Splitting, bureaucracy, grassing
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-04-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Chris Barnes accuses SO of caring if this leads to the failure of the whole campaign.
This is nonsense. SO has consistently argued for a united campaign — involving both the organised labour movement and community groups; our supporters have participated in building local groups, and argued successfully in union branches for non-implementation since the early days of the anti-poll tax movement.
We say that it is the bureaucratic approach of Militant that will lead to any split in the campaign. There are two major problems with the Militant Tendency's regime in the Anti-Poll Tax Federation.
Orgunisutionally, the Militant are as bad as ever. The Labour Party Young Socialists was run by the Militant from 1969/70. Minorities in the LPYS had no access to the LYS's press; no rights for minority status (through STV elections) on committees; no rights to debate at LYS events. It was in the LPYS that the Militant learnt that the best way to whip into line your troops is to give out the line as "recommendations" from the platform, before any vote. All these techniques were adopted at the November 25 Anti-Poll Tax Federation founding conference.
Indeed, the whole event was run as a Militant rally: take the debate on motions that anti-poll tax unions had bothered to discuss and send to the conference. This was interrupted - without any consultation with the delegates on the conference floor - so that Tony Mulhearn, Militant surcharged Liverpool City Councillor could make a plea for financial support for the councillors. Not that we don't support the councillors, but the blatant disregard for the conference business shows what contempt Militant show for debate and discussion. And Mulhearn was granted 15 minutes - five times longer than any ordinary delegate to the conference.
Just like the LPYS, the Militant Tendency utterly dominate the formal structures of the Anti-Poll Tax campaign (12 out of 15 places) and then ignore the structures. All the decisions are made elsewhere — by Militant committees.
It is quite true that the Militant have done a lot of work on the poll tax, and are a big "current of opinion", so would have a big say in any poll tax campaign. But I defy anyone to tell me that they have not been packing meetings, setting up HIrE VU TAX Don't pay, don't collect 'front' anti-poll tax unions, and local federations — often as rivals to already existing democratic groups or federations - to grab hold of the committee structure of poll tax campaigns. There are plenty of reports of such activity from all round the country.
Politically the Militant bent their stick so far towards mass non-payment and away from non-implementation that the stick broke long ago. Indeed, one Militant supporter recently argued at a local meeting that it would be sectarian to be involved in the Labour Party at this time!
Of course, any campaign, whatever, its politics, would find the council meetings which set poll tax rates good focuses for demonstrations. I don't see that this tells you anything about the politics of the campaign.
It is a fact that Militant have done very little in the unions. In NALGO, the key union in regard to the poll tax, it was not the Militantcontrolled Broad Left which has set the pace on the issue, but a coalition of branches led by non-Militant people, many of whom are sceptical about the Broad Left and Militant.
The Federation has at last decided to call a trade union conference in June. But, they have only done this after being approached by the Socialist Movement Trade Union Committee which originally floated the idea at a 500-strong delegate based conference of trade unionists six months ago.
The Militant of the officers Federation have not replied to any communication from the Socialist Movement on this issue, including an appeal from Tony Benn. Instead they have stolen the idea.
There is little reason to believe that a conference organised by the Militant office holders will be little more than a Militant rally.
Chris argues that Militant ignore the trade unions. But he doesn't ask himself why. The reason is simple:
Militant's obsessive focus on non-payment reinforces the illusion that on its own direct action community resistance will be sufficient to defeat the tax. Militant's fixation with non-payment has led them to adopt an extremely sectarian posture towards honest trade unionists who could be won to a policy of non-implementation but who have doubts and reservations about non-payment.
The basic fact still remains that unless the anti-poll tax campaign takes the struggle into the trade unions the mass non-payment movement will be easily isolated. The maximum force for smashing the poll tax will not be mobilised.
Militant have taken control of the anti-poll tax campaign to suck up as many recruits as possible, 'processing' them speak the three sentences of Militant gobbledegook that are necessary for 'supporter" status and are believed to contain the basics of Marxism.
For our part we cannot step back from criticising what is wrong in our movement. For example, we refuse to support — and are right to criticise - the likes of Steve Nally and Tommy Sheridan (both Militant supporters) when they promise to witch-hunt members of the Federation and "name names" of demonstrators on the March 31 demonstration — to name names, in effect, to the police. We think that this sort of class collaboration — or can Chris Barnes think of a better name for it? "Reformist grassing" perhaps — is more likely to split and confuse the campaign!
And demands such as demanding a recall poll tax conference; organising regional committees and conferences to hold the National Committee's regional reps to account are bound to bring us into further conflict with the Militant. Militant have never been prepared to tolerate opponents or competitors. We would be serving the anti-poll tax movement badly if we didn't try to prepare it for the bureaucratic methods Militant will apply in the future, as they have in the past.
Murphy
Scan page 5
(Sheffield Universit Student Union Executive and NUS Lesbian and Gay Committee, in a NU WOMEN'S EYE By Liz Millward When is a feminist
----- pull-quotes -----
2OL ТАЛ- collect TORY TAX Don'T collect