Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"We have never had socialism or planning in the GDR"

Socialist Organiser no. 444, 19 April 1990 · scan p. 9 · about 1,583 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

is Kupfer of the | Left in Halle to Clive Bradley Wor the selections?

That is your assessment We were all disappointed. It was important for us to be in parliament, although not the number of representatives. What was really disappointing was the general result, first of all the successcs of the right-wing.

They won the elections very clearly. It was disappointing but not surprising.

Why did New Forum do so badTy?

First, none of the opposition has ever had close connections with working people. They were small groups, and didn't pay attention to the concerns of the masses.

Also, for example New Forum includes a wide variety of political streams. The only thing all of them have in common is that they want to create a different understanding of democracy. But as New Forum grew, they tended to have the same opinions as the other parties, for example on mification. So no-one wanted to vote for them.

One part of the Forum, those who really initiated the revolution, will leave the Forum, I think./ What is the organisationa! strength of the Social Demorats and the PDS?

They are very strong. The PDS has a lot more members than any other party - and the Social Democrats are growing, too. It's not yet clear what direction those parties will choose.

The PDS might choose to become a strong left-wing party with revalutionary traditions and aims. Or it might choose to become the strongest social-democratic party.

The Social Detourats were the stronger party last December, but they haven't managed yet to consolidate. They made a lot of mistakes What's the social composition the two parties?

The PDS is full of intellectuals not only intellectuals, of course. The Social Democrats have a lot of priests and lawyers, like all parties, but a lot of workers, too. There are some workers who remember the social democratic tradition, and are against the PDS-SED.

Do you mean literally Frenching" the tradition? Old workers?

Through their families, in many cases. I've talked to many social democratic workers who've told me about their family traditions. But only the active workers who are really thinking over the situation have joined the Social Democrats, or in some cases are still in the PDS. The majority of the others voted for the CDU.

What is the strength of workplace organisation?

After the revolution, the old trade union structures collapsed, but there was no new structure to replace them. Some workers tried to elect new leaders to the unions. On the one hand there was no strong or gaination to fight for workers' interests, but on the other, such an organisation was more necessary than ever before.

Factory managets, who had been part of the Stalinist system too, of course, are making deals and contracts with the Federal Republic.

Tt's difficult to decide who to support. There were initiatives' for independent unions. Many people who took part in setting up the United Left took part in such initiatives. The most important is the Initiative for Independent Trade Unions (IFUG), but hasn't managed to grow, it's very weak.

The old trade unions still aren't totally renewed. They still have the old bureaucratic structure, are only concerned with social security, and don't fight for workers' interests.

Is it true that workers see workplace activity as too risky because it might scare off Western investment?

Yes, it's true, I think. People want to have the same standard of living as the Federal Republic. Many are afraid that strong unions and factory committees will mean that no money will come in from the Federal Republic.

We have a campaign for factory committees, but there's always only a minority in the factories who have thought everything through. Sometimes they get into trouble with their colleagues, who think the positions. They were an associated group of the United Left, but we cut the connection. We had a coalition with them, but I think it was a mistake. Many of them are really old Stalinists, and quite militaristic. I don't know how long they'll survive.

How does the United Left define itself against the old system?

There are a lot of different streams in the United Left. For example, there are some ecological socialists who are totally against traditional concepts of the left, but who have much to say. It's important such people are involved in discussions. There are anti-Stalinist Marxists, there are some people who see themselves as anarchist, some people who only wanted to Left, etc, Even so, the United Left is more defined than the other parties. We are against Stalinism and for democracy. We believe we have never had socialism or economic planning in the GDR. We are also anti-capitalist.

But it's not possible to reduce the discussion to a simple formula. The United Left is a democratic organisation fighting against the restoration of capitalism in the GDR, and against all forms of dictatorship and non-democratic political structures.

What international links have you had in Eastern Europe?

Not much. But such links are important. Everyone in the GDR is only interested in the West. Our friends in Poland wanted to organise a conference.

Developments in these countries of course played an important role in inspiring the movement in the GDR.

How do you assess the position of the far right?

It would be a mistake to think that nationalist demonstrations show an extreme growth of the far right. But the far right is growing. We don't have democratic traditions, or popular discussions. Decisions were always made without majorities.

Most people aren't really nationalist or fascist. They just want to have the same kind of life as in the Federal Republic.

There are lots of youth groups and others who have a real tendency to nationalism and fascism. Many of them are initiated by people coming from the Federal Republic. For example, they went to the demonstrations in Leipzig with tons of material. They didn't they were fascists, of course.

Will unification strengthen the far right?

Unification as such won't strengthen them. But there's a big gap between the promises and the reality of unification. The Christian Democrats have promised everything, but they can't deliver it. People could get disappointed and look to the far right.

How do you now address unification?

We're not against unification, we're against incorporation. We haven't been against unification in general, but the unification being proposed was not in the interests of working people.

We will have the reunification of Germany. It doesn't make sense to fight it now. But we want to challenge the nationalist euphoria. dinated. We have contact with all the left, but the type of contact varies. We had contact with the left of the Green Party, former Green members, the United Socialist Party, and others. We try to be very open.

What role will there, or should there, be for West German unions in the GDR?

It's difficult to decide how to act. The West German unions are very bureaucratic, but it's not possible to work without them. What we can do is try to inform workers about how the West German unions act, and influence the choice of unions.

There are people in the unions in the Federal Republic who fight for workers' rights and we can use their proposals.

How do you approach the integration, for example, of parliamentary institutions?

We would want an all-German constituent assembly. It's not clear yet what is going to happen. The Christian Democrats, and East, want unity only from the top.

Is the idea of democracy from below in unification popular?

Not popular enough. People just want unification. Of course, people will accumulate experience and I think that maybe in one year they will agree with the things we say now. But it will be too late, although I am sure it will not be such a fast development as some people want to have.

Another big question about reunification is the currency. What do you think is going to happen and what is your attitude?

I've heard of some cases of workers already being paid in Western marks, but I'm not sure if it's widespread.

The general thing is that people want to have monetary integration very quickly. The situation now is that people are disappointed and angry because of the attitude of the West German government and the West German banks.

They had promised to have an exchange rate of 1:l, and now they are going to discuss a rate of 2:1. which is totally impossible. It would mean that we have higher prices and half the wages. I think they will be forced to have 1:1.

Of course, if you want a left politics you cannot just reduce yourself to aspects of the constitution. Among the other very important things: if the workers demand - and they have a right to demand equal money for equal work, I think we should support them.

We should criticise our government for the difference between their promises and their reality.

How definite is it that a reunified discussing with the USA and the USSR. I'm sure even many Christian Democrats are against being in NATO Is the military hierarchy in the GDR resistant to the unification and NATO?

It varies. There are some officers who are totally against unification and serving in NATO. West German uniforms have already been brought to the GDR.

----- pull-quotes -----

create independent unions, women's groups, the Christian

CAPITALISM AS VICTORIOUS. PASS IT ON,...

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 444

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →