Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Will Walesa become a new Pilsudski?

Socialist Organiser no. 446, 3 May 1990 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,282 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Second and final pa of an interview with Jozef Pinior of the Socialist Political Centre (Poland) witl Mark Sandell and Martin Thomas What do you think are the prospects for building a left wing within Solidarity?

It is a real possibility, not only within Solidarity but also with people from the former opposition against Stalinism.

For instance, there is now a move to the left by Karel Modzelewski. He was the author with Kuron of the Open Letter to the Party in 1964 la revolutionary socialist manifesto]. Modzelewski is now a senator in parliament, and he is a university teacher in my university in Wroclaw. In parliament he has organised a group to defend the workers.

He is moving to the left. He is not a revolutionary or a Trotskyist, but he is moving to the left. We have to support such positions.

We have to support everyone in Solidarity who is open to the left, who wants to discuss with us, who is against unemployment and pauperisation, and have a broad movement without sectarianism.

Do you still think you were right to boycott the elections last year?

It was obligatory for us. We had a really broad base at that time. On 1 May in Wroclaw we had a demonstration of about 15,000 people. It was a potential movement for more democracy than offered by the Round Table.

Our analysis was correct. But perhaps the boycott was a little sectarian. I'm not sure now.

How immediate do you think the threat from the right is in Poland?

I see two dangers. The first danger is state authoritarianism.

Walesa wants to be president. As president, if he wants to introduce the IMF programme, he must attack workers' rights - the right to strike, the right to free trade unions and so on. We could have something similar to Pilsudski's system before the Second World War - state authoritarianism.

Another danger is the rise of a reactionary, chauvinistic, antisemitic movement, with populist demands.

I'll try to explain the difference by comparison with Poland between the wars. There were two sources of authoritarianism in Poland then.

There was a nationalist movement, National Democracy, the biggest political party in Poland, openy anti-semitic, petty bourgeois. Some currents in it were fascist.

Another source of authoritarianism was the Pilsudski current. Pilsudski came from the pre-First World War Socialist Party, but after the war he was a military leader, not a socialist leader.

He created an authoritarian state, not on a nationalistic position, but on a state position, based on the state bureaucracy,the state apparatus, the military apparatus, and so on. His coup d'etat in 1926 was supported by the Socialist Party and the Communist Party!

I think they supported the coup d'etat because they were afraid of fascism from National Democracy.

How is Walesa motivating his bid for the presidency?

He says the changes in Poland are going too slowly. He calls for the complete overthrow of the nomenklatura. It is only propaganda, but it is his demand.

He criticises the Mazowiecki government from a free-market position - thạt they go too slowly with the privatisation of the economy. Evidently he wants to control the new wave of radicalisation in Solidarity.

He says the situation is very bad because we don't have privatisation yet, we don't have the free market yet, the nomenklatura is still in control and so on.

Since the split in the PPSRD) your group is mostly confined to Lower Silesia and Warsaw. Do you have plans for spreading to other areas of the country?!

Yes. We want to work on a national scale. We work together with the workers in rank-and-file Solidarity in Upper Silesia, and other areas.

We're organising a publishing house, and we're publishing a monthly bulletin.

What are your relations with the KRET group. [Mandelites)?

We co-operate. Our differences are tactical. They want to build a political party now, and we think that is impossible - we must build a political centre first.

How is building a political centre different from building a political party?

In our opinion we must be in the mass movement. We must be careful not to build a political party which will be sectarian, a political party outside the workers movement.

But don't the KRET group wan be inside the mass movemeni too?

Yes. But if we create a politcal party now there is a danger of being outside the mass movement. There is a danger of being marginalised.

What are your relations with leftwing groups in other countries in We have very good relations with the United Left in East Germany, with Petr Uhl in Czechoslovakia and with Kagarlitsky's group in the We are discussing the project an international bulletin, and of international confernce, maybe the summer or autumn. what remains of the PiD with We are open to everybody who has left positions in Poland. If the friends from the PPS(RD) are in the class struggle in Poland, with workers in the strike movement, in our campaign against racism and anti-semitism, we will work together.

We don't agree with them on some positions. They say Solidarity is a transmission belt between the government and the masses. That is a completely sectarian position. Solidarity is like a social-democratic trade union movement not a Stalinist trade union movement.

Before the municipal elections they created a list with a group which is close to the PPS in emigration. We didn't agree with that.

Other differences are on history, relations to the October Revolution, Trotskyism and so on.

The expelled the Trotskyists. It was a completely sectarian move, in my opinion. It was absolutely horrible.

If they will be in the class struggle, it is possible to be together in future. fully aware of its implications. Undoubtedly, the Code of Practice — yet to be worked out - will specify in more detall which women will be deemed "fit" mothers: lesbians and single women almost certainly will be excluded.

So while we celebrate the extension of abortion rights, we must argue that we won't compromise on the issue of choice for all women, and step up the campaign for the right of lesbians and single women to have equal access to reproductive treatments.

Also still to be debated is the demand for self-referral, where women themselves will be allowed to decide on whether or not to have an abortion, up to 12 weeks, without having to get the agreement of two doctors. This would significantly reduce the number of late abortions, as doctors exercising their "consciences" would be unable to prevent women from having an abortion. The campaign should continue to fight for this amendment to be passed, so that Britain is brought into line with the majority of European countries.

Nor should we forget that liberalising the abortion laws is meaningless if you live in Birmingham, where few facilities and provided, and many doctors refuse to grant "permission" to women seeking NHS abortions. To make the abortion law effective, we should campaign for better NHS facilities, sex education and contraception: that is the way to cut down on late abortions. Reversal of the cuts in government funding that have threaten up to 50% of family planning clinics must be fought for.

The campaign launched this week by MPs for better facilities, and contraception is an important part of the continuing fight for real choice: we should also encourage affiliations to the National Abortion Campaign, to build on the successes won in Parliament, and win an extension of our abortion and

Scan page 6

barra ANTED 1972: Mass strikes free jailed dockers and smash Heath's anti-union laws Little against Labour government The Trotskyists supported political problem crippledthe sense

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 446

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →