Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Witch-hunt in NUS

Socialist Organiser no. 443, 12 April 1990 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 2,061 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

By Paul McGarry. NUS executive member, in personal capacity The witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser is hotting up. And not just inside the By the end of last week's conference of the National Union of Students, the whole of the NUS right was rallying to attack Socialist Organiser. By the last day we were being verbally spat at every ten minutes - from the platform as well as from the rostrum.

The assault was led by the ragbag of right-wing 'independents' who had lost elections to Left Unity supporters who are also supporters of Socialist Organiser. They did not ask themselves why the majority of conference delegates had backed Left Unity - against them - in an open, fair, democratic election by single transferable vote. They just hurled abuse.

It was all pretty crass. Being called "a pile of shit" by the tiny rump Communist Party would be laughable if it were not the dying cry of an organisation which for decades has covered for a series of Soviet dictators who destroyed the lives of millions.

There was no

Scan page 6

revolution even if there appear to be some ANNETT SEESE: Until October You have to take, into account 1989, the German Federation of Democracy: Wall outside CP headquarters Prague, December waves that preceded the round The following table" accords, the working class discussion on the was not divided and constituted a bloc against the bureucracy. After working class in the the "round table" accords, the GDR, Poland and working class divided into two - a group supporting Walesa and his Hungary was political line, and another organised by Inprecor demonstrating in the street. a socialist bi-weekly the application of the austerit! published in Paris. measures of the new Mazowieck government, this second group has The participants: also split in two.

Annett Seese, an East decided to cooperate again with German student and a Walesa so as to maintain the unity member of the United of the working class. But, to the ex- tent that the leadership of SolidarLeft in Leipzig; Milka. nosc has put itself to work with the enemies of yesterday, the Polish Tyszkiewicz, from United Workers' Party (PZPR) and Poland, a member of the Socialist Political Centre in Wroclaw; and Laszlo Andor, a Hungarian economist and a member of the groups remain marginal.

Left Alternative.

That has been the attitude of the working class towards the recent events in Eastern Europe?

ANNETT SEESE: The first problem in the GDR is that the movement did not start from the working class, but has been a movement of perienced as such. It is thus difficult the entire people, and has been ex- resonance. to speak of a specific attitude of the working class.

There was certainly an important working class participation but the working class was not there as a specific social category. Strikes only began much later, in the form of "warning strikes" • But these consisted of walk-outs - the workers would leave their factories, express their demands, then return to work, workers.

even working extra hours to make up for those that had been "lost"

MILKA TYSZKIEWICZ: As you nonetheless necessary.

know, for the majority of the Polish working class, the market has become a kind of universal alternative to self-management, te socialism. In the consciousness of the workers, the very wore "socialism' has becom synonymous with Stalinism.

In the spring of 1988 and thi similarities.

summer of 1989, during the strik MIKES L THA A POSLEERNI kuleme 1989 There the attitude of the workers in relation to what is called in Hungary the PT, the "peaceful transition" ...towards the restoration of capitalism! Because the PT is very much on the order of the day in Hungary. This state of mind is the result of the history of the past decades -During the last five months, after the dramatic level of the country's debt, the worsening of the exploitation of the workers, the fall in their standard of living and their real salaries. The workers, then, react A first group, very radical, has very violently to all that they consider as being the cause of this. growing economic and social crisis. 1989 was a year of great hopes and illusions for the working class and the whole of society. After 40 years of Stalinist dictatorship, very much was expected of pluralism -Jaruzelski, the notion of the "com- and the market - which were supmon enemy to overthrow" has posed to resolve all the problems. disappeared and certain members There was a tremendous euphoria, of this group have begun to speak a tremendous optimism. of fascism as the only alternative That said, all this happened which can resolve the political without the effective participation crisis. They have started to demand of the workers. The new parties "guillotines" to "cut off the heads were founded without any base in of all the leftists" ...That said, these the workers' movement.

A first disillusionment came There exists also among the when it was revealed that the new working class a great interest in parties were not noticeably better everything that happens in the than the old single party and their neighbouring countries, notably in leaders were not particularly more the Baltic states (a part of these intelligent! It is possible to distinguish three belonged to Poland before the Se- regions, for example in Lithuania, kinds of attitude in response to this.

Firstly, among certain workers, a cond World War). The debate on in Czechoslovakia and in Rumania German reunification, the uprising rejection of all this political show, of pluralism and so on, and a total have also had a very deep demobilisation. The second group could be tempted to vote for the right, under the influence of the that of the necessity of preserving An idea which is very present is mass media which repeats day in and day out that socialism Some of the government's measures national independence at all costs. represents a shameful episode in have been rejected by the workers our history, that the USSR has because they could imperil in- played an ignoble role in Hungary, dependence, through the sale of and so on.

Polish factories to foreigners. For workers, amongst the most con- And, finally, a small minority of management has also begun to regain an audience amongst the these same reasons, the idea of sell- trade unions, and the little parties scious, in the workers' councils, the of the left - and also the bine this will for independence with But the problem is how to com- the Socialist Workers Party (HSWP), the two wings coming out Hungarian Socialist Party (HSP) or links with the West, believed to be of the split in the old Communist Party in power - who are going to LASZLO ANDOR: So far as the oppose this peaceful transition. attitude of the Hungarian working class during the recent events is con- What are the forms of organisation cerned, it is necessary first to make of the working class today, and its it clear that the situation is not at all attitude to the structures already in the same as in the other countries, place?

ABY JAKO DŘIVE TRPĚLY Free only existing trade union organisation.

All workers were de facto members of it. It was not then a trade union of militants. Official propaganda pretended that property was collective and that the means of production belonged to everyone. But the people did not see things in that way.

The FDGB profited very much from its privileged links with the West German trade unions which, in certain circumstances, lavished financial aid upon it.

Beginning in October, a reform movement began at the base of the FDGB to make it a genuine trade union. Other worker militants were of the opinion that the FDGB was not reformable, that the apparatus could not be remodelled and that it was thus necessary to aim towards the creation of independent unions.

But the independent unions have remained very much in a minority and exist only in certain cities, like for example Berlin. On the other hand, in Leipzig, in certain small enterprises, workers have begun to put into practice forms of selfmanagement outside of any struc ture of the trade union or workers' council type.

Moreover, in addition to the traditional unions with elements of self-reform and the small independent unions, there exist three varieties of workers' councils. The first, very much in a minority, considers workers' councils struments for the implementation of a genuine self-management. A second variant, of which I have already spoken, is based on the involvement of the workers in production, on the West German model. The third advocates representation of the workers amongst management.

During its recent congress, the FDGB adopted a very radical language — quasi revolutionary! -in defence of the workers and their trade union rights. But it is hard to know if this will be followed through and if it still has enough of a genuine base to put its words into practice.

MILKA TYSZKIEWICZ: A multitude of workers' organisations exist today in Poland and the situation can be summarised in the well known witticism - every time two Poles meet, three organisations are founded...and there are 35 million Poles!!

Leaving aside the Stalinist organisations or those linked to the Church, I will content myself with speaking briefly about some of the organisations linked to Solidarnosc or to the clandestine activities of the working class in the 1980s.

Solidarnosc was originally a mass organisation with, roughly, one single type of membership. Today, a series of little organisations exist having very complicated structures.

Solidarnoss now has nearly two million members, with two structures at the national level.

The first is a vertical structure, bureaucratic, led by Lech Walesa.

It supports totally the Balcerowicz plan and the retorms of the Plazo wiecki goverement.

The second is a horizontal structure of the different industrial sectors. Today, there are 25 structures of this type organised at the base by the workers.

This problem is very intimately linked to the workers" conAn image of liberty from France's reve sciousness, or in any case that of the members of Solidarnosc. At first, everybody was favour of capitalist "laissez-faire" but when people saw that it had become difficult to find work, when they had tasted the popular soup of Mr Kuron and when they had seen the real nature of the paradise which they had expected, they began to organise themselves.

Thus, in my region, the enterprise-based trade unions used to pass on 25% of the dues of their members to the regional structures - recently, they have decided to reduce this proportion to 10% and keep the rest for their own expenses. The majority of this sum is henceforth to be devoted to these horizontal structures. There also exist regional territorial structures, the networks. These are essentially groups from different enterprises in the same city or region who coordinate together for local activities.

Some clandestine structures of Solidarnosc continue still to functioin at the regional level, with regional strike committees. The majority of their members belong also to the legal trade union, but maintain their clandestine structures, their equipment, and so on.

I must also mention "Fighting Solidarnosc" , another clandestine organisation, which is half way between a classical trade union and a political organisation. Politically, "Fighting Solidarnosc" can be placed in the social democratic current - initially, under martial law, it had a radical enough programme on self-management, then it veered to the right.

Another interesting fact is that, since nearly a year ago, a trade union of sectors of the army and, more recently, a police trade union have begun to organise themselves.

There is also a structure of Solidarnosc of small peasant proprietors which also organises the agricultural workers on state farms.

They are very radical and are almost nostalgic for the good old days of Stalinism when their living conditions were not as bad...

I must also mention the Committees of Citizens of Solidarnosc, which are political structures set up before the parliamentary elections.

They bring together both factory workers and sections of the intelligentsia and envisage transforming themselves into political parties.

But the level of political consciousness of the working class, as

----- pull-quotes -----

class and thi democratic

JIS NECHCEME,

DĚM 2A PRESVEDYENI RODIKŮ Trade Unions (FDGB) was the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 443

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →