Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Don't wait for thinking

Socialist Organiser no. 448, 17 May 1990 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,909 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

O'Mahony

Socialist Worker' is a good agitational paper, deliberately taking as its journalistic model the respect-worthy 1960s Daily Mirror, and turned out with an enviable professionalism.

It preaches fervent anti-Toryism, advocates direct action and denounces the foot-dragging Labour and trade union leaders, loudly ringing all the. militant socialist hate-the-bosses emotional bells.

If that is all we need for working-class politics, then Socialist Worker is a great force for socialism.

It isn't, of course. It is a great force for spluttering m...m...militant incoherence and confusion.

You need not only to preach hate for the Tories and their Labour understudies. You must also know how to go about replacing them; you need to go from fervently advocating socialism to the working out of strategy and tactics for the labour movement. Loud militant shouting is common to socialists and anarchists and intermittently to large numbers of workers and other oppressed people during their battles with employers and governments. "Marxists" who are not the best militant fighters, in even limited working-class struggles, are a misunderstanding, a contradiction in terms. Even so, the irreplaceable contribution of Marxists to the class struggle is not militancy but... Marxism.

"This is advertising agency politics. The 'come on' on the from page is meant to catcl the current mood In Britain right now to shout against the Tories is, in Marxist political terms, very little. It is the other things - strategy and tactics and what you have to say to your readers about how they can achieve what they want, what you want to replace the Tories with, how you propose to deal with the fact that the working-class leaders are shamefully inadequate when not openly treacherous - it is those which are decisive.

Those, and not the anti-Toryism which it has in common stock with most of the left, define a newspaper, and tell you what it is, what role it is playing in the class struggle now.

It will also determine what happens to those reached and roused by the fervent anti-Tory and socialist agitation.

Last week's Socialist Worker had a poster front page. The vast headline read: "After the elections, FINISH THATCHER OFF". In the middle of the page was a big red spot with these words printed in black: "Don't wait for Labour"

The accompanying article had 59 (fifty-nine) words. [Devoted but hard-pressed SO reader: "I should be so lucky!" But before you welcome the quantity, wait to examine the political wit!] I quote: "We don't need to wait for Kinnock to replace her. We can do that right away" "Step up the action, get the Tories out" If your heart rises at this prospect, you will turn eagerly to page 3, where you will be told, in an editorial, "No holding back" "What we need to do next".

What do we do to "replace Thatcher right away" without waiting for Kinnock? "Action" now, says SW. Don't pay the poll tax; don't collect it. Press for adequate wage demands, don't hold back for fear of losing Labour votes in the next General Election.

Yes, this is good stuff, which SO also says — and has said for longer and rather more consistently than SW, which for years has been paralysed by defeatism - but how do we "replace Thatcher right away"? The front page promised to tell me, I paid my 30p, and I want to know, please. But the answer isn't there. SW keeps its secret.

After a long and largely accurate survey of the timid inadequacy of the Labour and trade union leaders, who are in effect helping Thatcher to ride out the storm and blocking the potential of the anti-poll-tax campaign, we come to the real point, the idea that is specific to SW. Since Labour "provides punch drunk, bewildered and divided Tory government with the only crumbs of comfort remaining to it [t]here could hardly be better proof of the need to build a fighting socialist party as an alternative to Labour And guess which "fighting socialist party" that is.

Now, both SWs articles might just pass muster as the hard-pressed speech of a fervent but inexperienced newcomer, saved from completely silly irrelevance by the practical proposals: fight back now and don't wait for Kinnock, As the considered view of a supposedly Marxist paper and of the leadership of a self-proclaimed Marxist party they are a disgrace. And those articles are typical, not accidental. You come face to face with the heart and brain of the SWP, the man with the wild poleaxed stare and talk which comes straight from the guts without filtering through a political mind.

In fact, the only way for the antipoll-tax campaign and strikes to finish Thatcher off "without waiting for Kinnock" - that is, without a general election - would be if they grew into a vast general strike, and that in turn grew into a successful insurrection which pushed aside the existing state institutions and procedures and overrode them.

Even in a full-scale general strike, serious class-struggle governadequate way forward ment = and Thatcher's is a serious class-struggle government, and a Heseltine or Kinnock government would be too - would resign if it could not ride out the strike. It would call an election "to decide" calling in the credit which Parliament has with even most working-class militants, and rallying the forces of "law and order", which would no doubt include the leaders of Her Majesty's Opposition. That is how the 1968 general strike in France was derailed.

Yet if SW is serious, it would logically have to call for an all-out general strike now and start to make preparations for insurrecttion, at the very least start making propaganda for it (!). But all this is a thousand miles from the SWP's real politics: for a decade they have played the wet blanket in the labour movement. It took them six months after the start of the 1984-5 miners' strike to register what was going on, and get stuck in to serious solidarity work, so disoriented had they been by a long depressive political pessimism.

Have they now flipped over to the sort of wild-eyed ultra-leftism - journalistic ultra-lettism, anyway - characteristic of the old SLL-WRP? No, because they don't mean it!

This is advertising agency politics. The "come on" on the front page is meant to catch the current mood generated by the antipoll-tax movement: once you get into the booth you find not the promised wonders - not that syndicalist miracle people have talked about for over a hundred years, but no-one has ever seen, and not even the call for a general strike - but just our old familiar and mundane friend "Build the Revolutionary Party" , posted up above the rear exit.

SW has always been very adept at adjusting its sails to catch the winds and moods. More than once in the early '70s it appeared with front page headline calls for a general strike without any explanation at all in any part of the paper. Yet it somehow managed not to call for a general strike at the point in July 1972 when quarter of a million workers struck at the jailing of five dockers by the Heath government and forced the TUC to call a one-day general strike, the threat of which got the dockers out of jail.

SW recognises n0 obligation to HE think things through honestly, Indeed, the leaders of the SWP have been doing this sort of thing for so long that by now they simply wouldn't know how to start. They have excised a whole dimension from the working-class struggle they try to serve - the political dimension!

They pretend — and it is nothing but wilful pretence by now - that the political dimension, that is, actually existing politics, bourgeois and reformist, can be ignored. Or, no, they don't ignore it, because come the general election they will advocate a docile vote for Neil Kinnock, as they did for James Callaghan. They don't ignore it, they pretend that "real" socialist working-class politics develops apart from it, by way of pure direct action, socialist propaganda, and "building the party"

But that is to pretend that the working class can develop unilinearly, so to speak, outside of the social-political processes, or by running away from them. It is to pretend that the working class exists outside of, parallel to, bourgeois society, and not within It, organically immersed in it until by way of political self-awareness it can become a class for itself and remake society.

In practice, the SWP argues that the whole "official" political dimension is not the business of socialists, and that only direct action is - even though it is indisputable that Thatcher's government, using the governmental power in almost a Jacobin, or even Stalinist, social-engineering way, has massively affected the prospects for the sort of direct action that SW recognises as real working-class It is no less indisputable that even a right-wing Labour government now would change the social and political climate, and thus the prospects for industrial action. SW leaves it to the soft left and the right wing to deal with all that. For all its scornful denunciation of Neil Kinnock, the SWP has to relate to elections passively, like the most backward and least class-conscious people in the labour movement, through and by way of Neil Kinnock and his friends, entirely on their terms, having made not even an attempt • influence the Labour Party, the mass political party of the trade un pa Resolutely ignoring electoral politics — until Thatcher or her successor imposes it on them - the SWP cannot make its agitation about toppling Thatcher concrete in the here and now, when talk of an all-out general strike and insurrection would be ridiculous, in the only remaining logical way: by campaigning and calling on the Labour Party to campaign for an immediate general election. They are left with a paper that talks attractive 1968 vintage gibberish, rightly encourages militancy, and has nothing to say about politics or how to kick the Tories out.

"At its heart is not so much an attitude to tl Labour Party as an attitude to parliament which rejects the existing political institutions."

Much of the argument between SW and SO supporters centres around whether socialists should be in the Labour Party or not. We say yes, they say no. But that's not the basic dividing line.

It might be that it became impossible or hopelessly unprofitable for socialists to be in the Labour Party, even though it remained the mass workers' party. (Neither is. true of the Labour Party now, despite the setbacks the left has had).

But suppose it is agreed that socialists shouldn't or can't be in the mass working-class party. Then one of two things. They ignore the existing organisations built over many decades by the working class, and go their own party-building way, in effect committing themselves to building a whole alternative labour movement and hoping that one day their "fighting socialist party" will supersede the old movement (absorbing or hegemonising parts of it, I suppose)Or else they continue to interact with the mass movement, advocating policies and strategies for it as a means of "exposing" the exNeither Washington nor Moscow but International Socialism

Scan page 9

South Korea answered erupts BSEE PAGE & 30p I SEE PAGE S

----- pull-quotes -----

generated by the anti- poll tax movement."

Abortion vote: your questions

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 448

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →