[John Cunningham looks at the film career of…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-04-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
John Cunningham looks at the film career of Greta Garbo n his book "Mythologies', published in 1957, the French writer Roland Barthes said of Greta Garbo:
"Garbo still belongs to that moment in cinema when capturing the human face still plunged audiences into the deepest ecstasy, when one literally lost oneself in a human image as one would in a philtre [magic drink or love potion), when the face represented a kind of absolute state of the flesh, which could be neither reached nor renounced."
And it is probably for her face that Garbo is best remembered (as well as her oft-quoted remarks about wanting to be alone).
Often shown in tight close-up, as in the famous portrait of Clarence Sinclair Bull, Garbo's face appears almost as a mask, disembodied, often the hair, neck and shoulders not visible. White and ghostlike, it emerges from a diffuse black background.
Yet at one level the face was as manufactured as any other Hollywood icon - Dietrich's legs, Monroe's blond hair. As Walter Benjamin so ably put it — *The cult of the movie star, fostered by the monev of the film industry, preserves not the unique aura of the person but the 'spell of the personality' " the phony spell of a commodity.
What made Garbo that little bit different was the element of ambiguity. Her expression is often ambiguous, the smile somewhat enigmatic, the voice wavering, uncertain - a woman of mystery, to use the cliche. -The film moguls managed even to capitalise on this aspect of the Garbo persona, however. One magazine in the '30s referred to her as "that weird and wonderful woman from the far north"
Most of all, it was her androgynous beauty which encapsulated her appeal and mystery. It should come as no surprise, once this idea is accepted, that Garbo was the ideal vehicle for such roles as "Queen Christina', where the Queen of Sweden masquerades as a man. In the first version of 'Anna Karenina' in which she appeared ('Love', directed by Edmund Goulding, in 1927) she transfers all her feeling on to her son, played in the film by an extremely androgynous 10 year old called Freddie Bartholomew.
Garbo at this time was only 22, and the scenes between them have a peculiar and very powerful effect. There is less erotic power in this relationship in the 'Anna Karenina' of 1935 (directed by George Cukor); however, the understated but ever-present 'mothering' of her Sunday 13 May Our international class After Eastern Europe -putting socialism on the agenda rish Protestants -people? lover Vronsky adds another layer of ambiguity.
Curiously enough, the costume dramas of the 1930s for which she is probably best remembered today ('Queen Christina' 'Anna Karenina' and 'Marie Walewska') were not box-office successes and found their greatest appeal among women audiences. Her almost stoic composure and somewhat detached "Scandinavian coolness' in the face of disaster and tragedy evoked a response from women who didn't identify with her earlier femme fatale' roles (such as "The Temptress' , 1926).
Men, it seemed, found her unsettling or even threatening. A contemporary critic Don Herold advised his readers to " ...detach themselves from the Garbo spell" but the writer Cecilia Ager wrote: "Garbo in "Camille' has character and standing, and, surprisingly, warmth. You don't just admire her tent and determined way she put them into practice.
In certain aspects of her life and work Garbo was able to define her own self, carve out at least some space for herself and her work in a way few other actresses could.
Bette Davis is one name that springs to mind for she, like Garbo, had a certain indefinable, ambiguousness about her. In this aspect if in no other Garbo was able to resist the totalising domination of tinsel town values.
She was able to show that behind the face-mask was something else, deeper and stronger - still perhaps resisting accurate definition, but you'll be able to see and feel it in her films. TV f is the eve of the Second World War and the War is about to impinge on the rather insular community of *Brass' (now removed to London).
Unfortunately it seems also to have changed the humour of 'Brass', although, admittedly, this was only a scene-setting first episode.
To put the goings on in historical context, Bradley Hardacre is about to make a damn great fortune out of the war: *Men's lives are blades of grass... and them that makes the mowing machines 'll harvest a lot of brass"
Indeed, the plot gave him the chance to disastrously divert the course of history by delaying Hitler's reply to Neville Chamberlain's ultimatum, which would have sealed the affair amicably with the two parties carving up such spheres of global influence as the Isle of Wight.
This, was the funniest bit of the programme. Unscrupulous Hardacre foils the chances of an unscrupulous peace.
We caught up with the latest on the Hardacre brood and, there, it is business as usual. Isabelle, for instance, is set to become the air-raid siren as she relieves young men setting off for war - perhaps never to return - of their virginity.
There is a new George and a new Austin. Both seem a bit too real to be funny. So does the set. There's the usual wealth of playing on words - but lots of it isn't jokes.
It ends up just sounding like cliches and purple prose, not a send up of those things. If the humour doesn't get sparkier, the programme is in danger of looking like the social melodrama it takes off.
It's going to end up like a jocular 'Upstairs, Downstairs' given that it is wartime. There might be too much temptation to concentrate on outside events, and to lose what was always the essence of the humour. the class interaction of the rich and poor familes.
Or, if not so much that actual interaction, the way it has been treated by great literary characters like D H Lawrence, and others not so great.
For that reason, it's impossible to do a 'Black Adder' where the same blackguardly upper-class character scrapes through the centuries. 'Brass'. , I fear' is a child of the '30s and of the very specific conditions it portrays.
If now, as happened in real life, everyone pulls together, the tedium might be relieved by interpersonal niggles and the appearance of the odd GI, but, on first showing, "Brass' ain't what it used to be.
----- pull-quotes -----
-Fighting Socialism students & socialist