Trotsky on the right of nations tr break awav from the USSR
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Famine victims in the Ukraine 1932. Stalin deliberately promoted mass starvation as a way of controlling the rural population. nationalities in Russia facilitated in field of the national question, the extreme the conquest of power whose paths are no more rectilinear by the proletariat. It was as if the than the paths of the agrarian proletarian revolution had sucked revolution. The federated structure in the democratic problems, above of the Soviet Republic represents a all, the agrarian and national pro- compromise between the centralist blems, giving to the Russian requirements of planned economy Revolution a combined character. and the decentralist requirements of The proletariat was already under- the development of nations optaking socialist tasks but it could pressed in the past. Having connot immediately raise to this level structed a workers' state on the the peasantry and the oppressed na- compromise principle of a federations (themselves predominantly tion, the Bolshevik Party wrote into peasant) who were absorbed with the constitution the right of nations Leon Trotsky wrote this article (here abridged) in 1939, arguing for the right of the Ukrainians -and other minority nations in the USSR -to have their own states if they wish n one of the tiny, sectarian publications which appear in America and which thrive upon the crumbs from the table of the Fourth International, and repay with blackest ingratitude, 1 chanced across an article devoted to the Ukrainian problem.
What confusion! The authorsectarian is, of course, opposed to the slogan of an independent Soviet Ukraine. He is for the world revolution and for socialism - "root and branch" . He accuses us of ignoring the interests of the USSR and of retreating from the concept of the permanent revolution. He indicts us as centrists. The critic is very severe, -almost implacable. Unfortunately, he understands nothing at all (the name of this tiny publication, the Marxist, rings rather ironically). But his incapacity to understand assumes such finished, almost classical forms as can enable us better and more fully to clarify the question, Our critic takes as his point of departure the following position: *If the workers in the Soviet Ukraine overthrow Stalinism and reestablish a genuine workers' state, shall they separate from the rest of the Soviet Union? No." And so forth and so on. "If the workers overthrow Stalinism.." then we shall be able to see more clearly what to do. But Stalinism must first be overthrown. And in order to achieve this, one must not shut one's eyes to the growth of separatist tendencies in the Ukraine, but rather give them a correct political expression.
Socialist Organiser stands for workers' liberty East and West.
We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with working class socialism.
We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under FSUBISCRIBEE -Get Sucialist Organiser delivered to your -door by post. Rates (UK) £8.50 for six months. E16 for year.
Name Address Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose E.. Send to: Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA *Not turning) our backs on the Soviet Union, continues the author, "but its regeneration and reestablishment as a mighty citadel of world revolution - that is the road of Marxism." The actual trend of the development of the masses, in this instance, of the nationally oppressed masses, is replaced by our sage with speculations as to the best possible roads of development. With this method, but with far greater logic, one might say, "Not defending a degenerated Soviet Union is our task, but the victorious world revolution which will transform the whole world into a World Soviet Union," etc. Such aphorisms come cheap.
The critic repeats several times my statement to the effect that the fate of an independent Ukraine is indissolubly bound up with the world proletarian revolution. From this general perspective, ABC for a Marxist, he contrives however to make a recipe of temporising passivity and national nihilism. The triumph of the proletarian revolution on a world scale is the endproduct of multiple movements, campaigns and battles, and not at all a ready-made precondition for solving all questions automatically. Only a direct and bold posing of the Ukrainian question in the given concrete circumstances will facilitate the rallying of petty-bourgeois and peasant masses around the proletariat, just as in Russia in 1917 True enough, our author might object that in Russia prior to October it was the bourgeois revolution that unfolded, whereas today we have the socialist revolution already behind us. A demand which might have been progressive in 1917 is nowadays reactionary. Such reasoning, wholly in the spirit of bureaucrats and sectarians, is false from beginning to end.
The right of national self-determination is, of course, a democratic and not a socialist principle. But genuinely democratic principles are supported and realised in our era only by the revolutionary proletariat; it is for this very reason that they interlace with socialist tasks. The resolute struggle of the Bolshevik Party for the right of self-determination of oppressed workers' control. We want democracy much fuller than the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers' privileges.
Socialism can never be built in one country alone. The workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own capitalist or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles worldwida, including the struggle of Uieter рир 1003 Tories solving their democratic tasks.
Hence flowed the historically inescapable compromises in the agrarian as well as the national sphere. Despite the economic advantages of large-scale agriculture, the Soviet government was compelled to divide up large estates. Only several years later was the government able to pass to collective farming and then it immediately leaped too far ahead and found itself compelled, a few years later, to make concessions to the peasants in the shape of private land-holdings which in many places tend to devour the collective farms. The next stages of this contradictory process have not yet been resolved.
The need for compromise, or rather for a number of compromises, similarly arises in the workers and oppressed nationalities in the Stalinist states against their own anti-socialist bureaucracies.
We stand:
For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working class-based women's movement.
Against racism, and against deportations and all immigration controls.
For equality for lesbians and gays.
For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.
For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.
For a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against capitalism.
We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board. to complete separation, indicating '"The sectarian, so of ten happens, finds himself siding with the police, covering up the status quo, that police violence by sterile speculation on the superiority of the socialist unification of nations as against their remaining divided."
thereby that the party did not at consider the national question solved once and for all.
The author of the critical article argues that the party leaders hoped "to convince the masses to stay within the framework of the Federated Soviet Republic". This is correct, if the word "convince" is taken not in the sense of logical arguments but in the sense of passing through the experiences of economic, political, and cultural collaboration. Abstract agitation in favour of centralism does not of itself carry great weight. As has already been said, the federation was a necessary departure from centralism. It must also be added that the very composition of the federation is by no means given beforehand once and for all. Depending on objective conditions, a federation may develop toward greater centralism, or on the contrary, toward greater independence of its national component parts. Politically it is not at all a question of whether it is advantageous 'in general" for various nationalities to live together within the framework of a single state, but rather it is a question of whether or not a particular nationality has, on the basis of her own experience, found it advantageous to adhere to a given In other words: which of the two tendencies in the given circumstances gains the ascendancy in the compromise regime of a federation - the centrifugal or the centripetal? Or to put it even more concretely: have Stalin and his Ukrainian satraps succeeded in convincing the Ukrainian masses of the superiority of Moscow's centralism over Ukrainian independence OF have they failed? This question is of decisive importance. Yet our author does not even suspect its existence. -Do the broad masses of the Ukrainian people wish to separate from the USSR? It might at first sight appear difficult to answer this question, inasmuch as the Ukrainian people, like all other peoples of the USSR, are deprived of any opportunity to express their will. But the very genesis of the totalitarian regime and its ever more brutal intensification, especially in the Ukraine, are proof that the real will of the Ukrainian masses is irreconcilably hostile to the Soviet bureaucracy. There is no lack of evidence that one of the primary sources of this hostility is the suppression of Ukrainian independence. The nationalist tendencies in the Ukraine erupted violently in 1917-19. The Borotba Party expressed these tendencies in the left wing. The most important indication of the success of the Leninist policy in the Ukraine was the fusion of the Ukrainian Bolshevik Party with the organisation of the Borotbists.
In the course of the next decade, however, an actual break occurred with the Borotba group, whose leaders were subjected to persecution. The Old Bolshevik Skrypnik, a pure-blooded Stalinist, was driven to suicide in 1933 for his allegedly excessive patronage of nationalist tendencies. The actual "organiser" of this suicide was the Stalinist emissary, Postyshev, who thereupon remained in the Ukraine as the representative of the centralist policy. Presently, however, Postyshev himself fell into disgrace. These facts are profoundly symptomatic, for they reveal how much force there is behind the pressure of the nationalist opposition on the bureaucracy. Nowhere did the purges and repressions assume such a savage and mass character as they did in the Ukraine.
Of enormous political importance is the sharp turn away from the Soviet Union of Ukrainian democratic elements outside the Soviet Union. When the Ukrainian problem became aggravated early this year, Communist voices were not heard at all; but the voices of the Ukrainian clericals and National Socialists were loud enough. This means that the proletarian
Scan page 9
vanguard has let the Ukrainian national movement slip out of its hands and that this movement has progressed far on the road off separatism. Lastly, very indicative also are the moods among the Ukrainian emigres in the North American continent. In Canada, for instance, where the Ukrainians compose the bulk of the Communist Party, there began in 1933, as I am informed by a prominent participant in the movement, marked exodus of Ukrainian workers and farmers from communism, falling either into passivity or nationalism of various hues. In their totality, these symptoms and facts incontestably testify to the growing strength jof separatist tendencies among the Ukrainian masses.
This is the basic fact underlying the whole problem. It shows that despite the giant step forward taken by the October Revolution in the domain of national relations, the isolated proletarian revolution in a backward country proved incapable of solving the national question, especially the Ukrainian question which is, in very essence, international in character. The Thermidorean reaction, crowned by Bonapartist bureaucracy has thrown the toiling masses far back in the national sphere as well. The great masses of the Ukrainian people are dissatisfied with their national fate and wish to change it drastically. It is this fact that the revolutionary. politican must, in contrast to the bureaucrat and the sectarian, take as his point of departure.
our critic were capable of thinking politically, he would have surmised without much difficulty the arguments of the Stalinists against the slogan of an independent Ukraine: •It negates the position of the defence of the Soviet Union"; "disrupts the unity of the revolutionary masses"; "serves not the interests of revolution but those of imperialism". In other words, the Stalinists would repeat all the three arguments of our author. They will unfailingly do so on the morrow.
The Kremlin bureaucracy tells the Soviet woman: inasmuch as there is socialism in our country, you must be happy and you must give up abortions (or suffer the penalty). To the Ukrainian they say: inasmuch as the socialist revolution has solved the national question, it is your duty to be happy in the USSR and to renounce all thought of separation (or face the firing squad).
What does a revolutionist say to the woman? "You will decide yourself whether you want a child; I will defend your right to abortion against the Kremlin police. " To the Ukrainian people he says: "Of importance to me is your attitude toward your national destiny and not the 'socialist' sophistries of the Kremlin police; I will support your struggle for independence with all my might!"
The sectarian, as so often happens, finds himself siding with the police, covering up the status quo, that is, police violence by sterile speculation on the superiority of the socialist unification of nations as against their remaining divided. Assuredly, the separation of the Ukraine is a liability as compared with a voluntary and equalitarian socialist federation: but it will be an ungestionable asset as compared with the bureaucratic strangulation of the Ukrainian people. In order to draw together more closely and honestly, it is sometimes necessary first to separate. Lenin often used to cite the fact that the relations between the Norwegian and Swedish workers improved and became closer after the disruption of the compulsory unification of Sweden and Norway.
wenty-something years ago, vividly remember feeling a shock of emotional horror when I read an account by, I think, Ignazio Silone - or could it perhaps have been Victor Serge? - of how, one drunken night in Moscow in the late '20s, the author and a friend had seriously talked about burning Lenin's mummy. —Not because they were hostile to Lenin, but on the contrary, because they believed the cult of Lenin, of which the sainted medieval mummy on display in Red Square was only a part, to be a gross offence against the real Lenin and what he had represented.
I saw immediately that they were fight, and that it would be far better, more communist, and indeed more "Leninist" , to burn the waxy remains of Lenin than have them continue there on show for Stalin. Yet the initial shock I felt - a feeling of Oedipal sacrilege, perhaps as if Lenin were both Pope and father — told its own story of how powerful the Lenin cult was; and that is probably why I remember it so sharply.l The Lenin cult was strong even with people who believed they should hate and seek to destroy all cults, religions and pseudoreligions, including pseudo-political religions.
The cult was in its entirety a creation of Stalin. Up to his collapse at the end of 1922, a year before he lied, Lenin had immense authority within the Bolshevik Party and within the Communist International it had founded in 1919. But he was primus inter pares, first among equals.
Lenin had to argue and fight for his positions, using the methods appropriate within an organisation of self-respecting militants. Sometimes he was in the minority, as on the issue of peace with Germany, a matter of life and death for the revolution.
It was Stalin and his partners between 1923 and 1925, Zinoviev and Kamenev - whom he would have shot in 1936 — who made Lenin into a secular all-knowing god, the Russian "God the Son" to Marx's universal "God the Father".
Lenin had tried to get rid of Stalin, and had spent his last strength attempting to organise d campaign against Stalin's Great-Russian chauvinist activities in Georgia and against the growing bureaucratism of the state, centred increasingly on the new-minted (1922) General Secretary of the party.
He had broken off all personal relations with Stalin, and written to the Bolshevik Party congress asking them to remove him. But Lenin's memory, like his corpse, was a prisoner of the speedily fledging bureaucratic dictatorship.
The bureaucrats used his writing and their own alleged continuity with Lenin as a source of authority in the struggle which began in the autumn of 1923 between the working-class Trotskyist opposition and the Stalinist apparatus.
They were the Leninists; those who in fact continued Lenin's real politics, Trotsky and his comrades, were lapsing back to Menshevism or "had never really broken with it" Zinovier, breke with Stalio in 192h and joined the working-class opposition for a while once he had understood what was happening in Russia - said to Trotsky, looking back, "The trick was to link up our disputes of 1923-4 with the old disputes in the decade before the revolution"
Party history was stereotyped and falsified to provide the ruling Stalin faction with ideological labels and categories into which to try to slot their current opponents.
"Lenin" was a source of authority, but Stalin and his allies decided what Lenin was, backed up by the power of the State and its organs of propaganda and repression. It was a game of ideological blind man's buff.
At the beginning Stalin certainly did not know where he was going or what he represented. He knew enough, however, to give himself a lot of help with his interpretation of "Lenin"
He used Lenin's death to open the doors of the party - which had considered itself under siege, holding on in Russia until the European workers' revolution could come to their aid - to vast numbers of careerists who could be relied on against the revolutionary working-class forces. Naturally he called this influx of careerists "the Lenin levy"
The more things moved away from Bolshevism and socialism, the more "Leninist" they were proclaimed to be. Stalin's version of the history of Bolshevism and of the revolution began to play the role in Russian society that the tales about the life and sayings of Jesus played for centuries in the lives of intensely Christian countries.
Lenin's comrade and wife, Nadezhda Krupskaya, was to live out her last 12 years as Stalin's political and moral prisoner, publicly honoured living political mummy. But she had spoken the truth in 1926 when she said that if Lenin were still alive, he would be in jail.
Lenin's mummy came to symbolise his place in history - the dumb dead icon of a regime he would have loathed and fought as long as he had breath in his body; the official ventriloquist's dummy through which others could speak, albeit in a pastiche of his own words, phrases and ideas; the cardboard-thin image assigned roles he did not play, often the opposite of those he really played.] That is what "Lenin" has been for more than six decades. When bureaucratic factions fell out in Moscow or Beijing, they argued in tereninism", like medieval of Lenin-thought, religious-political figures arguing their own interests in terms of Biblical texts.
When Hungarian workers erected barricades behind which to fight the Russian Army in 1956, they used statues of Lenin to taunt the Russians. Most of the people on either side would not have suspected that Lenin could not possibly have chosen to be anywhere else in that grim Budapest except on the barricades and with those fighting the Russian ArmyLenin had written some of the most profound and powerfully felt argument in favour of national self-determination. He had infused the Russian labour movement - which was to break down the walls of the Tsar's prison house of nations with his own spirit on this question. Without knowing it, those Hungarian workers acted as if under guidance of some benign spirit of historic truth!
The official Stalinist state cult of "Lenin" was not entirely negative, Stalin, the gravedigger of the revol for they did publish his books and pamphlets, in vast editions and at cheap prices. It was even possible to read what he said and to learn by analogy what he would have thought of those who staged their annual military parades to glorify the Stalinist version Asiatic despotism around his mausoleum.
More than that too, as my own experience will show. Long ago, in the late '50s, I was a teenage Lenin cultist!
I had joined the Young Communist League, wanting a communist revolution, but painfully ignorant about it all. Then I learned that we believed in peaceful revolution! By way of votes to elect «Labour, Communist and. Progressive" Members of Parliament! Of the British Parliament!
The British ruling class would surrender peacefully? For anyone who knew Irish history this could not make sense.
I'd just been beaten up in a Salford police station by two cops investigating vandalism at a timber yard from which I'd been sacked for trying to organise a branch of the TGWU, and that stiffened my dogmatic ingrained conviction that revolution was not just a matter of winning elections. I didn't believe it. Couldn't.
But I couldn't argue agairist it, either, not against people who could quote Marx in support of the idea.
Then I read Lenin! Lenin dealt with the argument that "Marx believed in peaceful revolution" in a polemic with Karl Kautsky, The Proletarian Revolution and the Renegade Kautsky.
Yes, said Lenin, replying to Kautsky, Marx did say you could get a peaceful revolution in Britain and in the USA, and maybe in Holland Was he right?
I think he was right, said Lenin. So do I believe that we can now, in 1919, have a peaceful revolution in Britain? No, I don't!
What was Marx's reasoning 50 years ago? He argued from the fact that there was military-bureaucratic state machine in Britain or the USA, as there was in the other capitalist countries. His conclusions were probably valid then. But is the world still what it was when Marx analysed it? Are Britain and the USA still without the military-bureaucratic state?
No, they are not. No, Marx's conclusions of 50 years ago are not valid any longer.
Lenin was immensely respectful "authority", to Marx and Engels - and before 1914 to Karl Kutsky - but he never reasoned from authority. He brought it in to back up his own argument. He brought in what Marx said, and used it to help him think about what he was analysing.
There could be no more direct contrast with the way the Stalinists used Lenin's words as themselves proof of whatever they were trying to prove at a given time.
History does show that Lenin could indeed be used as the source of dogmatic certainties as interpreted by various "Leninist" popes. But you could not read arguments like the one about peaceful revolution, critically and with your mind open, without learning to think for yourself.
Lenin did not offer you a priori dogmas, or his own pontifications, he offéred you reasonings. No matter how dim you were, no matter how strongly inclined to settle in to the self-hypnosis of quasi-political religious certainties, Lenin - the Lenin that exists, the books - did not accommodate you.
He dealt in and offered you a Marxism which was historically rooted, conditional, evolved and evolving.
That Lenin is vivid and alive still. He cannot tell us much about many of the things that have come into existence in the world in the 66 years since he left it, but he can teach us how to think about it as Marxists.
Sections of the Russian bureaucracy now favour an open repudiation of Lenin, and also of the October Revolution, by the Russian state. Gorbachev — who belongs to and represents a different class from the class Lenin belonged to and represented - apparently still wants to go on arguing his programme in the old Stalinist way, invoking aspects of Lenin's writings that suit his needs. That cannot last if Gorbachev and his faction carry through their full programme, which is now, on current evidence, a programme of restoring capitalism. They too will break with Lenin.
Good! The sooner the better! The sooner they relieve Lenin from his long posthumous captivity, the sooner the workers in the Stalinist states and elsewhere will feel free to explore Lenin's real ideas and what he really fought for.
The day they burn or bury the poor dead remains of the great iconoclast Vladimir Lenin will be a good day for socialism. And for Leninists.
----- pull-quotes -----
WHERE WE STAND
SOCIALIST Britains death squad 9 exposed!
TIDE 120 years after the birth of Lenin