Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

On the Black Hills

Socialist Organiser no. 447, 10 May 1990 · scan p. 10 · Vicki Morris · about 793 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

cheaper, and had fewer rights, and where there were fewer controls on industry._Profits accordingly skyrocketed.

During the time of the Flint closures, GM president Roger Smith was annually awarded higher and higher bonuses, at one point clocking up a two million dolla raise.

Michael Moore, creator of *Roger and Me, tried to find Roger By English teacher used to extol the virtues of William Wordsworth's poems though, she said, some people found them rather "sowhattish".

William Wordsworth goes out for a day in the country and sees some daffodils or an old turf-cutter slaving his guts out and goes "aren't they nice? So pastoral.

Well, Channel 4's 'On the Black Hill' was better entertainment than a Wordsworth poem, and every bit as so-whattish but, if I can be allowed to judge, had nothing like as much literary merit.

It was quite simply the story of three generations of one family growing up in the Black Hills of the West Midlands. I had anticipated an epic family saga — more tasteful than the usual, being Channel 4but, though it had its moments of passion, the stream of the years had the effect of ironing out the ups and downs and ending up an anodyne chronicle of rites of passage -growing up, having children, or not, dying..

This in spite of nicking literary conventions from authors as varied as Thomas Hardy, DH Lawrence and Dylan Thomas.

The central characters were twin brothers growing up almost inseparable, and ageing together, eventually coming to share the same bed that their parents had slept in. As seems popular at the moment, the twins were portrayed as having a telepathic understanding, and a tendency to smother each other with their more or less mutual jealousies.

Hence neither ever got married, though one would have liked to.

Just as in most people's lives there wasn't much plot although there were plenty of ironies. These consisted mostly of people not forgiving in other people the same faults they had themselves committed previously in other contexts.

And there was a rather clumsy device of showing change in the outside world by the regular intrusion of modern aeroplanes into the brothers' lives.

I tried to work out why the programme was so unsatisfying. Perhaps because the countryside bores the life out of me, although there are ways of treating the subject which wouldn't make the brothers' story just a pretty picture of a stagnant backwater of history.

Wordsworth is worth something because he uses the rural idyll upon which he reflects to a purpose — to contrast with the life and values of the town. Thomas Hardy's gripping "Mayor of Casterbridge' is all about a dying way of life, but there's the point: his stories have a dynamic: the clash of old and new. No such dynamic was present in 'On the Black Hill' I don't know if it's sad to be so adamant that drama needs a bit of conflict to take it out of the mundane. But some competition clearly a good thing...af least in historical drama. thousands of people will buy the recording just because of his name As for Joe Soap, he'll need luck even to get in to the recording studio - and a great deal more luck for the recording company to give his song any publicity.

Is Meryl Streep a better than Jane Soap who has to around for bit parts?

Maybe, maybe not. But if Jane Soap isn't lucky, she may spend her whole career in bit parts. Meanwhile Meryl Streep gets big money from producers because they know her name will sell pictures to distributors and to audiences.

Between two scientists, Professor Z and Dr X, it is relatively easy to have an objective measure of who has produced more and better work. But neither will get rich.

The way the market works when buyers don't have any objective measure of whether product A is better than product B is that buyers take price as an indicator of quality. If A costs more than B, buyers assume A is better than B. A gets a reputation for being better than B; so A is priced higher; so A maintains the reputation.

Something similar happens among capitalists and entrepreneurs. On the whole capitalists get super-rich not through manufacturing useful goods but through financial wheeler-dealing.

People have got rich on Wall Street and in the City while being complete dunces at the technicalities of finance. Once they get a reputation for being good deal-makers, they get brought in on the big deals, they get big money, and their reputation is reinforced.

The manufacturing capitalist, however, deals in more tangible, objectively measurable things.

The capitalist market economy rewards the confidence-trick much more than it rewards performance.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 447

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →