"Not only workers' liberty from Stalinism but also workers' liberty from capitalism"
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-04-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
RANT This pensioner is selling a few battered tins and a few pounds Jozef Pinior, a leading Polish socialist and anti-Stalinist, spoke Mark Catterall Our party comes from the Solidarity trade • union movement, most of the party leadership coming from clandestine Solidarity:
In 1987 we felt that now in Poland, it was necessary to build a left alternative, inside the workers movement - not only an alternative in the workplace, for workers' self-defence, but a project for the future. We tried to organise the Polish Socialist Party. Of course it is an experiment; as with every experiment, we have had problems.
In Poland Stalinism is at the crossroad. Stalinism has compromised all left traditions. Stalinism was a disaster for the workers' movement. Our socialist language was something new in the workers' movement.
But since 1987 a new generation of young workers, and students, have come to our left alternative, an alternative of workers' power and workers' self-management.
Inside the Polish Socialist Party (Democratic Revolution) (PSP-DR) there are a number of political currents. We want our party to be very democratic, with a lot of ideological and political currents. We have a Trotskyist current, close to the Mandel wing of the USFI, an open Trotskyist current, and a left social-democratic current. We want to discuss in our party, and build with all political currents in our party a new force which works for workers' liberty, not only workers' liberty from Stalinism, but also workers' liberty from capitalism.
At present we have a lot of problems in our party because of our differences over tactics and ideology.
I personally belong to an open Trotskyist current in our party. Our first difference is over tactics in party building. My current and the other Trotskyist current want to build our party through serious work inside the real existing workers' movement. For us the existing movement is the Solidarity trade union movement, in the first place rank and file Solidarity, Of course we oppose the existing Solidarity leadership. For us the existing leadership is classic bureaucratic reformist leadership. But we are close to the rank and file of Solidarity, and in my opinion it is wrong to try to build a new trade union outside Solidarity as others wish to do in the party.
Our second difference is over ideology. My current and the other Trotskyist current believe that the October Revolution was a workers" revolution. The members of our party in the left social-democratic current reject that tradition.
We have a lot of problems over this point and recently this has led to organisational problems inside the PSP-DR.
Secondly, our programme on the economy differs from that of the social-democratic current over market reforms. We reject tree market reforms. Our friends from the social-democratic current have a programme with free market reforms.
They also want a state without classes. For us that is irrational, and a fantasy.
Our programme on the economy looks to planning from below. We work for democracy and a self-governing society. Of course, we do not reject the market completely. We want to control the market by democratic control of the workers from below, of bruised apples to supplement his pension.
We reject the possibility of a state without classes. We fight for our future project, which, of course, is a self-governing society, a society with massive democracy where in the first place workers control society from below, and where eventually all of society democratically controls society.
"In Poland you a real existing old official trade the leadership bu My personal tradition is close to that of Rosa Luxemburg, not the tradition of the pre-World War I Polish Socialist Party of Pilsudski, and that is an important difference. 1 am personally close to the leftZimmerwald, Luxemburg, Trotskyist opposition tradition. There are deep differences in tradition inside the PSP, with others closer to the classic social-democratic tradition.
I am very afraid of following the road of a sect. There are a lot of revolutionary sects in the world, with a good ideological platform, but without any relation to the mass existing workers' movement, and, it is a sad situation.
I think that now in Poland and the Eastern Bloc it is time to build a new workers' movement. Workers need alternatives because of the IMF measures which attack workers living standards.
Workers and most of society must defend themselves against these attacks. Now is the time for building an alternative, a new To me a very interesting model for a political party is the Braziliar PT (Workers' Party). For me, a workers' party must have freedom for all political currents, freedom of discussion for ideological left currents inside the party. A party must fight for democracy as a key to socialism. In my opinion democracy is a key to socialism. You must have democracy inside your political party, you must have discussion, you must have debate.
In Poland it is time now for building this kind of party. This political party must represent workers' real interests. It must have a good relationship with rank and file Solidarity.
In Poland you have a real existing workers movement, not in the OPZZ (the old official trade unions), but in Solidarity — not in the leadership but in every factory and factory commission.
There is a danger of having a sectarian platform in relationship to Solidarity. Because we reject the Solidarity leadership, it can become easy to reject all of the Solidarity movement. That is a sectarian way.
We must work inside rank and file Solidarity, build a new left alternative for workers' liberty inside this movement and, from the best workers' consciousness, build a workers' party that represents workers' interests.
Miners went on strike in January and while on strike they rejected the Solidarity bureaucracy. Now in Solidarity there are elections leading up to the Solidarity Congress and in these elections the radical wing of Solidarity is having some success.
For me this is good news. It proves it is democracy inside this moveme for My plan for Solidarity? In the first place support every strike, support workers fighting. Secondly, support the fight for deep democracy inside Solidarity and organise for free elections to reject the bureaucracy.
Of course it is not easy, but we must fight for the fate of the workers' movement.
You must remember that the Walesa leadership is a very bureaucratic reformist leadership under the influence of Western proPranda, with a lot of illusions in market reform and the possibility of capitalism with a human face. anti-semitism) both on a Polish level and on an Eastern in the West"
On the other hand this bureaucracy is very new and not that strong. It is possible to fight the bureaucracy and to put forward a workers' platform.
In my personal opinion the rise of the right is a danger, not only in Poland, but in all the Eastern Bloc.
You have a very deep frustration, with a very deep economic crisis. In this situation you have a lot of right wing groups - not only liberal right wing, but also a strong authoritarian right wing.
ror example, in Poland we have a problem with a very chauvinistic group. It is a marginal group, with its anti-semitic and racist slogans. But it is a danger for the future. As we see the results of the IMF/ Solidarity austerity measures, these groups can grow. The PSP-DR fight against these groups.
A few months ago we condemned an anti-semitic statement by Cardinal Glemp and recently we helped protect African students from physical attack in Wroclaw by "Nazi Front' skinheads.
We have relations with the antiracist movement in Europe, eg. SOS-Racisme in France. We want to organise a campaign against chauvinism and racism (including anti-semitism) both on a Polish level and on an Eastern Europe level, linking with such campaigns in the West.
As for German unity — personally, i thin that Germany as a nation has a rit to determine its own future. Within the process of reunification we support the workers' movement in the East and West.
We support and have links with the 'United Left' in East Germany.
Our project is for a United Socialist States of Europe. We must defend workers against reunification with nationalistic slogans. We must support those in Germany who are fighting for a United Socialist States of Europe.
We struggle for a Europe without armies, a Europe with complete disarmament. We want a Europe with workers' liberty east and west.
We must have a close relationship to the comrades in Germany, we must reject completely nationalist platforms against Germany. Both the Stalinists and nationalists in Poland have positions against Germany. Many ordinary Poles agree with them.
In my opinion the breakdown of Stalinism means it is time to build a new international consciousness, a new workers' movement in Eastern Europe. It is a time to look for new roads to the future. We have good relations with the new left in Eastern Europe. Personally I have a good relationship with my friend Petr Uhl of the Czech Civic Forum and Left Alternative, who I have just heard has become a top civil Turn to page
Scan page 9
hat's in the coffin at the nat's in ine cottin neral of socialism? servant in Prague.
During the time of clandestine work, for a number of years, we would meet in the mountains. In 1987 we organised a Polish/Czech solidarity committee. It called for a legal open opposition in Poland and "But you must provide British and Western European socialists with information about our struggle, our fight. Build solidarit) with our fight. Tell British workers about all currents the Polish labour movement, they all have something to A couple of months ago Lvisited Petr in Prague. We discussed the need for the left to discuss political and ideological questions. For a number of years we have had contact, first in clandestinity and now in the open with a Trotskyist group in East Germany under the leadership of Herbert Misslitz.
Also we have contacts with Boris Kagarlitsky's group in the USSR Anti-semitic graffiti in Warsaw and a small left group in Hungary. We take these contacts seriously and wish to deepen our discussions with Eastern European socialists.
When I spoke of the need to build a new international consciousness, I was thinking not just a solidarity platform for Eastern Bloc socialists, but for a Western and Eastern European platform. Naturally we are all part of one Europe and one world.
We must build a relationship between East and West through conferences, meetings, and visits, etc. We need to develop ideas through papers and discussions and perhaps in the future this new international consciousness will help build a new socialist organisation which will go further than Solidarity.
We in Poland try to inform Polish workers through our press about the lives and struggles of Western European workers, and Latin America workers and where possible to support those struggles.
Every labour movement success in Western Europe is a success for our movement. Every successful battle against Thatcher's government provides us with strength.
But you must provide British and Western European socialists with information about our struggle, our fight. Build solidarity with our fight. Tell British workers about all currents in the Polish labour movement, they all have something to Support our fight for socialism. Together we can build a new international consciousness. Together we can use the chance provided by the near collapse of Stalinism to change Europe. • Since this interview was done, the PSP-DR has split, and Jozef Pinior and his comrades have set up a new group, the Socialist Political Centre. Prague 1968, TIDE Bourgeois propagandists Bas that se me sate tell us that we are witnessing the end of socialism.
Socialism is dying of shame, failure and self-disgust before our eyes in Eastern Europe. Socialism has been tried and is now deservedly rejected as an all-round social and historical failure.
It is rejected most explicitly by the working class who. for example, gave the right the bulk of its vote in last month's East German election.
The workers want capitalism, and socialism, "history's great dream" - so bourgeois and exsocialist propagandists alike say — goes the way of other ignorant yearnings and strivings, taking its place in the museum quackery alongside such relics of barbarism as alchemy.
For sixty and more years, "socialism" , in common discourse, has been what existed in the USSR. The ideas conveyed by the words socialism and communism before Stalin established his system sixty years ago faded into the mists of pre-history, and "socialism" came to be the theory and practice of Stalinism — what became known in the 70s_ as "actually existing socialism"
That was "socialism". There has been no other socialism (unless some fool wants to cite Western "democratic socialism" , Sweden tor example.
And yes, it is this "actually existing socialism" that is ceasing to exist, melting like islands of ice in the warm seas of international capitalism. And yes, its enemies are the very working class in whose name the "socialist" states claimed their historic legitimacy.
So much for "socialism", "actually existing socialism". But for the socialism of Marx, Engels, Lenin, Trotsky, Luxemburg and Gramsci, it is a good thing that millions of people in Eastern Europe and in the Soviet Union have risen in revolt against "socialism" and "communism" In fact it is the best thing that has happened for socialists in fully half a century.
The fact. that those millions hate and despise socialism" is the best pledge we could have that socialism has a future, that socialism is indeed the "wave of the future"
"This becomes clear when you ask yourself the question: what have the workers revolted against when they revolted against "socialism""? What has been proved or disproved by the indisputable failure of the Stalinist system?
The workers and others revolted against: • National oppression by the USSR and within the USSR. • Subordination of individuals, social groups, and nations to an all-powerful regulating state through which a bureaucratic ruling class exercised its dictatorship. • The denial of free speech, free press, free assembly, free organisa tion. • Exploitation and poverty, combined with outrageous privilege.
They want instead: • National and individual freedom. • Democracy, • Prosperity and equality — an end, at least, to the peculiarly glaring sort of inequality imposed on the Eastern Bloc by bureaucratic privilege.
That the workers think they can get these things, or get more of them, under a market system, is very important, and it determines what happens now, but it is not the whole story. It is not even the gist of the story. And it is not the end but the beginning of the chapter that opened in the East last autumn.
And what has the failure of Stalinist "socialism" proved? That rigidly bureaucratic systems, where all power, decisions, initiative and resources are concentrated in the hands of the state, cannot plan their economies ettectively. No Marxist ever believed they could.
That the workers become alienated when a supposed "workers' state" actually means rule over them by privileged That socialismis impossible without freedom and democracy, without free initiative and comprehensive self-rule.
That socialism is impossible when the socialists set out to develop backward national economies, rather than the working class seizing power on the basis of the technology created by advanced capitalism and beginning with equality and freedom.
Eastern Europe proves all these things. But then its evidence vindicates, rather than disproves, he ideal of Karl Marx.
Marx argued that socialism would grow out of advanced capitalism, which had developed the means of production far enough that want could be abolished almost immediately; that socialism would be the creation of the mass of the people, led by the working class, and, by definition, therefore, democratic; and that socialism would immediately destroy the bureaucratic state machine, substituting an accountable system of working-class administration.
What came to be known as "socialism", and in fact was the "actually existing socialism" , was never socialism. | Lenin and Trotsks did not believe that socialism was possible in the backward Tsarist empire. What they believed wasthat the workers could take power there, and make the first in a chain of revolutions that would reach the advanced countries where socialism was possible.
The revolutions in Western Europe were betrayed and defeated. In isolation, the Stalinist mutation, a new form of class society with collective property, emerged by way of a bloody one-sided civil war against the workers of the USSR, led by the genuine Marxists, Trotsky and his comrades. After World War 2 it spread.
Stalinism was never socialism. But the revolt against it is socialism in embryo — the mass self-assertion and revolt of millions of people is the raw material of socialism.
It would be a true miracle if the workers in the Stalinist countries had political clarity after years in darkness. It would be remarkable if they were not confused by the official "socialism" which meant tyranny and poverty, and by the capitalism of Western Europe which means comparative prosperity and liberty.
What they are gaining now is the freedom to think, to organise, the freedom to struggle and marr from their struggle ol - the first steps toward ilisn"- independeni workers organisations, parties, and trade unions — will emerge again in countries in which History did indeed seem to have ended in hell forty or more years ago. In the East, working-class history has begun again, Working classes which fail to shape their own history sometimes get a second chance - in the first place the chance to learn from and not repeat that history.
"Socialism' is dead; socialism!
----- pull-quotes -----
workers' movement, not in the OPZZ (the
unions), but in Solidarity — not
every factory factory commission".
«We want to organise a campaign against chauvinism and racism (including
Europe level, linking with such campaigns
liberty From page 5