Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Dream and nig! in America

Socialist Organiser no. 447, 10 May 1990 · scan p. 10 · Colin Foster · about 986 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Belinda Weaver reviews 'The Hunt Red October' and "Roger and Me' Films don't need slogans and manifestos to be political. All movies are political, since they present pictures of society based on certain assumptions. If the same assumptions are repeated over and over again, it's because filmmakers believe that they are true, that they represent the way things are.

In American movies, the American Dream - that anyone, regardless of background, can "make it' - is the underlying myth of many films. It's a con, of course, but that fact is never admitted; American directors have mastered the art of presenting society as they wish it to be, rather than as it is. Myths about America abound in their films, nowhere more blatantly than in comedies. Laughs are the sugar coating that makes the bitter pill easier to swallow.

Yet dramas also have their share of myths. "The Hunt for Red October' , superficially a chase movie, is built on a vast superstructure of myth. Briefly, the message is 'Russians bad, Americans good', but it's put across a little more subtly than that.

The Red October is a new superquiet nuclear submarine, capable of penetrating American defences and landing its warheads off the American coast. When it goes AWOL, the Soviets want to find it and sink it, and so do the Americans who fear they have a first strike weapon aimed right at them.

But Dr Jack Ryan, a CIA analyst, is convinced that Ramius, captain of the Red October, is defecting and we're all set for a tense countdown. Who will find the Red October first?

Critics haven't been LART 'Unbridled car italişm in American movie, but it's first class entertainment of the kind many critics are too lofty to enjoy these days - a simple adventure story, well told.

It has its weaknesses. The Russian crew, headed by Sean Connery's Ramius (speaking Russian with a nifty Scots accent) talk perfect English till they're confronted by Americans when once again Russian becomes the language of choice.

Scenes where the defecting Russians muse about their future life in America are sentimental slop.

The other weakness is in the underlying assumptions. We're expected to swallow, straight faced, the assumption that the Russians (devious, lying, treacherous) can't be trusted with a first strike weapon, but the Americans (straight talking, fair minded) can. Piffle. This is cold war rhetoric of the first kind, but the Americans get away with it because of the introductory disclaimer PreGlasnost...

"The Hunt for Red October', enjoyable as it is as an adventure movie, is cultural brainwashing, based on a thoroughly false view of America as upright and fair, the land of opportunity and freedom.

more tarnished image of the A land of opportunity is on view in 'Roger and Me' , a rather black documentary about the effects of unbridled capitalism on an American town!

Flint, Michigan, was a oneindustry town, and the industry was cars. General Motors had a number of factories there, which it began to close in the sixties. First the truck plant shut down, then the car plants closed, and pretty soon, thousands upon thousands of car workers were out of a job.

General Motors wasn't closing down production though; they simply opened new plants, in Mexico, where the workers came A 'pre-glasnost' adventure story Smith and bring him to Flint, to confront him with the human tragedy of his company's policies.

Smith proved elusive, so Moore told the story anyway, filming interviews with laid off workers and other residents of Flint, the dying town.

This is no straightforward documentary, but a rather savage black comedy. The deputy sheriff responsible for evictions comforts himself that people are at least being thrown out of their homes by someone they know, someone sympathetic.

Destitute people try to stay afloat as best they can, and their ettorts to survive are nothing short of heroic.

Moore challenges the view that a US NAVY company's only duty is to stay in profit, and that it should be accountable only to its stockholders. What about accountability to the workers who built the company and were the basis of its profits? Don't they deserve some consideration?

The residents of Flint, long encouraged to work for and depend on GM for jobs, were suddenly left with nothing - no job, no future, no compensation. GM sucked Flint dry, then decamped to Mexico to begin the same scenario over again.

GM is of course only doing what all capitalists do — chasing profits. The human consequences are never considered.

Michael Moore says ceptable. He's right.

When the Sunday Times Britain* its list of Britain's 200 richest people on 8 April, it was dominated by millionaires who had inherited wealth.

The minority in the list who are self-made millionaires give us some measure of what themarket economy rewards.

Most of them made their fortunes in the City. Their special talent, if any, is for outdoing and swindling other rich people.

Four, by my reckoning, got rich through success in a productive trade rather than in managing or trading. Andrew Lloyd Webber, George Michael, Mick Jagger and Paul McCartney got into the ranks of the super-rich through show business.

Why does the market economy reward performance by musicians - and by movie actors and actresses - so much more than performance by, say, scientists or technologists?

The paradoxical, but quite logical, fact is that showbiz performance is rewarded better partly because no-one can measure very well whether it is good or not. "Stars" are stars because they command big money, and they command big money because they're stars. Whether they are good or not is secondary.

Is Paul McCartney really a better performer than Joe Soap whom no-one has ever heard of? Who knows? When Paul McCartney records a song, it is heavily advertised, and

----- pull-quotes -----

BUICK CITY Welcemes You

The con- economy THE HIDDEN HAND

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 447

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →