[In 1972-74 struggles brought down a Tory government…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-05-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
In 1972-74 struggles brought down a Tory government. Yet it was followed by a Labour governmen which carried outcuts on the behest of the IMF. Martin Thomas draws the lessons for today June 1970 the Labour government was voted out of office. The new Tory government started out with a proto-Thatcherite free-market Tremendous trade union struggles over the following three and a half years finally crippled it and forced it into an election which it lost in February 1974.
As a huge TUC demonstration against the Tories' anti-union laws made its way down the Embankment in March 1971, the left-wing AEU leader Hugh Scanlon jumped onto a bench and told the seething crowds that we must kick the Tories out and get Labour back in.
But — he felt obliged to add — this must not be another Labour government like the last one. It must be a Labour government with a socialist programme.
The slogan "Labour government *Labour government with socialist with a socialist programme" policies", had been the stock-in-trade of the Trotskyists since the 1940s. To the Trotskyists it meant that they were cleverly combining the need to relate to the Labour Party with the need to argue for their revolutionary programme. To the average worker. listening, it meant only that the Trotskyists wanted a Labour government and leftish policies of some sort.
The slogan was not transitional, but just a bit of ambiguous wordplay. If it should get any grip at all, it could only be miseducational, by implying that socialism was a blueprint to be executed by a Labour government rather than an effort of self-liberation by the working class.
And, indeed, the Trotskyists were unable to provide the trade union militants of the early '70s with any means to get a grip on politics. The Trotskyists echoed the spontaneous slogan "Kick the Tories out!" They added radicalism by saying "Labour government with a socialist programme" or "General strike to kick the Tories out!"
But "General strike to kick the Tories out!" was ambiguous too. To the Trotskyists it meant "General strike for revolution"; to anyone else it mean "General strike to force a general election", or, in other words, "General strike whose revolutionary potential the government can readily disarm by calling an election"
All this left Harold Wilson in charge of the political alternative to the Tories. There would be a few token Trotskyist candidates in the February 1974 election, but they were token candidates with token votes. Labour. But most of them had no orientation to the Labour Party at all. Militant mumbled its routine propaganda about nationalising the top 200 monopolies.
Some of these issues were thrashed out at the time, in the Marxist magazine, Permanent Revolution (early 1973).
Reviewing a book which argued that the working-class character of the Labour Party was withering away it agreed that active working-class involvement at ward level was declining. Many workers had lost patience and turned to direct industrial militancy instead.
That could be a step forward as long as we understand that the way "forward' to revolutionary politics is not a simple linear succession of steps."
But "the inability of direct industrial action short of general strike to come to grips with the whole of "Tory'-dominated society imposes the need to consider governmental alternatives on workers". The Labour Party retained its trade union links, and its ability to channel workers' political activity.
It had been important to "disinter" Lenin's concept of the Labour Party as a bourgeois workers' party; most of the Trotskyists had come to think of it as just the "workers' party"
The slogan "Labour government with socialist policies" was "fantasy-mongering" -But socialists needed to raise specific demands on Labour, "to mobilise workers against the Labour leadership", and argued that "the Labour Party remains a major - bourgeois — force in the politics of the working class. It will not die away of itself.
Besides its reluctance to come to grips with the Labour Party at all, one other revolutionary left in this period.
The Tory government was applying to join the Common Market. Most trade union leaders were alarmed at the prospect that their places in the corridors of power, already threatened by the Tories domestic policies, would be further menaced by a shift of authority to Brussels./ Wilson opportunistically denounced Common Market entry as being "on the wrong terms". Labour's deputy leader, Roy Jenkins, consistently voted in Parliament for entry and against Labour Party policy.
Both in the country at large, and in the Labour Party, it seemed that the Common Market was the great issue of the day which separated right from left.
When the Common Market had first become an issue in British politics in the early '60s all the Trotskyist groups had said that the socialist answer should be neither to oppose nor to endorse entry, but to build working-class links across Europe. Now they all allowed themselves to be swept away by the wave of nationalism. They all rallied to the anti-European cause (with only one exception, Workers" Fight), For the mainstream reformist left, oppositiop to the Common Market was logically linked to their basic economic programme, the "Alternative Economic Strategy" which emerged in 1972-4. They proposed import controls, price controls, increased public spending; selective nationalisations, and "planning agreements" between a Labour government and major conomy, but oriented to a stare rather than to war.
The Trotskyists criticised this nationalist strategy, of course; but how could the criticism make much ly en 2T911 shou WOT strat the n years gove Th Terer most feren itself bank build in thi from Th Parts beca each 20 2 from mem was as thi them unde mem Th also Nati Was! ty rignl the TERC orga abol disu Th beer
Scan page 7
The EEC left and the [workers' fight XI VOTE BOSSES' MARKET BOSSES' BRITAIN