Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

DNA fingerprint faults

Socialist Organiser no. 443, 12 April 1990 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 942 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

accused of a crime. Suppose the evidence against you were purely circumstantial but the police wanted to fingerprint' your DNA to match it with samples taken from the scene of the crime. You'd be happy to because it would clear your name — but would it?

So far, there have been по criticism of genetic fingerprinting evidence in Britain but in the US several cases have been thrown out of court on the grounds that DNA tests that are carried out by the commercial forensic DNA labs that have sprung up are not reliable. This raises a general problem of scientific evidence. However impeccable the theory behind a test, its results are only as reliable as the techniques used to obtain them. A case in point is that of the Birmcards. To avoid this possibility, the conditions of the test must be exactly right and this turns out to be part of the problem with the American DNA tests.

As we know, the discrediting of the forensic evidence against the Birmingham 6 has not resulted in their release. This is an aspect of another problem associated with scientific evidence. Quite often juries and judges are incapable of understanding the arguments about such evidence. Faced with a disagreement among 'experts' about the scienfific evidence, they may therefore fall back on their prejudices, all too often in favour of the prosecution.

So what's wrong with DNA twins). Analysing their DNA and comparing it with that found in a sample will definitely answer the Obviously current DNA fingerprinting involves some short cuts.

The present technique consists of "cutting' the DNA at certain points and separating the fragments on the basis of their size. The 'scissors' are types of enzyme made by bacteria as defence against infection by viruses. Called "restriction enzymes' these break the DNA at specific points.

Since everyone's DNA is different, the restriction enzymes Will cut at different points, making fragments of different sizes.

The resulting mixture of fragments is then put on one end of a length of gel. An electric field is applied and the fragments migrate towards the other end, the lighter ones going faster (the technique is called gel electrophoresis), Finally, a pattern of bands in the gel is obtained which is unique to that individual (with lan uncertain perhaps one part in ten billion).

So far, so good but the above represents the optimum case, with the carefully collected sample, with the restriction enzymes given the right temperatures, acidity and same strength each time. But some of the bands are very close together and can be confused if the electric field is slightly different. And sometimes the enzymes may not work as fast as usual, producing fewer bands. And what about using samples that have decayed or degraded in strong sunlight or are contaminated with bacteria or chemicals?

In a separate test of the reliability of the three US forensic DNA labs, two came up with false positives (ie samples were said to come from the same person when they didn't). The other lab was unable to decide in over a quarter of the samples sent in. These were hardly a striking vindication of the power of DNA fingerprinting it is a powerful and potentially very useful technique, particularly in establishing family relationships where these have been disputed but there is plenty of scope for tightening up procedure. admission, and the implied claim that he knew what he was doing, won't have done Field any good at all with the members of the Labour Party who saw his performance.

It was part of Newsnight's long report (4 April) on Frank Field's witch-hunt in the Wirral, which also included a brief account of Socialist Organiser.

It should have been obvious from the report - which included film of our editorial office and brief excerpts from an interview with the editor - that Socialist Organiser is no conspiracy, but an open labour movement newspaper.

Saturday-Sunday 19-20 May, at Sheffield PolyStudent Union, Pond Street. Registration fron 10am Saturday.

Credentials £10 (delegates from organisatione), E6 (waged individuals), or £3 (unwaged), from PO Box 118, Chesterfield, Derbyshire S44 SUD.

Scan page 11

ivists plan poll tax conference Constituency Labour Party activists are planning a conference, focused on organising against the poll tax and against witch-hunts within the Labour Party, for 23 June in London.

The date was set by a meeting of the Organising Committee of the Constituency Labour Parties Conference on 7 April in Wakefield. A full CLPs Conference was due to take place on that day, but had to be cancelled after the booking fee for Wakefield Town Hall was mysteriously, and at short notice, raised from nil to £400.

The CLPs Conference was launched from a fringe meeting at the Socialist Conference in 1988. It has held three delegate conferences, and scheduled for the North, in Wakefield, where local activists are confident of being able to sort out the problems on hall bookings given the extra time.

The Organising Committee was reluctant to break the tradition of meeting outside London, but recognised the force of other arguments. A venue was readily available in London, and following the forced cancellation of the Wakefield meeting, the CLPs Conference could not afford to wait or to take chances with new venues. London is a logical place for a congiven the exceptionally high rates or ference focused on the poll poll tax there. And, to increase the range of CLPs involved with the CLPs Conference, it is necessary to meet sometimes in the South.

The Organising Committee also

----- pull-quotes -----

testing? Each person's DNA is uni- que to them (apart for identical

Socialists Conference

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 443

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →