Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Behind the ANC torture scandal

Socialist Organiser no. 444, 19 April 1990 · scan p. 5 · about 749 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

The African National Congress tortures, beats and kills dissidents within its own ranks.

That is the allegation being made against the ANC by five former members of its armed wing, Umkhonto we Sizwe (MK). Nelson Mandela has confirmed that many of the allegations are true.

According to a report in last Sunday's Correspondent (April 8) the five, Simla Molefe, Jacki Molefe, Ronnie Masango, Luvo Mbergo and Amos Maxonga, and many other ANC dissidents, have faced:

• Beatings • Various forms of torture including 'kulukudu' in which prisoners are kept in underground containers exposed to the full heat of the African sun • 'Daily bread' in which prisoners were forced to lie with their faces flat on a cement floor while officers in heavy army boots jumped up and down on their skulls • 'Slaughter' , where officers made inmates stand straight against a wall with their eyes open as they hurled rocks at their faces •Testicle strangulation All these punishments were visited on critical MK members at a punishment and "re-education" centre nicknamed "Siberia" by the jailers.

The dissidents were being punished for a mutiny which spread across MK's Angolan camps in 1984 and involved up to 90% of the movement's fighters in the country.

The ANC rebels wanted MK to concentrate on the guerrilla struggle in South Africa rather than the war in Angola. Many were also critical of the flamboyant lifestyle of the ANC's exile leadership, a lifestyle in stark contrast to the squalid conditions of many MK camps in the frontline states.

MK has never been free from infiltration by the South African secret service. These revelations come at a very difficult time for the ANC, as the movement's leadership prepares to enter "pre-negotiations" with the regime and Mandela is about to visit Britain.

Nevertheless, it would be wrong for left-wingers to try to sweep the allegations briskly under the carpet.

The treatment of these dissidents should be seen as part of a more general pattern.

The ANC and ANC sympathisers in the liberation movement have in the past been ready to use physical violence or the threats of physical violence against left wing dissidents in the mass movement.

It should therefore come as no surprise that the MK leadership should be prepared to behave so brutally towards dissidents within their own ranks.

But why?

MK is seen by many black South Africans as a liberation army, and it is a genuinely popular expression of resistance to the hated apartheid regime. Through the "70s and '80s, militant black youth sought to join MK as the most effective way of fighting the regime.

However, MK is more than merely a symbol of black rebellion. It is a military and political organisation with very definite aims and functions.

The kind of armed struggle' that MK is engaged in — the struggle of an elite divorced from the mass of black workers - necessitates a high degree of military discipline. If there are no democratic channels within the broader political movement to raise the kind of criticisms the rebels had, and there appears to have been none, then this military discipline simply becomes a weapon for suppressing dissent. Brutally and bloodily if needs be.

ANC strategies have traditionally defined a dual role for MK. It is both a guerilla elite, vanguard in a broaker "people's war" , and the basic component of a new police force in a liberated South Africa. To perform this second function it is vital that MK remains unified, disciplined and free from internal disruption.

According to this reasoning, dissent can no more be tolerated 'within the ranks of MK than De Klerk could tolerate dissent in the SADF or SAP.

How MK functions as part of the security forces of the post-apartheid state will be shaped by the class interests that state defends. It is already clear that the central ANC leadership seek a partnership with big capitalist and the mine owners in the shape of the Anglo-American corporation. Already both Winnie Mandela and the Communist Party's Joe Slovo have dubbed the Anglo-American bosses "patriotic businessmen of good faith".

If MK are to defend such a political settlement they may well find themselves in brutal and bloody conflict with black workers who seek economic and social as well as political emancipation.

The five dissidents say they still support the "political" AN and Nelson Mandela in particular. To clear the movement's name, Mandela should help organise an open and public inquiry into these allegations.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 444

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →