Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialists and the first years of Thatcher of Thatcher government

Socialist Organiser no. 444, 19 April 1990 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 1,987 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

If opinion polls mean anything, we are moving towards the end of the Thatcher era.

Margaret Thatcher's personal rating in the opinion polls is down to 20 per cent, the lowest ever racorded for a prime minister, and Labour leads the Tories in the polls by 20 per cent or more.

The left still needs to learn the lessons of the era, and especially why Thatcher was not stopped in the first couple of years of her government, when working class confidence was still high and the Tories were almost as unpopular as they are now.

Those were also the first years of Socialist Organiser. The paper was launched in October 1978 by the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, which had been initiated in spring 1978. Martin Thomas looks back over our struggle for policies which could have beaten the Tories.

The impulse to form the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory came from the approach of a general election.

The election seemed likely to come in autumn 1978, but was eventually called for May 1979. As it approached, the left had spent four years battling against the cuts and wage freezes of the CallaghanWilson Labour government.

In 1976-77 the International Marxist Group and the Socialist Workers Party had stood some candidates in by-elections. Some of the IMG candidates got passably good scores. At one point it looked possible that there would be a serious joint slate of the revolutionary left for the coming general election.

The short-term advantages of such an effort could not be sufficient to outweigh the damage to the long-term work of socialists in the Labour Party. But what was their alternative policy for the election?

They had the general formula Vote Labour and prepare to fight' anything more than being tootsoldiers for Callaghan and mumbling Marxist criticisms for their own consolation?

Some of us evolved the idea of a Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory. We would try to organise Labour leftists with slogans and leaflets to win votes for Labour but simultaneously to build support for socialist policies.

At first we thought that this would inevitably be a small-scale affair. Unexpectedly we found that the project allowed us to tackle a problem we had already identified without being able to see an answer: that Marxists' activity in the Labour Party was largely propagandist, without any link to the broader left.

A small (and, as it turned out, rightward moving) lettist group called the 'Chartists' agreed to join the campaign. They brought a big range of contacts. By July 1978 we were able to organise a conference for the SCLV with 200 Labour activists, the participation of such people as Ted Knight and Ken LIvingstone, and a message of support from Arthur Scargill., In late 1978 Socialist Organiser was launched as the paper of the SCLV. SCLV local groups and later SO local groups drew in many new activists.

The SCLV published leaflets and broadsheets for the election in May 1979 which were used to one extent or another by five CLPs. As we wrote at the time: "Our achievements in the election were limited, but only by our small forces. In principle we proved it possible to mount a distinct leftwing campaign within the Labour Party's campaign - for the first time since the ILP's break with the Labour Party in 1932, or maybe even for the first time since the early 1920s when the young Communist Party and the Labour Party were still organisationally entwined."

The development of the SCLV and the accompanying shift from pure propaganda activity in the Labour Party to an attempt to organise a broader left, caused considerable controversy among Marxists. Many comrades argued that we were abandoning principles and giving credit to fake-lefts.

The proof that we were not would come after the election, when Knight, Livingstone and the 'Chartists' went for rate rises as the answer to the Tory cuts in money for local government. We fought them hard - indeed, maybe with less tactical flexibility than would have been desirable - they split from the SCLV in early 1980.

There was no revolutionary left slate for the May 1979 election. The SWP and the IMG stood a few desultory token candidates each, and got such small votes that both of them have renounced the idea of standing parliamentary candidates ever since.

The SWP had responded to the election of the Labour Government in February 1974 by developing the perspective that Labour| would rapidly be 'exposed' and the SWP would grow as an alternative mass party. *Steel r left' was the slogan. It was a disasi ter. The SWP lost probably the maioritv of its actives trade uni onists. They were demoralised 210C alienated bu policy of ul Itra-militancy and shrill denunciation n which lacked all relation to the cautious and hesitant evolution of workers' real response to the slum p and the betrayals of the Labour Government After som le floundering, the SWP finally regr ouped itself round the idea that wa irking class struggle had suffered a a decisive 'downturn' in the mid-'70s. The practical conclu- the mid-'70s sion was the sectarian orientation sion was th which they have followed (with this which they I or that modification) to this day. or that mod From wild expectations that they From wild would repla would replace the Labour Party, they slipped they slipped into passive acceptance that Labour that Labour would dominate working class pol ing class politics for the foreseeable future, whil future, while the SWP concerned itself with t itself with the 'militant minority'. They could summed up the policy as TI policy as "The SWP looks after the strikes, Labe strikes, Labour looks after the rest.

The inadequacy of this policy was The inade cruelly exposed in the 1979 election. cruelly expo:

After 11 or After 11 or 12 years of proclaiming everything ir everything in and about the Labour Partv to be to be a waste of time. the SWP slipped SWP slipped into a brief anti-Tory, bro-Labour binge. Paul Foot wrote: "For the next three weeks I **For am a stron am a strong Labour supporter. I am a that a Tory government government shouldn't be returned and I shall and I shall be going around to meetings Weac having telling everyone to vote Labour". evervone to The IMG did no better.. They The IMG formed an electoral front, 'Socialist formed an el Unitv'. with Unity, with one or two tiny other groups • S •Socialist Unity' got miserable votes for a few candidates miserable vo on a platfe on a platform considerably less revolutionar revolutionary than the SCLV's and then disapp then disappeared, its only lasting legacy being legacy being largely to exclude some

Scan page 7

ment. Turn to page 8 movement arris activists from the dramatic upheavals in the Labour Party that followed May 1979.

The years 1979 I were -811 among the most tumultuous in Labour's whole history. In October 1979 at Brighton the Labour Party conference voted for mandatory reselection of MPs and the principle of NEC control over the Party manifesto.

De-selection of MPs had been possible since the early '70s, but required an elaborate procedure to initiate it. The reform made a selection contest automatic.

The demand for NEC control over the manifesto had been triggered when Harold Wilson personally vetoed the call for nationalisation of 25 top companies included in the NEC-drafted Labour Programme of 1973. Both reselection, lost NEC control over the manifesto, but voted in the principle of election of the Party leadership by the whole Party (not just the MPs). It adopted unilateral nuclear disarmament, backed direct action against local government cuts, and committed Labour to withdrawal from the Common Market.

Callaghan retired as Party leader the same month, trying to get a successor securely in position before the new leadership election procedure could be introduced. But Callaghan's chosen successor, Denis Healy, was narrowly defeated terim figure and a left-winger, though a faded one.

In November Labour MPs disrupted Parliament to stop the Tories decreeing a rise in council rents. In January 1981 a special Labour Party conference adopted procedures for electing the leadership: there would be an electoral college with 40% of the vote for the unions and 30% each for the CLPs manifestos promised, but by how securely its leadership could control and protect themselves from the rank and file. On that criterion Labour had been seriously destabilised.

In the division in Labour's right wing that took place in March 1981, Healey, Hattersley, and the others who stayed in the Labour Party were right against Williams, Rodgers and Owen.

The SDPers found out 'from the right' what others have found out 'from the left' - that Labour had deep and tenacious roots in the working class, and that breakaways, even with an impressive-seeming initial base, are likely to throw themselves into a void. And the right-wingers who stayed with Labour finally managed to make the Party safe again for capitalism. But it was a long and arduous struggle for them, not completed even today.

The SCLV played an important literature, organisation of big meetings round the country and at trade union conferences with Benn and other speakers - was done largely by SCLV and CLPD. But the meetings were big, there were a lot of them, and the effort was decisive on such things as getting Labour's leadership elected by the whole Party.

SO did not just build the big movement. It argued a policy. It argued that the left which had destabilised the Labour Party must aim for a 'workers government' -a government accountable to and based on the labour movement, which would take decisive measures against capitalist power and privilege, Immediately, we called for the labour movement to break off all allahanation with tha Taru anuarn collaboral The smute en PART democracy had to be extended to a wholesale renovation of the labour movement. In particular, the struggle for democracy had to be taken into the trade unions - for all the left's victories relied on a temporary and fragile alliance with the trade union bureaucrats annoyed by the Labour government's treatment of them in 1976-9 - and "we must rearm the movement with real socialist policies at the same time as we fight for democracy"

"The victories so far are formal" we warned. *They must be filled out with the content of working class struggle if the movement is to be regenerated. A 'democratised" labour movement will become a fighting organisation of the workers, hammering at the Tories and their backers, or it will quickly fall again under the control of the bureaucrats and timeservers" -who would use witch-hunts to help them neutralise the democratic reforms.

That is indeed what happened. In December 1981 Michael Foot marked the start of the counter-offensive with a denunciation of the left-wing labour candidate for the then forthcoming Bermondsey by-election, Peter Tatchell. In January 1982 the Labour Party and TU leaders met in conclave at Bishops Stortford, and agreed a programme of restabilisation.

A witch-hunt was launched against Militant - not because they were dangerous (they had been passengers in the RFMC, no more), but because they were an easy target to use to frighten the whole left.

Sior Party as bem one, ince then the restoration of Labour Party has been slow, faltering, laborious, but apparently inexorable. Why? How did the left lose the advantage?

There were four main reasons. • Lack of rank and file movement in the unions The rank and file movement in the Labour Party was unable to link up with a rank-and-file movement in the trade unions. The lack of linkage in 1970-4 when vigorous rank-and-file groupings in the trade unions were unable to make any links into the Labour Party was repeated in reverse.

----- pull-quotes -----

borrowed from the Marxists of Lenin's day. But did that amount to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 444

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →