Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

CPSA CONFERENCE SPL Fight sexism at work and in the unions

Socialist Organiser no. 447, 10 May 1990 · scan p. 16 · about 1,183 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 16

By Caroline The CPSA Broad Left have produced a "Charter for CPSA Women Workers" At first glance it appears good, covering issues ranging from low pay to sexual harassment.

But on closer inspection it becomes clear that the Charter offers no solutions to the many problems faced by women workers. The 10-line conclusion in the pamphlet offers but one piece of advice - join the Broad Left.

The Charter fails to address many questions pertaining to women's oppression, including one vital one: the oppression of women within the trade union movement. The Charter rightly shows how management oppress women. But it. doesn't deal with an important issue.

Why, in a union where over 70% of the membership are women, do men overwhelmingly dominate the union structures? The reason the Charter fails to deal with this question is that the politics of the Charter are essentially those of Over the years Militant's attitude towards women's oppression has been at best tokenistic and at worst downright reactionary. Militant have no answers as to how to fight women's oppression, other than to make propaganda now and to wait for the revolution to free women. The end of capitalism, in which women's oppression has its roots, will mean the beginning of the end of women's oppression. But Militant fail to accept that the divisive nature of capitalism which sets man against woman and white against black, must be fought in the here and now.

Working class women are doubly oppressed as workers and as women. Many women are now in waged work, yet they continue to bear the burden of family life. From this double burden stems many of the problems faced by women, both in the workplace and in the unions. To effectively deal with women's oppression in the workplace, trade unions must look to reforming themselves.

The sexism of male trade unionists is a barrier to the involvement of women in trade unions. Additionally, there is the very real problem of bureaucratic union structures which reproduce the problem of the male-dominated union meeting. Add to this the lack of thought about childcare provision at meetings, unsociable meeting hours and transport difficulties for women then it is hardly surprising that unions are male-dominated. The Charter fails to recognise these problems within our union - let alone deal with them.

It is vital that women are fully represented in the structures of the CPSA in order to ensure that issues specifically relating to women members are raised effectively. Full «Militant supporters pretend that problems do not exist between union members within the representation of women on union committees will also help to encourage other women union members to become more active. It is vital that CPSA looks at its own structures, promotes women positively into its ranks and fights for demands relevant to women.

Militant supporters pretend that problems do not exist between union members within the CPSA. The Charter reflects this blinkered view. This is partly because Militant argue vociferously against positive discrimination for women on the grounds that it "divides the working class" and have always opposed the self-organisation of women for the same reason.

Yet it is capitalism which divides the working class and making bland propaganda will not resolve the problem. Men will continue to dominate the CPSA unless some form of positive discrimination, eg. reserved seats for women on the NEC, is implemented. Women will continue to feel unable to participate in union meetings with men sitting on the top table unless CPSA women's groups are set up to encourage women's participation and give women confidence.

Positive discrimination and self-organisation, combined with a working women's charter raising both workplace and union demands will ensure that the specific oppressions faced by women are truly taken on.

The record of the CPSA Broad Left on women is far from progressive. Time and time again Militant have rejected motions at Broad Left conference calling for the setting up of Broad Left women's groups, and reserved seats for women on the CPSA NEC. When policy was carried in 1986 to set up Broad Left women's groups, the Militant women's officer and Broad Left National Committee failed to carry it out.

Militant themselves make no attempt to ensure Broad Left election slates reflect the 70%-plus women in the CPSA. This resulted in the disgraceful spectacle in 1987 of the Broad Left NEC largely dominated by men. Militant argue it is insulting to women to positively discriminate in their favour.

What is insulting however, is the fact that many good Broad Left women are passed over in favour of Broad Left men who have all the advantages in the first place. To put it in a nutshell, Militant refuse to accept that life in a union is much harder for a woman than a man. This attitude means that however good the demands of the CPSA Women's Charter, they won't be won unless our union is transformed to truly represent the majority of its members. Socialist Caucus has been agitating for many years for positive discrimination and self-organisation of oppressed groups within the CPSA. CPSA conference: representing members. Photo: John Harris By Ruth Cockroft fice bran n May 1989 I started working for the Civil Service, recruited on a casual basis at the Training Agency Head Office in Sheffield.

As a casual, my contract was at first for one week, eventually it was extended monthly for the next 12 months.

Management call this kind of job insecurity "flexible working" whereby workers are subject to incredible pressure to ensure that they kep their jobs from month to month.

The CPSA has a policy that sanctions casualisation for arguably legitimate reasons, such as longterm leave, maternity or annual leave, but the reality is that casualisation is now being used across many departments of the Civil Service to systematically substitute for permanent jobs, drive down the conditions and wages of all clerical grades and to erode union structures.

The CPSA should wake up and see casualisation for what it is - a massive attack on the union and on fice branch has been the decline in union membership and the complete stagnation of the union branch itself. Without determination and an active union, casuals are notoriously hard to recruit -membership in the Training Agency has declined by 200, roughly the number of casuals there are in the building.

The BL'84's passivity about casuals and Leedham's own "couldn't care less" attitude has bred cynicism amongst rank and file members that the union is not really there to represent their interests. This is reflected in extreme ly tiny meetings.

Yet it is not only the right-wing/ BL'84 who are to blame for the failure to fight casualisation. In 1986/7 a Broad Left DHSS SEC had the chance to lead a fight against Limited Period Appointments (LPAs) when DHSS workers in Wales took strike action. Instead, the DHSS SEC left the strikers stranded and refused to spread the fight, saying any fight against LPAs should be subsumed into a general fight against staffing cuts. It never was.

My own experience of being a

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 447

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →