6 WORKERS' RIGHTS A Workers' Charter for free trade union
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Solidarity what trade is is all about.
Withou collective organisation and solidarity, the working class is only a collection of victims of exploitation, individuals at the mercy of market forces.
That, of course, is what the Tories want. Over the past ten years they have introduced law after law against solidarity.
Any action at all is unlawful unless it is against your own employer at your own place of work. That means that if your employer does what Rupert Murdoch did to his printworkers — provoke a strike, sack them, and reopen business elsewhere - there is nothing you can do lawfully against him. If your boss artificially divides his business into separate units, you can only take action unit by unit, on issues within the unit. cannot strike unless you have first Even within those limits, ballotted - and ballotted in a way that a crusty old High Court judge finds satisfactory. The number of things they can find wrong with ballots is increasing all the time! They said the railworkers ballot last year was no good because the question was unclear. They said the dockers' ballot was no good because the Dock Labour Scheme allegedly ruled out strikes. They considered saying that the engineers' ballot was no good because of the arrangements for counting manual and white-collar votes.
Then you cannot have more than six pickets, and you can't expel strikebreakers from your union or penalise them.
Already, if you strike unlawfully, your union leaders have to do more than just abstain from supporting you. As the National Union of Seamen found out in the Dover P&O Ferries dispute, they have to act effectively to wreck your strike. Otherwise the union's entire funds will be seized.
The labour movement needs to fight to stop the new Tory Bill and to ensure that the next Labour Government makes effective trade unionism lawful once again.
At first glance the GMB composite does not look too bad. It calls for "the repeal of anti-union legislation and its replacement by a fair and positive framework of industrial relations legislation". Moving it, GMB general secretary John Edmonds said that Labour Government must repeal not just parts, but all, of the "mass of menace" represented by the Tory anti-union laws.
The real intentions of the Labour Party leadership, however, were made clear in the weeks following conference. In the Independent on 9 October, Michael Meacher wrote: •Would it be lawful for workers to refuse to handle imports from South Africa?' Answer, no. 'Would meat porters be allowed to take action in support of nurses?' Answer, no." Moreover, "we would retain the current Code of Practice peaceful picketing which limits the number of pickets [to six]"
None of this had been voted through Labour Party conference. What had been voted through, as a package with amendments or voting in parts forbidden, was the Policy Review. Alongside many positive proposals, the Policy Review promises to many Tory law:
*Union members should have the right to a secret ballot on...strikes. Although in the nature of industrial disputes there will continue to be occasions on which walk-outs take place and strike action occurs before any ballot can be arranged, a ballot should subsequently be held. Any union member should be able to appeal to an independent tribunal if a ballot has not been held."
The problem here is not whether ballots are desirable. On the whole they are, so long as they are workplace ballots held after collective discussion. The problem is whether a judge, or a supposedly "independent' tribunal, should have the power to decide when and how a ballot should be called, and whether the ballot is a satisfactory one.
It doesn't take a lot of imagination to picture how judges could use such power to call ballots at critical moments during strikes, timed to suit the bosses. They should not have that power. Trade union democracy should be regulated by union members, not by the State.
But the Policy Review is only half the story. This month the National Executive will publish a new policy document which, according to the press, will include many of Meacher's restrictions.
It will agree to keep Tory laws against the closed shop, and Tory regulations limiting picket lines to six people. It will recognise the right to solidarity action only for workers with a direct "occupational or proWapping fessional interest" dispute.
And even before that document is published, a statement by Labour front-bencher Derek Fatchett on teachers' plans for action to save jobs has taken us further down the road of state regulation.
National strikes over local redundancies are likely to be illegal under a Labour government," so the Sunday Correspondent (22 April) reported Fatchett as saying, "although action across an [education] authority would probably be allowed."
It's a very narrow definition of "occupational or professional interest" which rules that teachers in one local authority have no interest in helping to save the jobs of teachers in another threatened by cuts due to poll tax and "Local Management of Schools"!
Labour's policy on trade union rights is grossly inadequate. The 1989 TUC Congress called for full restoration of the right to strike, but many TUC leaders have gone along with Labour front-bench policy, or actively supported it. We need a campaign from the rank and file for a better policy.
At the 1988 and 1989 Labour Party conferences, Wallasey CLP moved composites demanding a Workers' Charter of trade union rights. In 1989 the composite got 2¼ million votes. The North West Regional Labour Party conference in March 1990 supported Wallasey's call for a Workers' Charter.
Now 33 trade union leaders have launched a "Campaign for Free "Solidarity is what trade unionism Trade Unions", with a four-point charter including the main items from Wallasey's 12-point list.
These are arguments for trade union rights:
The core of our composite is the twelve points of our proposed Workers' Charter. These are our arguments for them. • 1. The right to unionise. Individual workers are always in a weaker position than individual employers. In any case, employers do not operate individually: they have their own "unions" • Without the right to organise, workers will be helpless victims of exploitation. • 2. The right to strike and picket. Unions are no use unless they can take action. And the strike is the basic form of trade union action.
Six people plaintively waving placards as cars and coaches speed by do not make an effective picket line! We do not advocate violence. we do advocate that the picket lines should be strong enough to make workers stop and listen to the arguments. We do advocate that when bosses bus in scabs and back them up with massed ranks of police, strikers should not be limited to helpless token protests. We do insist that a restriction on the number of pickets is as undemocratic as would be a restriction on the number of people allowed to join demonstrations. • 3. The right to solidarity action. Ambulance workers and nurses need decent wages and conditions as much as other workers. They want to fight against cuts in the NHS. Yet they are inhibited from striking by concern for the sick. They need other workers striking to support them and to support the NHS.
Many workers are prepared to strike. In an opinion survey in January 1990, 50% overall, and 30% of Tory voters, were willing to strike in support of the ambulance workers. Yet any such strike is unlawful under Tory law — and if Labour's front bench get their way, it will continue to be unlawful under a Labour Government.
Also, as long as trade unions are barred from solidarity action, any small workforce facing a hostile boss is helpless. The boss can sack them and hire scabs, and then they can do little lawfully. If the boss shuts down and re-opens business under another name, there is nothing they can do lawfully. • 4. The right to organise. The new Tory Bill is supposed to make it inlawtul to refuse someone a job, r sack them, solely on grounds of union membership. That is not enough. There needs to be a legal Get your CLP to circulate the Charter to all its affiliated right of access for union representatives from outside — full-time officials, or shop stewards from other workplaces: people who cannot be victimised by the employer under any pretext. • 5. Union control over rulebooks. Certainly every union member should have a right to vote on who should lead their union. It's a scandal that some unions refused that right, and thus enabled the Tories to look as if they were putting through a democratic reform. But union democracy should be enforced by union members themselves, not by anti-union judges. Current Tory law insists that union executives must be elected, but by postal ballot, so that the main influence on the members voting is the capitalist media. • 6. The right to stop unsafe work. Unions had protested about unsafe practices on P&O ferries long before the Zeebrugge disaster. Workers had complained about risks on the North Sea oil rigs long before the Piper Alpha disaster. Nothing was done — so people died. If work is unsafe, it should be stopped at once. It's no good waiting for a government inspector. • 7. Consultation and information. Every employer owes his wealth to the workers who produced it. Why should he have the right
----- pull-quotes -----
union branches, a covering letter asking them discuss it.