Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The fight for trade union democracy

Socialist Organiser no. 447, 10 May 1990 · scan p. 15 · John Moloney · about 861 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

their defence.

The argument goes like this:

(i) A course of action is correct if it furthers the revolution. So far, so good, but at this point Militant's logic takes over from that of Trotsky, with dire consequences.] (ii) Without Marxist leadership the working class will never achieve socialism.

(iii) Therefore, any action which allows the "Marxist leadership" to stay in positions of influence etc. in the union [eg. Macreadie as general secretaryl is to be supported.

In this argument, the positions of influence held by the "Marxist leadership" is the supreme goal. Court case after court case follows in which working class organisation is subordinated to the capitalist state for the sake of keeping a handful of "Marxists" in positions.

But what Trotsky actually said was that for Marxists means and ends are linked. We fight only by those means which help mobilise workers for our end of working class self-liberation. We reject those means which turn the working class into passive spectators or subordinate the unions to the bosses' state — neither of which help point to our goal.

So Militant's attempt to use Trotsky in their defence falls down.

It is no accident that Militant so love litigation. When they have found their positions of influence threatened they have not only issued writs against trade unions and the Labour Party, but even Militant sup Macreadie o Court sorter Johr utside the redundancy notices to workers [remember Derek Hatton). Anything Is permissible if it keeps the "Marxists" in power. In reality such behaviour only alienates workers.

All this reveals a lot about the Millcant and their view of socialism. Their bureaucratic schedules ["don't strike this year, strike next year"] and their positions, from which they make their mind-numbing "socialist" propaganda, come first, working class action last. PSA London Socialist Organiser has a Spostions on the questiod positions on the question of trade union democracy: all full-time officials of the union should be elected annually, by individual ballot at workplace meetings, and should be on salaries linked to those of the members they represent.

This is the policy that Socialist Organiser supporters, and other activists within the Socialist Caucus group, have been arguing for within CPSA. This year's conference agenda gives us the opportunity to really move forward on this vital issue.

Motions 502, 503 and 510 together show the way ahead for all those who wish to see our union became a genuinely democratic organisation.

However, even if these motions are heard (and it is unlikely that enough time will be given to this part of the agenda), there will be organised opposition within conference arguing against them.

The National Moderate group, and the mis-named Broad Left '84 will both be keen to tell delegates how "unrealistic' and 'impractical' these proposals are. Perhaps they will tell us (again) how tired members are of all these boring old elections.

Having elections annually for all posts is not a magic solution to all the union's problems. But it is a means of giving to the ordinary membership a greater degree of control over the running of their union. One of the demands of the great Chartist movement of the 1840s was for annual elections to the British Parliament.

Why, 150 years later, is it a dangerous and unacceptable proposal that fulltime officials be accountable every 12 months to the people they represent? Or could it just possibly be that some interested in hanging opt are made si- dividuals зате THere tions for themselves and their cronies than they are in the principles of democracy and accountability?

The fight for union democracy goes much further than annual elections. An overhaul is needed to turn our unions into genuine bastions of working class democracy and struggle. This means not only making formal changes such as electing full-time officials annually -and paying them the same wages as the workers they represent — but also ensuring that power really is in the hands of the rank and file members.

Measures to achieve this include:

• Union policy-making bodies to be made up of elected lay members only.

• Voting to be at workplace meetings — we want informed, collective decision • Strikes to be automatically official.

• No secret negotiations. Every stage of negotiations should be subject to rank and file ratification at mass • Shop stewards must be elected at mass meetings held in the workplace.

• The right of members to criticise union policy; to meet unofficially.

• Defence of the rights of trade union branches and district committees against the central union bureaucracy.

• Trade unions to fight for total independence from the state. Non-cooperation with the Tory anti-union ¡any is also vital that unions represent all laws of the members - particularly black, women and lesbian and gay members. This means implementing measures to help ensure unions are habitable for oppressed groups, such as:

• The right to self-organisation for black people, women, lesbians and gays.

• The purge of open racists from all union positions.

• The expulsion of fascists.

• Positive discrimination measures.

The CPSA is our union. Let's begin the fight to control it.

Support motions 502,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 447

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →