor Moscow bat International Socialism DOWN THE TREES.
LITHUANIA CRACKS 30p • Page 13
----- pull-quotes -----
Off TAX worst ever, but next week POLL
politics of the Labour Party leaders."