Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Poll tax - don't

Socialist Organiser no. 447, 10 May 1990 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 1,989 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

naive notions, Socialist Organiser supporters believe that a merger would not be in the best interests of CPSA's membership.

The uniting in one union of the managers and the managed presents very great practical problems, and attempts a fusion of two groups with often conflicting interests. The result could easily be a decline in activism, and dominance by management grades over and above their numerical strength. Suggested DSS London This last year we have Thistores events ing historic events in Eastern Bloc states.

Who would have thought a year ago that those seemingly invulnerable stalinist dictatorsnips would have been largely smashed and we would now be witnessing the rebirth of independent working class activity after 40-plus years of Stalinist repression?

However, the picture has hardly been one of thoroughgoing victories for the working class.

No-one will have forgotten how the democracy movement in China was drowned in the blood of the workers and students in Tiananmen Square. In Romania the Stalinist National Salvation Front still holds Even in those countries where the bureaucracies have been toppled there have been election victories for the free-market capitalist parties. And all across Eastern Europe the far right is growing and antisemitism is widespread.

Given the records of 40-plus years of Stalinist actually existing socialism", genuine socialists have a huge task in front of them and they remain relatively weak.

We have an absolute duty as socialists and Trade Unionists to do everything in our power to help those socialists in their struggle.

The British trade union movement has an appalling record on Stalinism - maintaining links with police-state official "unions" while socialists were imprisoned for their activities. members on this question. Our aims for the future should be:

• To seek merger with other non-managerial groups of civil servants.

• To promote resource sharing, and general trimming of bureaucracy across civil service unions, where this would not damage services to members.

• To forge unity in action by the rank and file. To halt bureaucratic merger attempts.

Support motion 669.

Now is the time to put that right.

There are a number of concrete steps that conference can take to really help those in struggle:

• Affiliate to the Campaign for Solidarity with Workers in the Eastern Bloc (CSWEB). CSWEB is currently organising a Support the Socialists' campaign to raise funds for workers' organisations in Eastern Europe. It also held labour movement conference in January, addressed by Eric Heffer MP and socialists from Poland, East Germany and Czechoslovakia, and was attended by over 500 people.

• Affiliate to the Chinese Solidarity Campaign. CSC has been campaigning in solidarity with the democracy movement since last year. It is organising a demonstration on 4 June to commemorate the anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre. • Support composites 1087 and 1093. These argue for support for all independent trade unions and specifically for support for SOTSPROF, the Russian socialist independent trade union.

These are all important practical acts of solidarity which will materially help the working class in Eastern Europe. It will be a great step forward to pass these motions.

It is worth noting that as their sole contribution to this issue, the so-called Militant have a single motion which offers no course of action or makes any proposal for making solidarity with Eastern offer their ponderous "theorising" about the nature of planning. It goes to show the complete rottenness of this semi-Stalinist sect that after a year of revolutionary upsurge this is all they have to say.

Thousands of CPSA members will not pay the poll tax.

An opinion poll recently in the Sunday Correspondent estimated that 8 million people won't pay the Poll Tax in England and Wales. Add to this the one million non-payers in Scotland and you have a mass campaign which is shaking the Tories. Many : low-paid CPSA members just cannot afford to pay — and this year's pay deal won't help.

Whilst By Trudy DH HQ Should we take unions to S court? Can the judges help the left beat the right wing?

This issue could well surface again in the CPSA. Some supporters of the Newcastle Central Office 8 have raised the prospect of resorting to the courts should the NCO 8 appeal be denied, or fail, or should an unacceptable sentence be re-imposed by the NEC after a successful conference appeal.

It's important to sort out the issues of principle, what is and is not acceptable for socialists in the fight against the right wing.

We should also separate the idea of using the law to defend jobs.

The NCO 8 are quite right to consider legal action against the DSS if they lose their jobs as a result of expulsion from the union but they should take on the employer not the union.

There is nothing necessarily wrong in using the law against right wingers. This should be separated off from the issue of using the courts as a power inside the trade unions. -This is wrong in principle.

The principle we seek to defend is the independence of the trade unions from the capitalist state.

The trade unions are working class organisations, the courts are part of the capitalist state. The unions - however imperfectly - defend the interests of workers. The courts - despite the fact that socialists can demand legal protecover the Poll Tax, they are not finished yet. They will try and use all the methods available to them to force people into paying - by freezing our bank accounts, by wage arrestments, by deducting it direct from Income Support, etc.

As trade unionists we must resist this. We must insist on support from the national union against wage arrestments. The Treasury must be told that the union won't tolerate any deductions from our wages. We must continue the pressure on Ellis and Co. to take this issue seriously. A good start would be for CPSA to state it won't make any wage arrestments on its own staff who don't pay!

If Ellis refuses to act (as tion for workers against the worst excesses of capital - fundamentally defend the interests of the rich and powerful. The courts are an integral part of the bosses' state, one finger in the clenched fist which includes the anti-union laws, MIS and the riot police.

To advocate that the courts intervene inside the trade unions, even if only to uphold the constitution of the union -is to propose subordinating the basic defence organisation of working class people to the bosses' state.

Allowing the capitalist state to adjudicate inside the trade unions goes against the ABCs of socialism.

Our socialism is a socialism of working class self-emancipation. In Karl Marx's words: "The emancipation of the working class is the act of the working class itself" . Through the interplay of ideas and struggles the working class must transform itself from passive victim of exploitation to active, conscious fighter for liberation.

There can be no short cuts. Socialism cannot be decreed from above, it cannot be introduced for the workers, it must be made by them. There is no substitute tor the long, bitter and protracted battles to transform the working class and its organisations.

To call in the courts because we can't beat the right wing inside the unions is to give up on the working class as the agency of change.

The socialist way to fight the right wing is to mobilise the rank and file. If the left fail to beat the official apparatus because the rank and file is too weak, ill informed or demoralised, then we we must lobby our own members in the computer centres to take a stand against wage arrestments.

As for deductions from Income Support, many DSS branches have policy against this. All motions on this issue have, however, been removed from the conference agenda by Chambers and Ellis.

Again, we should continue the pressure on Ellis to back his own members rather than the Tories. We cannot allow a repeat of last November when DSS members went on strike in some London offices against being used as Poll Tax snoopers and the union refused to support them! The union should give automatic support to members who take action against the Poll have lost.

To fight the right wing apparatus with the apparatus of the bourgeois state makes rank and file mobilisation and litigation equally valid options. The special place that working class activity has in the fight to democratise and transform the trade unions is lost.

Advocates of using the law inside the unions. end up amending the old slogan of the Clyde workers' committee; instead of "If the leaders won't lead, then the rank and file must" , we get "If the rank and file won't fight then the lawyers must"

Let's look at some of the arguments employed to justify using the courts inside the unions. By far the most popular is "We must fight the right wing by any means necessary".

This sounds very bold, uncompromising and militant, but very few people who voice this idea really believe it. "By any means necessary" must mean exactly that: ie. any means can be employed. But few people in the CPSA would contemplate murder and assassination or the taking of hostages as justifiable tactics in the current battle against the The left in the electricians' union used to justify ballot-rigging on the grounds that you must beat the right wing "by any means necessary". Look where it got them. The union has been in solid right wing control for the last thirty years.

Some of the more pompous supporters of Militant have tried to justify taking the union to court by calling Leon Trotsky to the witness stand in

Scan page 15

CPSA CONFEREI Thatcher's attacks a tale of two branches Tax. However, if the union won't support us we should consider in the trade unions, and how to fight the Poll Tax in the We'll sor ballot on By Vicki Morris, PSA T privatisation has been a he countdown to PSA headlong rush shrouded in mystery...and the workers have already been paying the price.

We are used on the whole to working in ones or twos, in small teams with professional officers, and of pension and redundancy terms, comparable with those we enjoy now, the move to the privatised PSA will be a personal disaster for thousands.

We will soon ballot for a one-day national strike and then selective action. These would deal a body-blow to management's assumption that PSA staff will go quietly into, first, a gersmamentowned company to remove our civil service status, and finally the privatised PSA.

We have got some work to do persuading membars that action will win. But initially it has been easy to make people see that management and gorainment an so stubborn, action of some kind is now the only way to try to defend our jobs. And that it will be fun giving management a slap in the face back. ment. It is not surprising, thorafore, that management, realising the Branch Officers are a soft touch, have refused to give the CPSA full details of the proposed relocation and most impor tantly, whether jobs are guaranteed in London.

The Broad Left in DH/SS HQ have launched a campaign amongst CPSA members around demands that jobs, wages and conditions of service are guaranteed for all members. The right-wing branch leadership are content to seek management assurances on no compulsory redundancies. Whilst the Broad Left has argued for a vigorous campaign to build up support for strike action if management refuse to give guarantees, the right-wing have left the membership uninformed.

The Broad Left have argued for full membership consultation at every stage of negotiations. The right-wing leadership have not bothered to make any real attempts to find out what members think - let alone consult them before agreeing anything with

----- pull-quotes -----

strike against off

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 447

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →