I for the Third World?
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Could North Korea explode advanced capitalisms.
And, generally, a substantial flow of funds from abroad will be necessary to finance all this: otherwise the land reform will collapse back into a mass of poverty, with only a few rising capitalist farmers making good, and new industries will falter because of lack of infrastructure and balance-ofpayments crises.
Colonialism imposed an alien state power on Third World coun tries; drained their wealth away to the metropolis, with minimal local investment in education and welfare or even in industry; and collaborated with archaic economic structures in the countryside. A radical reversal is necessary on all these three fronts.
Listing these conditions tells us why the development of the Third World has been so uneven and crisis-ridden, and why South Korea's development is not a model 284g World for all other countries to follow at will and find capitalist prosperity.
To write a land reform law is easy, and almost every Third World state has done it. To enforce it against the opposition of the landowning classes is more difficult. Having enforced it, to provide sufficent resources to the new units -smallholdings, cooperatives, or state farms - so that they do not collapse in a spontaneous 'counterreform' is more difficult still.
South Korea got its land reform - a ruthless and thorough land reform — as a paradoxical by-product of the US's war against Stalinist North Korea. It got huge amounts of aid and military contracts as a by-product of the US's war against Vietnam.
It got effective political independence - and effective political independence it certainly has had, despite some people on the left describing its regimes as "puppets" of the US - probably as a by-product of the success of the land reform and the Stalinist grimness of North Korea. After the Korean war, strong anti-Stalinist and anti-working class governments could find a solid social base in South Korea. They were dictatorial and repressive, but they were based on the better-off in South Korea, not on any foreign power.
too?
With the fall of CeausAlbania's current cautious "glasnost", North Korea is now the probably the world's most vicious, regimented, closed-off Stalinist Public life is dominated by a huge personality cult for dictator Kim Il Sung and his family. Every household — so travellers report -has to have a picture of Kim I! Sung The US did not need to intervene and make South Korea a semicolony in order to safeguard its world-political interests. Nor would it have found it easy to intervene. The South Korea bourgeoisie, having thrown off Japanese rule, was not willing to tolerate American rule any longer than it had to. Allying with the US on profitable terms was one thing; renouncing independence another.
South Korea's development is not unique. Most Third World countries have found independence and pushed their way out of colonial underdevelopment at least to some degree. A few have achieved industrial growth almost as dramatic. The idea that the countries are still "semi-colonies' or "neocolonies" , different only superficially from their colonial pasts, is a distorting myth.
But the capitalist way out of colonialism is a path of grinding repression, feverish exploitation, hugely uneven development, mass pauperism and vast inequality — a hellish combination of the evils suffered by working people in Europe from the 16th century through to the 20th, all compressed into a single bundle. South Korea's way has been luckier than Bangladesh's or Brazil's. It is no way for human beings to develop our world. hanging on its walls, or else be visited by the secret police demanding to know why not.
Yet since the 1940s North Korea has also developed industry and a large working class - not as spectacularly as South Korea, but substantially nonetheless.
How much of what's happened in Eastern Europe, China and South Korea has filtered through to the North Korean workers we don't know. But North Korea's rulers, too, have an explosive charge at their feet.