Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Name that source!

Socialist Organiser no. 444, 19 April 1990 · scan p. 3 · about 658 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Deutice, tierietola/rud gegen dir judide -chreuel To. honda Tati me bei Dcitiesen!

Germans defend

ourselves against jewish yony al berl aganda Scratte KITBOYCOTT Photos: Searchlight One unforseen result of the Strangeways prison seige was that Bill Goodwin was not sent to jail last week.

Mr Goodwin is a trainee journalist on The Engineer. Last November the High Court ordered him to reveal his source may be only a humble trainee on a relatively obscure trade magazine but he understood enough about the elementary ethics of journalism, to refuse.

He appealed unsuccessfully to the House of Lords and last Tuesday returned to the High Court, expecting to be sent down.

Three journalists this century have been jailed for contempt of court: Brendan Mulholland of the Daily Mail and Reginald Foster of the Daily Sketch, got six and three months respectively for refusing to name sources during the Vassall case of 1963; in 1971 Bernard Falk, the genial TV and radio presenter, spent four days in Crumlin Road prison after refusing to identify an IRA man he had interviewed.

Then came the 1981 Contempt of Court Act, Section 10 of which gives journalists the right to refuse to disclose sources... "unless it is established to the satisfaction of the court that disclosure is necessary in the interests of justice or national security, or for the prevention of disorder or crime."l That seems fair enough, doesn't it? In fact it wasn't very long at all before the judges seized upon the words that followed "unless..." to make mockery of Parliament's intentions.

The Sarah Tisdall case demonstrated once and for all the uselessness of the statutory protection supposedly COlE tained in Section 10. In 1983 The Guardian published excerpts from a leaked Ministry of Defence document and was promptly ordered to return it so that the source could be identified. on Section 10. In an extraordinary deci basing its case sion, the Court of Appeal ruled that although the publication of that particular document posed no threat to national security', the person who leaked was obviously untrustworthy and might leak more important documents the future. Guardian editor Peter Preston huffed and puffed about freedom of the press and searched his liberal conscience for about five minutes before capitulating. Sarah Tisdall got six months.

Fortunately, some journalists have shown more guts. Last year, The Independent's financial reporter Jeremy Warner was ordered to reveal his source for articles he's written about insider dealing. The High Court had ruled that Section 10 protection did not apply because disclosure was "necessary in the interests of justice" and "prevention of crime"

Such an interpretation would, of course, make it impossible to protect any sources in any article about any crime... Mr Warner stood his ground and was fined £20,000 with £100,000 costs.

The "interests of justice get out was used again by the Law Lords in turning down William Goodwin's appeal. This time a further imaginative twist was added by Lord Bridge who explained that "justice' could mean the wish of a private company to discipline a disloyal employee, "notwithstanding that no legal proceedings might be necessary to achieve this end' Taken together with the decisions reached by the learned judges in the Tisdall case and the Warner case, this amounts to a situation where journalists cannot legally protect any source in any article dealing with security matters, crime or the internal affairs of a private company. So much for investigative journalism.

Incidentally, The Engineer complied with 'Company X's injunction on Willian Goodwin's article, which was never published. No commercial damage was done. The only 'crime' in this case was the refusal to reveal SOUrCCS.

Even so, "Company X' wanted Goodwin sent down for six months, but Mr Justice Hoffman observed, "the prisons have enough problems without having to take otherwise to codin wat he 85,00 Mr Goodwin was €100,000 costs.

----- pull-quotes -----

of information about the commercial affairs of 'Company X'. Mr Goodwin

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 444

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →