Sectarian on ANC N sectarianism of Socialist
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-04-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Nothing could reveal the Organiser more clearly than in the week that one billion people hear Nelson Mandela's appeal for intensified sanctions against the regime you should decide to concentrate your coverage on grossly exaggerated claims of 'ANC torture' The ANC is completely correct to maintain an iron vigilance against the agents of Pretoria and against any attempt by imperialist provocateurs to penetrate into its ranks.
If that means that occasionally innocent comrades may get hurt, then that is only an unfortunate consequence of the war in which the ANC is engaged against the forces of racial tyrannyMK is a genuinely popular liberation army and the implementation of its programme - the Freedom Charter - is incompatible with the maintenance of racial capitalism. It is therefore inconceivable that MK will be used to defend Anglo American and other representatives of South African capitalism.
Yours in comradeship, Dick Carter Manchester
Scan page 5
ilding a left alternative in Bu Jozef Pinior, a leader of the 'Socialist Political Centre' Poland, visited London recently spoke to Mark Sandell and Martin Thomas. (This is the first of two parts).
That assistance socialists in Britain give you?
In the first place, defeat Thatcher! It is very important for us in Eastern Europe and in Poland because Thatcher is a symbol of capitalism.
If the British people vote against Thatcher and against capitalism, that will be a big success for us in the propaganda battle. It will help us in organising a left alternative in At present the left is very weak in You have a move to the right all the time in every country.
I think the move to the right is short term. In the long term it will. be different. The collapse of Stalinism is a big chance to build a revolutionary alternative to capitalism.
People hate Stalinism, and of course reject it. On the other hand you have in Poland the first results of the IMF austerity measures, and people must defend themselves against them. There will be a struggle.l Because of these objective factors there are real possibilities for building a left alternative in Eastern Europe. The very weak left which exists now must organise publishing houses, must publish books and bulletins, must be with the workers in their struggle, their strikes, their demonstrations, with pamphlets, with leaflets, vith magazines and bulletins.
The left must help the workers to produce factory magazines and newsletters. We must organise help for the workers when they are on strike, because the Walesa leadership is against strikes.
It is a very ambitious programme, and we have a long way to go. But just as the right wing bourgeoisie in the West helps the right in Eastern Europe, so the left here must help the leftist groups in Eastern Europe.
The collapse of Stalinism creates the possibility for a new consciousness in the international workers' movement, and a big regroupment. We must be together in this struggle.
You've recently had a split in the Polish Socialist Party (Democratic Revolution). What are the perspectives now of your group, the Socialist Political Centre? In the process of building a eft alternative in Eastern Europe, we must be very careful.
We must not be sectarian in this process. It is very easy to discredit revolutionaries in Eastern Europe now, because of objective factors. For most people, Marxism and left wing ideas are the language of the oppressor.
In Poland, the labour movement is inside Solidarity, not outside. In my opinion, after all the trotskyist experience in Poland under the martial law and since, and my individual experience in the PPS(RD), it is not possible to build a serious, big political party in this situation, with the whole labour movement inside Solidarity.
For example, I think that last December there was a sort of sectarian development in my party, the PPS(RD). We were against the Round Table [agreement between the Stalinists and Solidarityl. Our analysis was correct. Walesa and his leadership did betray Solidarity's revolutionary current in the Round Table. But on the other hand he won legality for the Solidarity trade union. And of course the workers went to the legalised trade union and not to us.
It would be stupid to be angry at the workers for going to a trade union. But our group was maginalised. And we had sectarianism in the group — fighting inside it, around a lot of currents and so on.
What has to be done now is to prepare a base for a serious left political party to emerge in the future when we have a workers' mobilisation from below. My model for this political party is the Brazilian Workers" Party. It is a political party with deep roots in the working class and with many currents.
I think there is a big chance to build such parties in Eastern Europe - in the first place in Poland, when we have a workers' mobilisation from below and a new mass strike movement.
Now we must prepare a base. So we decided — me and my comrades — to build a socialist political centre. We will discuss on the ideological and political level. We work with journalists, with students and with workers.
At the same time we work in the workers' struggles. We help the Solidarity factory committees to publish papers.
Our political centre is an open centre. Some of us are close to the Fourth International. But it is an open centre. It is not a section or a revolutionary party.
We will discuss all the problems. At the moment we are discussing the nature of the Eastern European states and the USSR.
We are active in the municipal elections. We have a candidate, and we have our political platform.
What's the difference between this political centre and a small political party?
Organisationally we are more open. It is not a political party structure. It is a first step to build a political party.
What's your view of the Solidarnose congress?
Solidarity is the labour movement in Poland. There is no labour movement outside Solidarity.
Inside Solidarity there are a lot of platforms, a lot of positions, a lot of groups. For me, the Walesa leadership are classical reformists. But in Poland there is no place for social democracy. If you want to be a social democrat, you must do something for the workers - shoes, housing and so on — but it is impossible in Poland.
The Walesa leadership want to turn Solidarity into a classical bureaucratic trade union. But it is difficult for them to do it. The situation in Solidarity is different from what it was at the time of the Round Table. Then, Walesa, controlled the situation by nominating people and so on. But now you have democracy in Solidarity. Workers can elect their represenPolish socialists demonstrate. tatives in factories and regions.
It will be very difficult for the Walesa leadership to change themselves into a labour aristocracy. They can't change their material conditions of living.
Walesa has had to explain why he moved to a better house - he published a book in the West, and he got money from that - but in our region, Lower Silesia, Which 1s the biggest Solidarity region, with one third of all the members of Solidarity, it is impossible for the regional leadership to change their material conditions.
It will be possible, maybe, but very difficult for them to change themselves to a labour aristocracy.
And we have a new wave of radicalisation in Solidarnosc. It's not on an ideological or political level, but on the level of trade union militancy, For example, when the Solidarity congress began in Gdansk there was a transport strike.
There were elections in the regions, and a lot of Walesa's opponents won these elections, Rulewski in Bydgoszcz, for instance, Slowik in Lodz.
It will be impossible for Walesa to control this movement in future. The problem is that in Poland there is no serious left political alternative.
My error two years ago was that I thought radical workers had to move to a left alternative. It is not true. It does not happen mechanically if there is no left publishing house, Marxist cadres and so on.
Instead you get demoralisation, frustration, agression, some radical workers moving to the reactionary wing — we say, the fundamentalists, like Jurczyk. On the one hand, they are against austerity; on the other hand, they are chauvinistic, sometimes openly anti-semitic.
There is also an anti-abortion platform mixed with populism. It is a real problem for us.
How strong would you say Jurczyk's current is?
It is weak. It exists only in one region, in Szczecin. They split from Solidarity and organised a separate trade union, Solidarity 80.
It is difficult to say what the strong currents are within Solidarity. Walesa controls the situation.
But there is a kind of new left Photo: Mark Catterall trade union bureaucracy in Solidarity. For instance, there is the Solidaritv leader in Lower Silesia, Frasyniuk. He is a real workers leader, and he is open to the left. And if Walesa becomes president of Poland, Frasyniuk has the best chance of becoming president of Solidarity.
Frasyniuk is in our campaign against racism and anti-semitism. He wants to fight against unemployment. He is not a leftist as a conscious position, but I think we must be for such people inside Solidarity if we want to build a left current.
Walesa is the strongest in Solidarity at the moment, but some of his opponents are strong too. For instance, Slowik in Lodz, who is very close to the Church, or Rulewski in Bydgoszcz, who is not close to the Church — he is radical, and he supported demonstrations against the Church's plan to change the abortion law.
What did your group do at the Congress?
We had a delegate. In our policies now in Solidarity we must be careful to avoid sectarianism.
Do you want free market measures? OK — but we must control. The workers, the labour movement, society must control. Do you want to open up the Polish economy for investments from foreign control? OK — but we must control. We must have a sovereign state. Society and the labour movement must control.
We rejected Stalinism and the bureaucracy. But capitalism in Poland is Argentine capitalism, not Swedish capitalism. So we heed the self-management alternative. We must control the economic situation.
Is there a democracy in our coun try? No. There is a danger of authoritarianism. Right-wing ideas, chauvinism, and anti-semitism are very strong. We must fight for democracy. We must fight for democracy from below, for the possibility to control the situation in every factory, in every region, and in the state.
So we explain to the workers that in Poland today the left stands for more freedom, more equality, more solidarity. We on the left are for democracy.
On this platform active inside Solidarity.
Scan page 6
year old Shenara 12 was helping out in her parents' shop in Knox Road, Forest. Gate, when a white man came into the shop wearing a crash helmet to hide his face and demanding money.
*Having grabbed a few pounds, he then pulled out a bottle and lit a piece of cloth coming out of it (the bottle was filled with petrol). The man proceeded to smash the bottle behind the counter and then ran off.
*The bottle landed less than a foot away from Shenara and set fire to some papers..."
*Mrs P who uses a walking frame, heard something at her letter box one evening and went to investigate the noise...By the time she managed to get to the passageway, she could smell smoke and saw her curtains smouldering. Fortunately she managed to i call for assistance...
Newham Monitoring Project Annual Report, 1988.
These are just two examples of the kind of racist attacks black people in Britain face all the time. As well as petrol bombs, racists use eventually deported to Sri Lanka after over a year in sanctuary in a church in Manchester. He was known to be an opponent of the Sri Lankan government, and his life would be in danger if he returned, but the British government was determined to send him back.
But there are hundreds of deportation cases: men and women separated from each other; mother separated from their children because the Home Office refuses to believe that they are really married, or really related. Viraj Mendis had been in Britain for fourteen years. Others have been here longer, sometimes all their lives, and are "sent back" to a country they don't even know.
Deportations show that racism in Britain is not only a problem of a few individuals with nasty ideas. Racism exists within the institutions of the state. The whole immigration system is inevitably racist: immigration officials have to administer racist laws, the essential content of which is to obstruct the entry and residence here only of black people.
But it's not only black people under threat of deportation who suffer racism. Discrimination exists at every level of society despite laws supposed to prevent it. Norman Tebbit
----- pull-quotes -----
» DDA PREFABET Iternative
- STRAIKUIACA LAPY PRECZ OD (OZI KOZiENICE ds. she wur rareu
KIEM PPS-R