Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Conflicts coming in the USSR

Socialist Organiser no. 447, 10 May 1990 · scan p. 3 · about 1,300 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Were we wrong about the W official trade unions in Socialist Organiser has argued that those official unions are not real workers' organisations, but state organisations for controlling workers. Yet the official unions have been protesting strongly against government plans for more free market measures.

The central trade union council has demanded that:

• the state continue to guarantee the right to work;

• the transition to a regulated market economy' be gradual;

• the government conclude an annual 'social contract' with the unions.

This protest reflects the discontent of one wing of the ruling bureaucracy more than that of the workers.

For decades the leaders of the official unions have been nominated by the top bureaucrats rather than freely elected by the workers. A man could go from being head of the KGB secret police to being chief of the trade unions simply as a move sideways within the hierarchy.

The unions' job was not to defend workers' interests - they never called strikes - but to help raise productivity. They were able to recruit workers because they controlled welfare provision, sick pay, sports facilities, holidays, housing.

But in the miners' strikes of last year, the offical unions took part in negotiations on the management side. One of the miners' demands was for a drastic reduction in the The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race"

Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Newsdesk: 071 639 7965 Latest date for reports: first post Monday Published by WL Publications Ltd -PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU)

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser number of trade union officials.

The opening-up of Soviet society under Gorbachev has lessened central Government control over the trade unions. In some countries of Central and Eastern Europe, Czechoslovakia for example, it seems that the collapse of the Stalinist regime has led to reform movements taking over the old state unions and transforming them into workers' organisations. Nothing like that has happened in the USSR, though.

Last weekend a new Confederation of Labour was set up at a conference of independent trade union groups in Novokuznetsk, western Siberia. According to reports in the Financial Times the conference supported the right of Lithuania to independence, condemned the Soviet Government for taking Lne economy to the brink of collapse, and discussed but rejected a proposal from a Social Democrat to set up a new workers' political party.

Those independent trade union groups, not the state-run organisations, are the real Soviet labour movement. Some part of the state unions' new show of militancy must be due to an effort to compete with the independent movement.

According to official figures, strikes in the USSR totalled over nine million striker-days in the first quarter of 1990 - an average of 130,000 strikers per day. In 1989 the average was 100,000 per day.

The background to the conflicts between the bureaucracy and the working class and within the bureaucracy is economic impasse. After five years, Mikhail Gorbachev's evolving programme for modernising the Soviet economy is at a dead end.

The economy is worse than ever. The latest official statistics show labour productivity down two per cent compared with a year before. By the end of 1989, only 50 out of 1200 basic consumer goods were readily available.

With the loosening of central control, the command economy has broken down. But it has not been replaced by a functioning free-market economy.

«The rule and the laws of Moscow are now being more or less openly defied by everybody from individual republics to regions, cities, enterprises and workers' organisations... At enterprise level, the crumbling economy has promoted a host of semi-legal or openly illegal practices.

"Factories have long been involved in direct barter transactions to get around the bottlenecks of central purchasing. Now they are forced to use other devices, like priming orders with scarce dollars to ensure supplies" (Financial Times, 3 May)

The response of Gorbachev's faction is to press forward faster. The talk is of privatising seventy per cent of state enterprises, and freeing seventy per cent of prices - in other words, going for a tullblooded private-profit market economy. Some of Gorbachev's advisers talk of ten million unemployed in the USSR.

A programme on those lines was promised for this month. Then the press was told that it might be delayed until autumn. Now the line is that a package will be announced very soon, but it will be more gradual than Poland's shock therapy.

"Most independent trade unionists in th USSR...are determil to defend workers" interests in the transition."

The USSR is following Eastern Europe's path towards Westerntype capitalism. But the hesitations and contradictory signals from Moscow indicate that there is strong resistance within the ruling bureaucracy (and among ordinary people) - much stronger resistance than in any East European country.

The growth of independent trade unions in Eastern Europe has been feeble since the revolutions of 1989. Most workers are evidently willing to wait and see the results of the drive towards market economies. Even in Poland, where an independent trade union movement, Solidarnosc, has existed since 1980, workers' militancy has been lowkey.

The USSR is different in this respect too. Most independent trade unionists in the USSR seem not to oppose the drive for market economics on principle, but they are determined to defend workers' interests in the transition. And theirs is a militant and growing movement.

Bureaucratic resistance and workers' militancy combines with the simmering and intractable problem of breakaway movements in the USSR's minority nations to make the Gorbachev faction's drive towards a private-profit economy an extremely perilous venture.

Yet it would be difficult to restore the old command economy now even if the Government wanted to. A Stalinist economy, to function effectively, requires a mighty political machine for terror, mobilisation and repression; and such a machine cannot be obtained just by government decree. The present method of economic regulation — bureaucratic haggling and muddling through, complemented by the black market — cannot continue.

Even if Gorbachev is ousted in the coming months, the same choices would face his successors. They could retrench only for a short period. Sooner or later, they would probably be driven on the same course towards a private-profit economy - and they would face the same obstacles and conflicts.

Already the USSR has seen open war between Armenia and Azerbaijan, bloody conflicts between central government and local nationalism in Georgia, and economic war with Lithuania. The coming months are likely to see even more open conflict.

Despite the long-term potential of the growing workers' militancy in the USSR, the short-term prospects are not good for socialists.

The nationalist movements of the USSR's minorities are often intolerant towards their own minorities — Russians in the Baltic states, Abkhazians in Georgia, the Armenian enclave in Azerbaijan. As far as can be judged from Western press reports, most of those in the USSR who reject free-market economics are conservative Russian nationalists, and most of the democrats are pro-capitalist, at best social democratic.

There are socialists in the Soviet Union who reject both Stalinism and capitalism, and fight for a democratically planned economy with self-management - but very few.

The immediate prospect is of messy, brutal conflicts in which neither side stands for democratic socialism. Our response must be guided by principles;

• consistent democracy for relations between nations. The right for every nation to determine its own future, the right of every minority to full equality:

• support for the workers against the bureaucrats who exploit and oppress them, whatever confused or wrong ideas the workers may have.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 447

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →