Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A chance to un the Labour left

Socialist Organiser no. 448, 17 May 1990 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,936 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Constituency Labour Parties Conference Fighting the Poll Tax and Red Rose Labour Club, 129 Seven Sisters Road, Martin Thomas previews the 'La Party Socialists' conference on 1 May The Labour Party Socialists' conference this coming weekend, 19-20 May, should be one of the biggest conferences of the Labour left for some years.

It could be the launchpad for an effective rank-and-file network of the left in the Labour Party - a link-up for individual activists which complements the coordination of constituency delegates through the 'Constituency Labour Parties Conference' Labour Party Socialists, like the CLPs Conference, is an offshoot of the Socialist Conference held under Tony Benn's auspices in Chesterfield and Sheffield and of the Socialist Movement. The idea was initiated by Labour Briefing people at the 1989 Socialist Conference. An attempt by Labour Briefing to launch Labour Party Socialists at Labour Party Conference in October 1989 was bungled, but it should be up and going after this weekend's conference.

• Elect a broad committee • Build links with all strands of the Labour left • Build "Labour Against the • Fight for Labour democracy against the witch-hunts • Build a socialist alternative to Stalinism; support the new socialist groups in Eastern Europe • Back the "Campaign for Free Trade Unions"

The conference will elect a 59-member steering committee. Policy issues will be debated, but decisions referred to an AGM later in the year.

Although the left is, and will probably continue for a while to come, much weaker in the Labour Party than we were in the early '80s, there are still many left-wingers doing good work in the Party. The heavy odds against us, and the political isolation or marginalisation many left-wingers suffer in their localities, makes national coordination more difficult, but also valuable.

Labour Party Socialists can provide a forum and link-ups for left Labour activists on several fronts.

Poll Tax: Labour Against the Poll Tax groups have been set up in Sheffield, Leeds, Manchester, and most recently in Nottingham. Labour Party Socialists should support and spread such initiatives. It should back the conference on the Poll Tax and Labour democracy called by the CLPs Conference for 16 June in London.

Strike support: Labour Party Socialists should work with the Socialist Movement Trade Union Committee to support strikes. The moves made towards the end of the Labour Club, 129 Seven indon N7 (tube: Finsbury edentials for delegates and obs CLPs Conference, 11 Egremon Merseyside L44 8BG the witch-hunt Saturday 16 June 11.30-4.30 ambulance workers* dispute for a conference of support groups is an example of what can be done.

Trade union rights: Labour Party Socialists should support, and provide a Labour Party wing for, the recently-launched 'Campaign for Free Trade Unions*.

At Labour Party Conference 1989 a composite calling for a comprehensive Workers' Charter which would codify the right to organise, to strike and to picket gathered some 20 CLPs behind it, and won two and a quarter million votes.

Since then the Labour Party leaders have continued to commit themselves to upholding more and more Tory restrictions. Last October Michael Meacher promised the Tories that Labour would keep strikes by other workers in support of health service staff banned. Most recently education front-bencher Derek Fatchett declared that a Labour Government would make a national strike by teachers against iob cuts unlawful just as it is under the Tories.

The North-West regional Labour Party conference at the end of March backed the call for a Workers' Charter. Now the 'Campaign for Free Trade Unions' launched by 33 trade union leaders, round a shorter four-point charter, greatly strengthens the prospects for a successful challenge at this year's Labour Party conference The unions whose general secretaries have already backed the Campaign command between them 2.5 million out of 5.5 million trade union votes at Labour Party Conference.

International solidarity: Labour Party Socialists should work with international solidarity campaigns. Especially important now is practical, material support for the new socialist and free trade union groups in Eastern Europe and the USSR. Labour Party Socialists should work with the Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Labour Party democracy Labour Party Socialists shoul work with the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy and the CLPs Conference to defend the right of CLPs to re-select MPs and to take part directly in Labour Party decision-making at Annual Conference.

Labour Party Socialists should also provide coordination for battles against the continuing witch-hunts, especially, at present, the investigations instigated Frank Field into Wirral Labour Parties and into Socialist Organiser.

Reviewing policy: Labour Party Socialists should organise conferences, day schools, discussions and brain-trusts to help Labour's left develop alternatives to the pro-market, pro-capitalist direction of Much can be done. To do it. Labour Party Socialists must avoid being wrecked by the factional con flicts which have dogged Labour's left in the years of depression since the miners' defeat and ruined other attempts to establish rank-and-file left networks.

Political and Sister Park) ervers:

Prom, ideological difMark Salman ferences on the left are inevitable: debate on them is healthy and need not hinder joint work where there is agreement. But the Labour left today is polarised into two camps.

On one side stand those orienting to the Socialist Movement and the broad scheme of developing a new left based as much on activities outside the Labour Party as on those within it. On the other stand those orienting more to Labour Left Liaison and the construction of an alliance of pressure groups for detailed and tenacious battles within the Labour Party.

Socialist Organiser has argued that there are one-sided reactions to defeat on both sides of this divide, and that the polarisation has made arguments unnecessarily bitter and one-sided.

On the face of it, the socialist Movement camp is obviously right. For new forces the left must look to fresh struggles. With some versions of the so-called "twin track" strategy, only the most hidebound fetishist resolution-passing, committee-coaxing, and Labour Party internal routine could disagree, In the latest issue of Labour Briefing, for example, Bryn Grif fiths defines the "twin track" strategy as to do with "how Poll Tax Unions have been used to recruit to the Labour Party" and socialists "raising non-payment as Council candidate[s] in the local elections." Socialist Organiser has argued for exactly this approach (under the rubric •Back Basics!").

But on closer examination there is sense to some of the objections from Labour Left Liaison. Other advocates of the "twin track" mean something quite different from Brvn Griffiths. For many in the Socialist Movement, the "twin track" is a half-way house built of wishful thinking. It is a way of avoiding both the hard grind of fighting against the odds in the Labour Party and the rigours of the SWP's sectarian project of building an "alternative party".

The idea, instead, is to hang around somewhere in the middle, gather a broad "movement" including people in the Labour Party, people in the SWP, people in the Green Party, and people in nothing much at all, and hope the party problems will come out in the wash.

The cost of this approach is loss of focus - loss of any idea of where to apply leverage for campaigns, and which direction to push. That's why the Socialist Movement can get big conferences (2000 people or more), but little campaigning results. That's why the Socialist Movement wing of the left had almost no impact at last year's Labour Party Conference, apart from some good work round the lesbian and gay rights motion, while the Labour Left Liaison wing was far more effective.

The incoherence in the Socialist Movement is reproduced in Briefing/Socialist Outlook, the particular faction which initited Labour Party Socialists. Labour Briefing was lauched as a breakaway from Socialist Organiser in 1980 round the project of getting as many left-wingers as possible selected as Labour candidates for the Greater London Council elections of 1981. The line was to push left-wingers of any sort, and leave the detailed politics to be sorted out later.

What happened "later" was that the machine-politics left wing fell apart and betrayed its promises under fire from the Tories. The same thing happened in Islington and other Labour councils targeted by Briefing. The policy of focusing "power" and dismissing "abstract" ideological issues brought defeat and demoralisation.

Undaunted by experience, one wing of Briefing/Socialist Outlook still pursues the same tack, codified in Labour Briefing's masthead slogan "Labour Take the Power!" They are as devoted to internal Labour Party machinations as the hottest partisan of Labour Left Liaison could wish, indeed more so than is good for anyone's mental health.

*It is important that the conference should not allow Labour Party Socialists to become a pseudopod of Briefing/Socialist Outlook. The committee should include a broad range of views."

Another wing of Briefing/ Socialist Outlook sees hope neither in Labour "power" politics nor in the more outward-looking Labour Party orientation advocated by Bryn Griffiths. They look instead to the Greens. In the National Union of Students, for example, they vote for the Greens and the SWP in preference to Labour.

Here the "twin tracks" are not like walking.on both legs, or flying with both wings, but rather divergent directions which never Labour Party Socialists must not fall foul of this incoherence. It cannot heal the divisions in the Labour left all at once, but it should avoid being boxed in as an opponent to Labour Left Liaison. It should keep lines open, especially, to the Camference.

Some Socialist Labour launch a Labour one wh Socialist tion, so form of Cold uggests uhrio:. paign ll fon Labo Part Democracy.

It is importa nt that the conference should not allow Labour Party Socialist s to become a pseudopod of Briefing/Socialist Outlook. The committee to be elected should include a broad range of views.

Briefing/Socialist Outlook sometimes pretends that it is a broad movement in and of itself, with no more ado, but the conference should not accept that pretence - reflected, for example, in the questionnaire distributed for conference delegates, which asks them to record affiliation to Labour Briefing as a species of "involvement in a local left caucus" whereas other political affiliations are to be recorded separately. Labour Briefing does have contributors outside its hard core just as Socialist Organiser does), but that hard core, Outlook, despite its big political incoherences, is organisationally as tight and narrow as any of the Labour left factions. are, its supporters probably less numerous than SO's, Although policy decisions are to be referred to the AGM, debate on at least two contentious issues within Labour Party Socialists will be started at the weekend's concomrades from Briefing/ Outlook propose that Party Socialists should «Socialist Campaign for a Victory" for the coming election, modelled on the ch was associated with Organiser in 1978-9. Imitait's said, is the sincerest flattery: calculation, however, that the use of the same the different conditions of today would bring very limited UDLIC HE response from today's depressed Labour left, and a ferocious witch hunt from the Labour leadership. It would be better to look for different ways of getting a voice for socialism in the election campaign.

The other debate is on the trade union block vote. Some comrades propose that we should favour abolishing it, and replacing it with a voice for the trade unions in the Labour Party at local level. Others (rightly, we think) say that such a move would weaken the labour movement and divert trom the necessary fight for democracy in the trade unions.

Conference Registration 9am-11am Saturday 19 May. Sheffield Poly Student Union, Pond Street.

Scan page 6

6 KOREA

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 448

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →